VTES rules archive

Loving Agony and Catatonic Fear

12 messages from 8 participants · 31 January 2011 – 11 February 2011 · vekn.net/forum
the topic on the V:EKN forum

noir

I was wondering something here. Does the card 'Loving Agony' work similar to 'Catatonic fear' in that, that it causes the damage after combat, making it non-preventable? The reason I'm wondering is because they're worded quite different with one saying "combat ends and the opposing minion takes 1 damage." whilst the other say "...as above (combat ends) and inflict 1 damage to the opposing minion once combat ends, if the range is close". Loving Agony Cardtype: Combat Cost: 1 blood Discipline: Valeren/Animalism Only usable at close range. [ani] Strike: hand strike at +1 damage. [val] Strike: combat ends and the opposing minion takes 1 damage. [VAL] As [val] above, and this vampire may burn 1 blood to untap before combat ends. Catatonic Fear Cardtype: Combat Cost: 1 blood Discipline: Presence Strike: combat ends. As above, and inflict 1 damage to the opposing minion once combat ends if the range is close.

Pascal Bertrand

If some strike reads: "Strike: Combat ends, and do something", then something happens after combat. The only exception is when the strike reads "Combat ends and untap" (Majesty, Earth Meld, Loving Agony, ..), where the *this vampire untaps* part happens before the end of combat. So, yes, the damage from Loving Agony is similar to the damage from Catatonic Fear, vis-a-vis their timing. They are inflicted after combat, and can't be prevented with combat cards.

noir

Ah, as I thought then. Thanks for the reply

Baronofhilliard

There is a difference that I think is interesting. You can play target cards with LA while you can not play them with CF.

KevinM

> Baronofhilliard wrote: > There is a difference that I think is interesting. You can play target cards with LA while you can not play them with CF. > 'Target' cards are played when choosing a strike, which is during combat, so why can't you play them on CF? Kevin M., Prince of Las Vegas "Know your enemy and know yourself; in one-thousand battles you shall never be in peril." -- Sun Tzu, *The Art of War* "Contentment...Complacency...Catastrophe!" -- Joseph Chevalier Please visit VTESville daily! vtesville.myminicity.com/ Facebook: www.facebook.com/groups/129744447064017 Kevin M., Prince of Las Vegas "Know your enemy and know yourself; in one-thousand battles you shall never be in peril." -- Sun Tzu, *The Art of War* "Contentment...Complacency...Catastrophe!" -- Joseph Chevalier Please visit VTESville daily! vtesville.myminicity.com/ Facebook: www.facebook.com/groups/129744447064017

Baronofhilliard

Because LJS made a ruling that you can not use target vitals on CF. I believe there is a window there that is missed. One occurs immediately while the other is after combat.

Suoli

> Baronofhilliard wrote: > Because LJS made a ruling that you can not use target vitals on CF. I believe there is a window there that is missed. One occurs immediately while the other is after combat. > The latest ruling (from 2009) I can find indicates that T:V can be played on CF. groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/browse_thread/thread/a65aac793032049a/98f97bcf7182437b?q=catatonic+fear+target+vitals+author:lsj#98f97bcf7182437b

Juggernaut1981

> Loving Agony > Cardtype: Combat > Cost: 1 blood > Discipline: Valeren/Animalism > Only usable at close range. > [ani] Strike: hand strike at +1 damage. > [val] Strike: combat ends and the opposing minion takes 1 damage. > [VAL] As [val] above, and this vampire may burn 1 blood to untap before combat ends. > > Catatonic Fear > Cardtype: Combat > Cost: 1 blood > Discipline: Presence > Strike: combat ends. > As above, and inflict 1 damage to the opposing minion once combat ends if the range is close. > I would disagree with Floppy. Catatonic Fear has (at ) Strike: Combat ends, and inflict 1 damage to the opposing minion once combat ends if the range is close. Loving Agony has (at ) Strike: combat ends and the opposing minion takes 1 damage. Loving Agony does not have the comma "," between the Strike and the "and". So Loving Agony would work like Majesty (Strike: Combat Ends and untap this vampire) and deal the damage during combat which would make it preventable. At the effect, while separated by a comma, explicitly states its timing. LSJ has ruled that you can play Target Vitals on Catatonic Fear and it will deal the additional damage. Retired Baron of Sydney, Australia, 418

jhattara

Both cards work exactly the same way. The damage is done after combat. > LSJ wrote: > > > Brum wrote: > > IF there is an untap effect it goes before the end of combat. IF it is any other effect, it goes after combat. Right? > > > Precisely (also, all the untap effects have been rewritten so that their overriding of that default (after) is explicit. > AND > LSJ wrote: > > > felipechewbacca wrote: > > Can I play Target Vitals with Catatonic Fear? > > > Yes. > Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Baronofhilliard

I was thinking of Oubliette.

Adonai

> Baronofhilliard wrote: > I was thinking of Oubliette. > Target cards can be played with Oubliette. They have no effect when they rely on dealing damage, as damage is not done by Oubliette.

Baronofhilliard

> Adonai wrote: > > > Baronofhilliard wrote: > > I was thinking of Oubliette. > > > Target cards can be played with Oubliette. > > They have no effect when they rely on dealing damage, as damage is not done by Oubliette. > The point is that there would be no point since you burn a life and not take damage. You can play it as many other cards to get them from your hand.