Is inferior Pulse of the Canaille a directed action?
My instincts say "no" but can find no solid evidence to back that up
It does not follow the templating of Vaticination that has been since ruled (and also via the symbol) to be a directed action
Rather, it feels like the action simply grants the controller of the acting minion and ability for the rest of the turn (what that ability does is irrelevant to the directed-ness of the action itself)
I am, however, unable to find another card with a very similar sort of templating
Pulse of the Canaille
Cardtype: Action
Cost: 3 blood
Discipline: Auspex
+1 stealth action.
[aus] For the remainder of this turn, you may look at all Methuselahs' hands.
[AUS] Put this card on the acting vampire. The vampire with this card gets +2 bleed. A vampire can have only one Pulse of the Canaille.
Artist: Anson Maddocks; Hannibal King
Suaku
Inceptor Asian Continental Championship
興っ
www.youtube.com/SuakuOz
The effect targets all Methuselahs´hands, making them all accessabile to be looked at for the player playing it.
Below is a post where the text was updated to make the targeting clearer and not mix sinuglar and plural.
usenet.krcg.org/t/hMnXiu-tgw0/#m9
Below is a post where LSJ clarifies that targeting a player's hand makes an action directed.
usenet.krcg.org/t/rZcOI3IZOJw/#m2
The resolution of the action could read as granting you an ability to look at other players' hands, rather than directly revealing other players' hands to you
Suaku
Inceptor Asian Continental Championship
興っ
www.youtube.com/SuakuOz
> the1andonlime wrote:
> Is inferior Pulse of the Canaille a directed action?
> My instincts say "no" but can find no solid evidence to back that up
>
> It does not follow the templating of Vaticination that has been since ruled (and also via the symbol) to be a directed action
> Rather, it feels like the action simply grants the controller of the acting minion and ability for the rest of the turn (what that ability does is irrelevant to the directed-ness of the action itself)
>
> I am, however, unable to find another card with a very similar sort of templating
>
> Pulse of the Canaille
>
> Cardtype: Action
> Cost: 3 blood
> Discipline: Auspex
> +1 stealth action.
> [aus] For the remainder of this turn, you may look at all Methuselahs' hands.
> [AUS] Put this card on the acting vampire. The vampire with this card gets +2 bleed. A vampire can have only one Pulse of the Canaille.
> Artist: Anson Maddocks; Hannibal King
>
I couldn't find anything neither, it's a one of a kind.
Since the card, upon resolution, does nothing other than set an effect for the rest of the turn, it is not directed to whatever targets it affects for the rest of the turn.
Prince of Paris, France
Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director
> Ankha wrote:
> Since the card, upon resolution, does nothing other than set an effect for the rest of the turn, it is not directed to whatever targets it affects for the rest of the turn.
>
How do you explain below post from LSJ, where the change was about correcting the grammar of the targeting (changed to the plural form)???
And if there are targets, it cannot be undirected?!?!
> Pulse of the Canaille - Action (aus) (3)
> * The inferior is grammatically incorrect, mixing singular and plural for
> the target. The correct reading is, as in the Jyhad version, "... may
> look at all Methuselahs' hands." [LSJ 19980211]
>
usenet.krcg.org/t/hMnXiu-tgw0/#m9
> inm8 wrote:
>
> > Ankha wrote:
> > Since the card, upon resolution, does nothing other than set an effect for the rest of the turn, it is not directed to whatever targets it affects for the rest of the turn.
> >
> How do you explain below post from LSJ, where the change was about correcting the grammar of the targeting (changed to the plural form)???
>
> And if there are targets, it cannot be undirected?!?!
>
> > Pulse of the Canaille - Action (aus) (3)
> > * The inferior is grammatically incorrect, mixing singular and plural for
> > the target. The correct reading is, as in the Jyhad version, "... may
> > look at all Methuselahs' hands." [LSJ 19980211]
> >
> usenet.krcg.org/t/hMnXiu-tgw0/#m9
>
It was about a grammatical error mixing plural and singular in the VTES edition ("any Methuselahs' hand"), it doesn't change anything about the way the card works.
Prince of Paris, France
Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director
These are LSJ´s own words " The inferior is grammatically incorrect, mixing singular and plural for the target."
How it works isn't in question, but who, if any it targets... According to LSJ there are targets (plural); according to you, there are none...
In jyhad it was clearly an undirected action
> lsj wrote:
> > Here's the card text:
> >
> > (BOLD) +1 stealth
> > (not bold) Look at all Methusalh's hands for the remainder
> > of your turn
> > (BOLD) The acting vampire has 3 bleed for the remainder
> > of the game
> >
> > My question: is the superior at +1 stealth as well?
>
> Yes. Bold at the top applies to the entire card.
>
> (Also all undirected actions are at stealth - with the exception
> of Igo's hunting and the mis-printed superior Enchant Kindred).
>
usenet.krcg.org/t/FQZwLDHXFD4/#m2
this was from 1995 though, long before the changes to firected actions in KoT
If the basis for the statement that it was "clearly undirected" is the quoted statement by LSJ, I'm not sure it holds.
LSJ wasn´t RD at the time when making the statement, and it was dismissed by the at the time RD Thomas R Wylie.
> Thomas_R_Wylie wrote:
>
> > LSJ wrote:
> > (Also all undirected actions are at stealth - with the exception
> > of Igo's hunting and the mis-printed superior Enchant Kindred).
> >
> Random non-directed actions do not default to being at any kind of stealth,
> actually. They are assumed to be at 0 stealth, and it just so happens
> that almost all of them are printed as being at +1 stealth. That is
> not reminder text, that is a case of cards systematically breaking the
> rules. An analagous situation would be mana sources in Magic... only
> tapping lands for mana defaults to being an interrupt, and it just so
> happens that most non-land sources of mana say the ability is played as
> an interrupt. Such cards are not restating the rules, but systematically
> breaking them.
>
> Igo is breaking the rules, because hunting normally happens at +1 stealth,
> so the card denotes this. Enchant Kindred is following the normal rules
> for random actions, so does not need to print any kind of stealth value,
> and is thus at 0 stealth. You might not *like* the fact that it's not at
> +1 stealth, but that does not make it a misprint.
>
usenet.krcg.org/t/FQZwLDHXFD4/#m8
The contradiction for me, whether it is directed or not, is the fact that it is an effect that enables the player to access information about other players' hands (that normally is secret and not allowed to be disclosed/shared), which makes it strange not to be considered as targeting said hands, as that is part of what those players control (the cards and the information of their hand)
It is a directed action.
It is almost identical to Vaticination
Vaticination
+3 stealth action.
Ⓓ Look at each Methuselah's hand and discard a card of your choice from among all those hands (including your own hand).
> XZealot wrote:
> It is a directed action.
> It is almost identical to Vaticination
>
> Vaticination
>
> +3 stealth action.
> Ⓓ Look at each Methuselah's hand and discard a card of your choice from among all those hands (including your own hand).
>
"Almost" could make the difference.
Consider the card effect "+1 stealth action. Until the end of the turn, vampires can burn 1 blood to burn 1 life from all allies."
Would it be directed at all the vampires? All the allies? Or is it a generic effect?
(replace "vampires" by "you" and "allies" by "all Methuselahs' hands")
I'm still thinking about it.
Prince of Paris, France
Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director
I find some similar in favor of D action.
Sowing Dissension
rulings.krcg.org/index.html?uid=101838
Requires a ready anarch. Each other Methuselah locks an unlocked ready younger vampire he or she controls. If this action is blocked by a non-titled vampire, the acting anarch can burn 1 blood to cancel combat and unlock.
Petra Resonance
rulings.krcg.org/index.html?uid=101396
+1 stealth action. Not usable if any Methuselah's crypt is empty. Each Methuselah reveals the top card of his or her crypt. If there is a tie for highest or lowest cost among the revealed cards, every Methuselah burns 1 pool. Otherwise, the Methuselah revealing the highest cost steals 3 pool from the Methuselah revealing the lowest cost. All Methuselahs shuffle their crypts afterward.
I find similar as undirected
Baltimore Purge
rulings.krcg.org/index.html?uid=100128
Requires a vampire. If this vampire is Ravnos, this is a +1 stealth action. Put this card on this vampire. During your unlock phase, burn this card and each other Methuselah chooses a ready vampire they control who is not older than this vampire; if you control a ready Lasombra, you choose the vampires instead; this vampire and the chosen vampires go to torpor.
In the sense of "setting an effect" pulse is more similar to Baltimore Purge.