rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

Franciscus 'takes damage' + Revelation of the Sire

8 messages from 7 participants · 19 August 2011 – 21 August 2011 · vekn.net/forum
the topic on the V:EKN forum

wumpus

Howdy, So Franciscus has been Revealed to be a !Salubri and Blooded by the Code, gaining Valeren (and +1 strength and cap 3). Question 1: His sect changed with his clan, yes? He's now Sabbat? He gets into combat and plays Armor of Caine's Fury and Trap before range. His opponent has no strike other than the default hand strike and no presses to end, but does have enough blood to survive long enough to hit Franciscus three times. Question 2: Was it a mistake for Franciscus to play the Trap? Is he going to burn, despite all the damage done to him being prevented? I think the answers are 1) Yes, he's Sabbat, and 2) Yes, he's going to burn. Thanks, Alex

Klaital

Yes he is sabbat, and no I don't think he burns, since if he prevented all the damage he didn't actually take any damage.

Pascal Bertrand

> wumpus wrote: > Howdy, > > So Franciscus has been Revealed to be a !Salubri and Blooded by the Code, gaining Valeren (and +1 strength and cap 3). > > Question 1: His sect changed with his clan, yes? He's now Sabbat? > Yes. When you change clan, you change your current sect to the default sect of the new clan. > wumpus wrote: > He gets into combat and plays Armor of Caine's Fury and Trap before range. His opponent has no strike other than the default hand strike and no presses to end, but does have enough blood to survive long enough to hit Franciscus three times. > > Question 2: Was it a mistake for Franciscus to play the Trap? Is he going to burn, despite all the damage done to him being prevented? > > I think the answers are 1) Yes, he's Sabbat, and 2) Yes, he's going to burn. > > Thanks, > Alex > "Prevented" damage isn't "taken". [LSJ 20021028] (this needs to be made clearer, eiter by definition of the word "taken" or by a cardtext update) So - I don't know if it was a mistake to play the Trap. Franciscus won't burn in this combat if all the damage inflicted to him is prevented.

Robert Scythe

Well, Franciscus wouldn't burn whether he prevented the damage or not, if he can survive the combat (must've been a trick question). > His opponent has no strike other than the default hand strike and no presses to end, but does have enough blood to survive long enough to hit Franciscus three times. >

Malachy

> Pascal wrote: > Yes. When you change clan, you change your current sect to the default sect of the new clan. > Sorry for being a little off-topic, but this needs to be re-posted With cards like Derange and Clan Impersonation one's current sect also changes? For example a prince gets Deranged by a !Malkavian she loses her sect therefore her title? NC of Hungary ///

Amenophobis

> Malachy wrote: > > > Pascal wrote: > > Yes. When you change clan, you change your current sect to the default sect of the new clan. > > > Sorry for being a little off-topic, but this needs to be re-posted With cards like Derange and Clan Impersonation one's current sect also changes? For example a prince gets Deranged by a !Malkavian she loses her sect therefore her title? > Yes, if you change clan, you change sect along with it. If you don't belong to the correct sect, your title (if any) goes inert as long as you are that sect. pckvtes.wordpress.com

Pascal Bertrand

> Malachy wrote: > > > Pascal wrote: > > Yes. When you change clan, you change your current sect to the default sect of the new clan. > > > Sorry for being a little off-topic, but this needs to be re-posted With cards like Derange and Clan Impersonation one's current sect also changes? For example a prince gets Deranged by a !Malkavian she loses her sect therefore her title? > The title will be recovered when the sect (and sometimes clan) is changed to appropriate. See more here: vekn.net/index.php/forum/6-rules-questions/7516-derange-titles-and-bloodbrothers

JediMike

> Well, Franciscus wouldn't burn whether he prevented the damage or not, if he can survive the combat (must've been a trick question). > > His opponent has no strike other than the default hand strike and no presses to end, but does have enough blood to survive long enough to hit Franciscus three times. > Franciscus [aus] Caitiff Capacity: 1 Group: 2 Camarilla: Franciscus is burned (without going into torpor) if he takes MORE THAN 3 damage during a single combat. Yup, trick question