Fee Stake: Florence
Florence, SC
July 24, 2021
2R + F
12 Players
Jose Lafuente
www.vekn.net/event-calendar/event/9799
Thanks to Jordan Beall for keeping notes during the final round!
Finals seating order: Jose LaFuente: !Malk stealth Bleed -> Ethan Mathis: !Toreador/Toreador Bruise & Bleed -> John Byrd: Weenie Obfuscate Bleed-> Benjamin Billings: Baba Yaga Animalism -> Jason Joy: !Salubri Bruise & Bleed Jose started Kindred Spirits bleeding Ethan right away with his mid-cap !Malkavians. It would not be until Turn 4 that Ethan got his first vampire out (Miller Delmardigan). John brought out small caps each Turn and rather than focus on bleeding a minion-less prey, he used his first few turns equipping his vamps with Laptops, Coolers or Bombs. Benjamin did not draw a Baba Yaga in this opening crypt and spent the first three Turns burning a pool to find one. It was not until Turn 4 that Baba Yaga would start receiving pool. Jason brought out Castiel and Thomas Steed, but had no rushes or weapons in his hand.
Jose stealth bled Ethan for 2-4 pool each turn.
On Turn 5, Ethan brought out Kallista, Master Sculptuer and was down to 8 pool on Turn 5.
On Turn 6, Ethan played a Villien on Miller for 5 pool to stay alive. He would also Fame John’s Basil, rush with Fleetness, Fast Hands Basil’s Bomb and sent Basil to Torpor. Ethan put Dragonbound into play on his discard phase. John lost 5 pool total from the Fame/Dragonbound Basil on Turn 6. On Turn 6, Benjamin influenced out Baba Yaga and was now down to 11 pool.
The Fame would burn pool from all Methuselahs at their unlock phases for all of Turn 7. At the end of Turn 7, both Ethan and John were down to 2 pool each. On Turn 7, Benjamin played a Slum Hunting Ground and Deep Song rushed Thomas Steed, dealing 4 damage to him.
On Turn 8, Jose bled out Ethan, earning the game’s first VP. John then bled out Benjamin with two bleeds for the second VP. Jason rushed John’s Celine and sent her to torpor, earning Castiel a Righteous Aura.
On Turn 10, after another minion was sent to torpor while attempting to bleed Jason, John transferred out his remaining pool, earning Jose a second VP. Jason and Jose went back and forth with bleeding and rushing actions. On Turn 11, Apache Jones went to torpor, and on Turn 12, Midget was burned in combat On Turn 14, Jose conceded and Jason earned 2 VPs.
1.5 VP +2 VP in final
Deck Name: Blood Insanity
Author: Jose LaFuente
Description: iMalk bleed
Crypt (12 cards; Capacity min=3 max=9 avg=5.25)
==================
2x General Perfidio Dios 5 dem obf AUS Malkavian antitribu:3
2x Apache Jones 5 aus for obf DEM Malkavian antitribu:4
1x Marta 3 aus dem Malkavian antitribu:4
2x Midget 3 obf pre DEM Malkavian antitribu:3
1x Persephone Tar-Anis 8 cel pot AUS DEM OBF Malkavian antitribu:4
2x Beauregard Krueller 4 aus dem obf Malkavian antitribu:4
1x Uncle George 5 aus dom obf DEM Malkavian antitribu:3
1x Alicia Barrows 9 AUS DEM OBF POT PRE Malkavian antitribu:4
Library: 90 cards
Master (15 cards)
==================
2x Institution Hunting Ground
3x Obfuscate
3x Auspex
5x Blood Doll
2x Dementation
Action (15 cards)
==================
15x Kindred Spirits
Action Modifier (24 cards)
==================
6x Eyes of Chaos
1x Into Thin Air
4x Lost in Crowds
1x Veil the Legions
4x Cloak the Gathering
8x Confusion
Combat (15 cards)
==================
4x Personal Scourge
1x Psychic Assault
2x Read Intentions
2x Behind You!
6x Coma
Reaction (21 cards)
==================
4x On the Qui Vive
1x Precognition
11x Telepathic Misdirection
5x Wake with Evening's Freshness
I'm a bit confused about this. Did Jason Joy win or Jose Lafuente win?
The list is for !malk, but the header of this post says hat Jason D Joy won.
Lasombra Archbishop of São José, SC, Brazil.
Transfered out to give someone GW, nice to see!
Sabbat.Black Hand Shakar: Lech loathe ranged weapons. Once each action, he may burn 1 blood to become Camarilla Prince of Krakow until the end of the action.
> Lech wrote:
> Transfered out to give someone GW, nice to see!
>
Indeed.
I rather thought this has been declared a violation of PTW...
(Then again, if John had zero minions at that time. Coupled with 4 or less pool that does make it pretty hopeless situation though...)
Finnish Politics!
> Lech wrote:
> Transfered out to give someone GW, nice to see!
>
Actually, if I read this report correctly, when the transfer out happened Jose still had several minions and more than a few pools so he would have earn his VP (and his GW).
> Timo wrote:
>
> > Lech wrote:
> > Transfered out to give someone GW, nice to see!
> >
> Actually, if I read this report correctly, when the transfer out happened Jose still had several minions and more than a few pools so he would have earn his VP (and his GW).
>
Doesn't matter. He already won the tournament.
> kschaefer wrote:
>
> > Timo wrote:
> >
> > > Lech wrote:
> > > Transfered out to give someone GW, nice to see!
> > >
> > Actually, if I read this report correctly, when the transfer out happened Jose still had several minions and more than a few pools so he would have earn his VP (and his GW).
> >
> Doesn't matter. He already won the tournament.
>
"John transferred out his remaining pool, earning Jose a second VP." It's not Jose we are talking about.
Sabbat.Black Hand Shakar: Lech loathe ranged weapons. Once each action, he may burn 1 blood to become Camarilla Prince of Krakow until the end of the action.
Deck Name: The Society of Blades
Author: Jason Joy
Description: !Salubri Sword Deck
Crypt (12 cards; Capacity min=2 max=7 avg=4.333333)
==================
2x Kervos, The Lieutenant 3 aus val Salubri antitribu:2
3x Thomas Steed, The Angry 4 ani aus val Salubri antitribu:2
1x Adonai 7 for AUS VAL Salubri antitribu:2
1x Wolf Valentine 4 for VAL Salubri antitribu:2
4x Castiel 6 for AUS VAL Salubri antitribu:3
1x Doris McMillon 2 val Salubri antitribu:2
Library: 90 cards
Master (17 cards)
==================
1x KRCG News Radio
1x Millicent Smith, Puritan Vampire Hunter
2x Path of Retribution, The
1x Powerbase: Montreal
1x Rack, The
1x Society of Leopold
3x Vessel
2x Wider View
2x Blooding by the Code
1x Code of Samiel
2x Dreams of the Sphinx
Action (6 cards)
==================
6x Sense Death
Combat (33 cards)
==================
5x Armor of Caine's Fury
6x Sword of the Righteous
2x Target Vitals
5x Taste of Vitae
7x Blessed Blade
3x Righteous Aura
5x Death Seeker
Equipment (7 cards)
==================
7x Blade of Bellona
Reaction (27 cards)
==================
4x Enhanced Senses
3x Eyes of Argus
10x Hide the Heart
4x On the Qui Vive
3x Spirit's Touch
3x Eagle's Sight
Don't have access to the Toreador deck.
> kschaefer wrote:
>
> > Timo wrote:
> >
> > > Lech wrote:
> > > Transfered out to give someone GW, nice to see!
> > >
> > Actually, if I read this report correctly, when the transfer out happened Jose still had several minions and more than a few pools so he would have earn his VP (and his GW).
> >
> Doesn't matter. He already won the tournament.
>
If I read the report correctly, Jose (first seed) had 1 VP and John 1 VP at that time.
Jason had the opportunity to oust Jose and John and make the GW. By transferring out, John gave the victory to Jose.
We don't know the exact state of the game at that time, but if John was about to die, he could leave Jose kill him instead of transferring out, otherwise he had no reason to transfer out (even if pissed off by being bled by his predator and rushed by his predator).
Prince of Paris, France
Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director
> Valas66 wrote:
> John had single pool left and no chance of not being bleed out when Jose took his next turn. There was no way I could have finished Jose before that.
>
In that case, it seems legit, even though there's no real incentive for John to transfer out except to save Jose's "bleed for 1" action, except prior deals.
Prince of Paris, France
Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director
> Ankha wrote:
>
> > Valas66 wrote:
> > John had single pool left and no chance of not being bleed out when Jose took his next turn. There was no way I could have finished Jose before that.
> >
> In that case, it seems legit, even though there's no real incentive for John to transfer out except to save Jose's "bleed for 1" action, except prior deals.
>
John is free to get his additional 0 VP any way he likes per the rules. The incentive to transfer out is to "teach" your prey about the result of relentless back-rushing. Why did John's prey rush him to gain the Righteous Aura instead of Jose?
TBH, there's nothing wrong with John transferring out at that point even if Jose had no minions that could bleed. It's clear from the recap that John had no options left to obtain a VP. He can leave the table however he likes at that point.
> kschaefer wrote:
>
> > Ankha wrote:
> >
> > > Valas66 wrote:
> > > John had single pool left and no chance of not being bleed out when Jose took his next turn. There was no way I could have finished Jose before that.
> > >
> > In that case, it seems legit, even though there's no real incentive for John to transfer out except to save Jose's "bleed for 1" action, except prior deals.
> >
> John is free to get his additional 0 VP any way he likes per the rules. The incentive to transfer out is to "teach" your prey about the result of relentless back-rushing. Why did John's prey rush him to gain the Righteous Aura instead of Jose?
>
> TBH, there's nothing wrong with John transferring out at that point even if Jose had no minions that could bleed. It's clear from the recap that John had no options left to obtain a VP. He can leave the table however he likes at that point.
>
I had no problem with what John did with transferring out. His situation was hopeless at that stage of the game. John's prey, this being me, back rushed him ONE time - hard to consider that “relentless” - but ok. John was playing a weenie deck and had several more vampires than I did and good bloat machine going. I had to slow him down or it would have been just him and Jose battling out for the final VPs. I couldn’t focus on Jose if I had John’s swarm contend with also. John had just bled Benjamin out and had his sights set on doing the same thing to me. So, I back rushed one of his bloaters and got my righteous aura thus taking away a resource from John - one less resource to focus on me while defending against Jose.