rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

LSJ- Antonio d'Erlette

11 messages from 8 participants · 29 November 2006 – 04 December 2006
original thread on Google Groups

XZealot

Antonio d'Erlette Clan: Tremere antitribu (group 4) Capacity: 5 Disciplines: THA dom for pot Sabbat: While Antonio is ready, you may spend four transfers to search your hand or library (shuffle afterward) for a mage ally Antonio could play. Put that ally in play with life equal to his starting amount (pay cost as normal). Charisma Type: Master Unique master. Put this card on a ready vampire. This vampire's recruit ally actions cost 1 less blood or pool (but never less than 0 blood or pool). If I have Charisma on Antioio d'Erlette and use his special to put an mage ally in play, is the cost reduced by 1 as per Charisma's text? Comments Welcome, Norman S. Brown, Jr XZealot Archon of the Swamp

oriang...@aliceadsl.fr

Nope, it's not a recruit action but "put that ally in play" [ quoted text not captured ]

XZealot

oriang...@aliceadsl.fr wrote: > Nope, it's not a recruit action but "put that ally in play" Is that you Scott? You are posting from a odd email address. [ quoted text not captured ]

Bram Vink

XZealot schreef: [ quoted text not captured ] The card text in this case is abundantly clear if you care to read it. He points out what you might've missed. What's with the comment? B

LSJ

[ quoted text not captured ] Correct. It is not an action, so it cannot be a recruit ally action.

XZealot

[ quoted text not captured ] I don't know who oriang...@sliceadsl.fr is. LSJ has multiple email accounts that he posts from. Is this a new account of his is what I was looking for. I am looking for an official answer from an official source to give to ex-magic players who have an artistic license with the English language. >What's with the comment? What comment? [ quoted text not captured ]

Azel

XZealot wrote: > I am looking for an official answer from an official source to give to > ex-magic players who have an artistic license with the English > language. oh god, i remember that disease. in fact, i think i get residual bouts of it from time to time. very infectious, and one of the less pleasant symptoms is pissy obstinacy. only treatment for a flare up was an official answer from an official source, kinda like preparation H and hemorrhoids.

Blooded Sand

On Dec 1, 5:36 am, Azel <opaop...@comcast.net> wrote: > XZealot wrote: > > I am looking for an official answer from an official source to give to > > ex-magic players who have an artistic license with the English > > language.oh god, i remember that disease. in fact, i think i get residual bouts > of it from time to time. very infectious, and one of the less pleasant > symptoms is pissy obstinacy. only treatment for a flare up was an > official answer from an official source, kinda like preparation H and > hemorrhoids. There is another answer of course: Smash their vamps repeatedly using the same kind of assinine argument, then bring the officiakl ruling, then explain to them WHY it's like that. This not only brings great pleasure ;p, but also forces them to think out of the MtG box. Which is a very narrow and consticting box, as it forces you to try and break everything, without truly understanding intent and wording

Frederick Scott

"XZealot" <xze...@cox.net> wrote in message news:1164844971.8...@j44g2000cwa.googlegroups.com... > > oriang...@aliceadsl.fr wrote: >> Nope, it's not a recruit action but "put that ally in play" > > Is that you Scott? You are posting from a odd email address. Usenet quirk: you may request a response from 'user X'. You may get a response from anybody. Not much you can do. It's not a terribly exclusive club, is it? Fred, normally wouldn't join any club that would have him

Blooded Sand

On Dec 2, 5:51 pm, "Frederick Scott" <nos...@no.spam.dot.com> wrote: > "XZealot" <xzea...@cox.net> wrote in messagenews:1164844971.8...@j44g2000cwa.googlegroups.com... > > > > > oriangiss...@aliceadsl.fr wrote: > >> Nope, it's not a recruit action but "put that ally in play" > > > Is that you Scott? You are posting from a odd email address. > Usenet quirk: you may request a response from 'user X'. You > may get a response from anybody. Not much you can do. It's not > a terribly exclusive club, is it? > > Fred, normally wouldn't join any club that would have him And then have some other loon ramble all over your response Blooded Sand, who loves clubs specifically for table splitters The kind with a big nail in them.....

atomweaver

"Frederick Scott" <nos...@no.spam.dot.com> wrote in news:eihch.2479 $Zb5....@newsfe13.phx: > Fred, normally wouldn't join any club that would have him > > For you, http://www.lorebrandcomics.com/amember.html Merry Christmas! DZ AW