VTES rules archive

Does Dabbler trigger on an ended action?

32 messages from 7 participants · 27 October 2026 – 31 October 2026 · vekn.net/forum
the topic on the V:EKN forum

Gr33n

During an action, a vampire with dabbler uses 3 disciplines. Change of target is played. Can dabbler trigger?

mipopo3

Dabbler Warning: Spoiler! Archetype. Trifle. Put this card on a vampire you control. Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards, this vampire can either burn 1 blood to unlock or gain 1 blood. A vampire can have only one archetype. Change of Target Warning: Spoiler! Only usable if this minion is blocked, before block resolution. Unlock this minion. The action ends (unsuccessfully). This minion cannot perform the same action again this turn. Action ended, not canceled, so "Yes", you get the blood.

mipopo3

So after Tangle Atropos' Hand Warning: Spoiler! Only usable if a minion attempts to block. Potence Cancel the action and unlock this vampire. (The action is not blocked. Do not lock the blocking minion.) Temporis As Potence above, and if an action card was played, take it back in your hand (discard down afterward). Superior Temporis As Temporis above, and this vampire gets +1 stealth during their next action this turn. You do not get the blood. ( or DI)

Gr33n

Contexto info: we discussed this in discord discord.com/channels/887471681277399091/1564324961592803358

Gr33n

What would you say against the following reasoning: Given that change of target has a ruling that no more action modifiers can be played during after action resolution and dabbler is an effect that triggers after action resolves, dabbler cant be used.

mipopo3

> Gr33n wrote: > What would you say against the following reasoning: > Given that change of target has a ruling that no more action modifiers can be played during after action resolution and dabbler is an effect that triggers after action resolves, dabbler cant be used. > Dabbler is not an action modifier. And the main text is: "Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved"

Gr33n

Dabbler not being an action modifier isn't a good enough argument in itself. "after an action is resolved" and "after action resolution" seem to be the same window. Actions that have ended before or during resolution do not allow playing "after action resolution" cards. For which reason would Dabbler being an optional effect allow it to be used when the action is no longer active? Daring the dawn has a ruling that the damage is still applied. Difference is that daring the dawn is a mandatory effect. Similar to how Outside the hourglass damage must resolve even if during the prevention window it opens, alpha glint ends the combat. Or an action ending due to sup Mirror walk still has the vampire burned from Millicent vampire hunter. Would be nice to know the official answer either way.

Ankha

> Gr33n wrote: > During an action, a vampire with dabbler uses 3 disciplines. > > Change of target is played. > > Can dabbler trigger? > Please include cardtext when asking a question about a card. Name: Dabbler Cardtype: Master Archetype. Trifle. Put this card on a vampire you control. Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards, this vampire can either burn 1 blood to unlock or gain 1 blood. A vampire can have only one archetype. The answer is: No. Once the action ends, you cannot use effects that are usable during a action. "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" happens after resolution of the action. This effect is not a delayed triggered effect that has to be resolved due to a previous condition met. > Gr33n wrote: > Dabbler not being an action modifier isn't a good enough argument in itself. > > "after an action is resolved" and "after action resolution" seem to be the same window. > Correct. Prince of Paris, France Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director

mipopo3

> Ankha wrote: > The answer is: No. Once the action ends, you cannot use effects that are usable during a action. "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" happens after resolution of the action. > Hi Anka, can you clarify this, as this looks to be a mixup with " Effects triggered when the action is blocked are still applied. RTR 19991206 " while "No other modifier or reaction can be played afterwards: the action has ended." is not apllyed to Master cards. LSJ 20010803-1 RTR 20180719 Note that the Change of target text in question is : "The action ends (unsuccessfully)" vs Dabbler "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" > mipopo3 wrote: > Dabbler > > Warning: Spoiler! > > Archetype. Trifle. > Put this card on a vampire you control. Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards, this vampire can either burn 1 blood to unlock or gain 1 blood. A vampire can have only one archetype. > > Change of Target > > Warning: Spoiler! > > Only usable if this minion is blocked, before block resolution. > Unlock this minion. The action ends (unsuccessfully). This minion cannot perform the same action again this turn. > > Action ended, not canceled, so "Yes", you get the blood. >

Ankha

> mipopo3 wrote: > > > Ankha wrote: > > The answer is: No. Once the action ends, you cannot use effects that are usable during a action. "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" happens after resolution of the action. > > > Hi Anka, can you clarify this, as this looks to be a mixup with "Effects triggered when the action is blocked are still applied. RTR 19991206 " > There's no such effect here. Nothing is triggered when the action is blocked. > mipopo3 wrote: > while "No other modifier or reaction can be played afterwards: the action has ended." is not apllyed to Master cards. > LSJ 20010803-1 > RTR 20180719 > > Note that the Change of target text in question is : > "The action ends (unsuccessfully)" > vs Dabbler > "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" > > Action ended, not canceled, so "Yes", you get the blood. > [/quote] This has nothing to do with the topic and doesn't apply here. Prince of Paris, France Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director

mipopo3

So, just to confirm, the "Dabbler" trigger, to get blood, will not trigger after "Change of target"?

Gr33n

Thank you Ankha. I will try to remember to add card text when asking questions. @mipopo3 Ankha already confirmed with a "No".

mipopo3

The wording on Dabbler indicates that there is no time limitation. You can do it in the Influence or Discard phase. ANK 20180719-4 Once more, this conflicts with current : > > Ankha wrote: > The answer is: No. Once the action ends, you cannot use effects that are usable during a action. "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" happens after resolution of the action. > > This effect is not a delayed triggered effect that has to be resolved due to a previous condition met. > . > As there is no time limit on Dabbler, the only limit is the turn end.

kschaefer

> mipopo3 wrote: > The wording on Dabbler indicates that there is no time limitation. > You can do it in the Influence or Discard phase. > ANK 20180719-4 > > Once more, this conflicts with current : > > > > Ankha wrote: > > The answer is: No. Once the action ends, you cannot use effects that are usable during a action. "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" happens after resolution of the action. > > > > This effect is not a delayed triggered effect that has to be resolved due to a previous condition met. > > . > > > As there is no time limit on Dabbler, the only limit is the turn end. > You need to read further into the sentence. "Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards..."

mipopo3

> kschaefer wrote: > Once each turn, after an action (successful or not)" > The "turn" is the time limit: the whole turn, untap, master, minion, influence, discard phases. Including your opponent's turn.(Madness Network, Enkil Cog,...)

kschaefer

> mipopo3 wrote: > > > kschaefer wrote: > > Once each turn, after an action (successful or not)" > > > The "turn" is the time limit: the whole turn, untap, master, minion, influence, discard phases. > Including your opponent's turn.(Madness Network, Enkil Cog,...) > Not enough eyeroll emojis for this response. You can be obtuse or you can read the card and understand how action timing works.

mipopo3

> kschaefer wrote: > Not enough eyeroll emojis for this response. You can be obtuse or you can read the card and understand how action timing works. > Do read before posting. ANK 20180719-4

Ankha

> mipopo3 wrote: > The wording on Dabbler indicates that there is no time limitation. > You can do it in the Influence or Discard phase. > ANK 20180719-4 > > Once more, this conflicts with current : > > > > Ankha wrote: > > The answer is: No. Once the action ends, you cannot use effects that are usable during a action. "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" happens after resolution of the action. > > > > This effect is not a delayed triggered effect that has to be resolved due to a previous condition met. > > . > > > As there is no time limit on Dabbler, the only limit is the turn end. > No. Read the whole topic and ruling again. Prince of Paris, France Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director

Bloodartist

I feel we have made mountains out of molehills in this topic. I also wonder whether Ankha either misread Dabbler or forgot how he has defined things in the past. 1. "Action ends" = "Action resolves unsuccessfully". If you play change of target on an action, the action cannot be attempted again. -> Action resolved. You can use dabbler just fine because the action reached resolution. The time window (whatever it is) is not in any way different from other ways of resolving an action, whether its successful resolution or action being blocked. 2. Yes, dabbler is not a delayed trigger. Dabbler is a "once per turn" effect that can be performed after an action has resolved (with conditions). 3. The wording of the timing window is technically the same as with freak drive, which is a card that can be played after action resolution. The difference is that freak drive is an action modifier, and thus must be played during an action. Same is not true for dabbler which is a master card. So this begs the question, can dabblers effect be used later in the turn (which is also "after action resolution") as long as its condition is met? If we read the cardtext as english language and not as defined rules phrases, I would say yes. ps. (not related to ruling in question) I would also like to point out for the umpteenth time that much of the confusion stems from using open-ended words such as "after" and "before" when defining timing windows. This is illogical and unintuitive and confuses players. It would be far simpler to use wording such as "effect happens/card is playable at the end of the action", in which case it would be clear that the effect must happen within the action, not next year which is also 'after' the action. If things would happen at the same time, then appropriate player could decide the order. Everything would be tidy. Smoking craters tell no tales. —Tex talks Battletech

mipopo3

> Ankha wrote: > No. Read the whole topic and ruling again. > This is in conflict with > > Ratadin wrote: > A turn start at the unlock phase of a player, and ends at the end of the discard phase of that player. >

KoRneeshon

> Bloodartist wrote: > Dabbler is a "once per turn" > No, it's "Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards", you cannot use it in your discard or transfer phase, you have to use it right after an action (successful or not) is resolved. The "once each turn" indicates you can use this effect only once per turn, not that you can use it at any point of the turn.

mipopo3

> KoRneeshon wrote: > No, it's "Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards", you cannot use it in your discard or transfer phase, you have to use it right after an action (successful or not) is resolved. The "once each turn" indicates you can use this effect only once per turn, not that you can use it at any point of the turn. > Core Rulebook: Action modifier cards: The acting minion can play these cards to modify their action at any time before action resolution. Dabbler: "Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved" There is no time restriction after action resolution; the only restriction is the end of the turn. There is no "in minion phase", "before untap"; there is no "after performing" restriction. The only condition to be met is: 1) 3 Disciplines were used (action can be successful or not, but not canceled). 2) The turn didn't end.

mipopo3

"EDIT" Duplice poste, sorry.

Hobbesgoblin

> mipopo3 wrote: > > > KoRneeshon wrote: > > No, it's "Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards", you cannot use it in your discard or transfer phase, you have to use it right after an action (successful or not) is resolved. The "once each turn" indicates you can use this effect only once per turn, not that you can use it at any point of the turn. > > > Core Rulebook: > Action modifier cards: The acting minion can play these cards to modify their action at any time before action resolution. > Dabbler: > "Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved" > There is no time restriction after action resolution; the only restriction is the end of the turn. > There is no "in minion phase", "before untap"; there is no "after performing" restriction. > The only condition to be met is: > 1) 3 Disciplines were used (action can be successful or not, but not canceled). > 2) The turn didn't end. > There is a general ruling somewhere that says "after X" ins the point in time "immedeatly after X"

Hobbesgoblin

> Ankha wrote: > > > Gr33n wrote: > > During an action, a vampire with dabbler uses 3 disciplines. > > > > Change of target is played. > > > > Can dabbler trigger? > > > Please include cardtext when asking a question about a card. > > Name: Dabbler > Cardtype: Master > Archetype. Trifle. > Put this card on a vampire you control. Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards, this vampire can either burn 1 blood to unlock or gain 1 blood. A vampire can have only one archetype. > > The answer is: No. Once the action ends, you cannot use effects that are usable during a action. "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" happens after resolution of the action. > > This effect is not a delayed triggered effect that has to be resolved due to a previous condition met. > > > Gr33n wrote: > > Dabbler not being an action modifier isn't a good enough argument in itself. > > > > "after an action is resolved" and "after action resolution" seem to be the same window. > > > Correct. > I think this is in Clonflict with this ruling on Forward momentum: > Ankha wrote: > > > Oshi wrote: > > "Forward Momentum > > Unique. > > Put this card in play. After a vampire who follows the Path of Cathari you control bleeds, if the bleed is successful (for 1 or more), add 1 counter to this card; otherwise, burn 1 counter from this card. After a vampire who follows the Path of Cathari you control performs an action, you can burn 2 counters from this card to unlock them." > > > > At which point does "After a vampire who follows the Path of Cathari you control bleeds" trigger? > > > After resolution of the action. > > > Oshi wrote: > > For clarities sake which if the following would cause forward momentum to lose a counter: bleed reduced to 0 bleed is blocked action ends to change of target bleed action card is cancelled by DI bleed action is cancelled by tangle atropos' hand > > > 1. burn (the bleed was not succesful) > 2. burn (the bleed action was not succesful) > 3. burn (idem) > 4. Don’t burn (the action didn't reach resolution) > 5. Don't burn (idem) > www.vekn.net/forum/rules-questions/82794-forward-momentum-and-failed-canceled-actions#116280 "After a vampire who follows the Path of Cathari you control bleeds" must be at the same time as "After an action resolves", aka "after action resolution" Forward Momentum is also not a "delayed triggered effect" its just a "triggered effect" If Master Card effects that trigger/happen/areusable "after action resolution" need the action to still exist, forward momentum should not buurn a counter after change of target. Forward Momentum [Master] Forward Momentum Unique. Put this card in play. After a vampire who follows the Path of Cathari you control bleeds, if the bleed is successful (for 1 or more), add 1 counter to this card; otherwise, burn 1 counter from this card. After a vampire who follows the Path of Cathari you control performs an action, you can burn 2 counters from this card to unlock them.

Ankha

> Hobbesgoblin wrote: > > > Ankha wrote: > > > > > Gr33n wrote: > > > During an action, a vampire with dabbler uses 3 disciplines. > > > > > > Change of target is played. > > > > > > Can dabbler trigger? > > > > > Please include cardtext when asking a question about a card. > > > > Name: Dabbler > > Cardtype: Master > > Archetype. Trifle. > > Put this card on a vampire you control. Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards, this vampire can either burn 1 blood to unlock or gain 1 blood. A vampire can have only one archetype. > > > > The answer is: No. Once the action ends, you cannot use effects that are usable during a action. "after an action (successful or not) is resolved" happens after resolution of the action. > > > > This effect is not a delayed triggered effect that has to be resolved due to a previous condition met. > > > > > Gr33n wrote: > > > Dabbler not being an action modifier isn't a good enough argument in itself. > > > > > > "after an action is resolved" and "after action resolution" seem to be the same window. > > > > > Correct. > > > I think this is in Clonflict with this ruling on Forward momentum: > > > Ankha wrote: > > > > > Oshi wrote: > > > For clarities sake which if the following would cause forward momentum to lose a counter: bleed reduced to 0 bleed is blocked action ends to change of target bleed action card is cancelled by DI bleed action is cancelled by tangle atropos' hand > > > > > > > > 1. burn (the bleed was not succesful) > > 2. burn (the bleed action was not succesful) > > 3. burn (idem) > > 4. Don’t burn (the action didn't reach resolution) > > 5. Don't burn (idem) > > > If Master Card effects that trigger/happen/areusable "after action resolution" need the action to still exist, forward momentum should not buurn a counter after change of target. > Correct. 3. should be "don't burn since 'after resolution' step is not reached". Prince of Paris, France Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director

Ankha

> Hobbesgoblin wrote: > > > mipopo3 wrote: > > > > > KoRneeshon wrote: > > > No, it's "Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved during which this vampire used 3 or more Disciplines to play cards", you cannot use it in your discard or transfer phase, you have to use it right after an action (successful or not) is resolved. The "once each turn" indicates you can use this effect only once per turn, not that you can use it at any point of the turn. > > > > > > > > Core Rulebook: > > Action modifier cards: The acting minion can play these cards to modify their action at any time before action resolution. > > Dabbler: > > "Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved" > > There is no time restriction after action resolution; the only restriction is the end of the turn. > > There is no "in minion phase", "before untap"; there is no "after performing" restriction. > > The only condition to be met is: > > 1) 3 Disciplines were used (action can be successful or not, but not canceled). > > 2) The turn didn't end. > > > There is a general ruling somewhere that says "after X" ins the point in time "immedeatly after X" > Correct. "after" replaced "when" in the older templates. Prince of Paris, France Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director

mipopo3

"Once each turn, after when an action (successful or not) is resolved" So let me get this straight: Is action ending not the action resolution? An action is resolved; After this, we can't use Dabbler? We only use it in the Resolution step of the Action? Is it only me? Or is this contradictory to the card text? Change of Target, mind you, only states that the action ended- it was resolved unsuccessfully. "Only usable if this minion is blocked, before block resolution. Unlock this minion. The action ends (unsuccessfully). This minion cannot perform the same action again this turn"

mipopo3

Action can resolve in only two ways: 1) Successful 2) Unsuccessful Thus, a resolution occurred. Action ends with a mirror walk, or a change of target does not skip the declaration of the resolution. Resolution must be declared.

mipopo3

My issue with this is that: 1) Dabbler is a master, not a reaction or an action modifier. Thus, not fall under: RTR 20180719 - Actions that are ended are over: action modifiers and reactions cannot be played anymore. 2)Stating that there is a "magic window" after action resolution and action ending: Conflicting with: ANK 20190113 3) Full "turn" use of the wording being limited to the "after/when" moment: Conflicting with: ANK 20180719-4 4)End of action window, which is generally used for freek drive: ANK 20190425 But yes, the New Definition of exiting phantom layer between action resolution and End of an Action, as it's in the rulebook ( there is nothing on this in the rulebook, sarcasm).

mipopo3

With this: Mental maze, Obedience, Mirror walk, Change of target, Bind the Night-Walker, Bloodstorm of Chorazin, Framing, The, Psychomachia, Red Herring, All fall under the action end, so this skips the magic layer where Dabbler works. Because Dabbler's wording "during a turn" - Once each turn, after an action (successful or not) is resolved is limited only to that magic window after action resolution and action Ending, thus it falls under Action Modifier and Reaction for End of Action(Actions that are ended are over: action modifiers and reactions cannot be played anymore.)?

mipopo3

Wording that should match the rulebook should be: "Action ends: Skip block and action resolution" With this, you make it clear. On the question, "How" did the action resolve? It didn't. Thus, there is no double language where it was (unsuccessful). And it shuts down any other effects.