VTES rules archive

[LSJ] Dodge vs. S:CE+effect

3 messages from 3 participants · 03 June 2011 – 13 July 2011 · vekn.net/forum
the topic on the V:EKN forum

KevinM

There still seems to be some debate regarding the Dodge vs S:CE+effect issue. Searching on the googley, using 'author:lsj dodge catatonic fear', from 3/18/2002 and 3/28/2002 LSJ says no, the dodge does not stop the Catatonic Fear damage, and even cites "S:CE will prevent the dodge from resolving. [LSJ 25-SEP-1998]." But, there is a 1/24/07 question where LSJ says yes, Dodge dodges the effects of Catatonic Fear; this answer is also given at 3/17/2007 and 3/23/2010 with the reasoning being "The dodge protects the dodger (and any non-retainer cards on him) from the effects of the opposing minion's strike." So, was the 2007 answer just a fluke/mistake, or was it a new ruling? Could we get a "final" clarification on this issue, please? Thanks. Kevin M., Prince of Las Vegas "Know your enemy and know yourself; in one-thousand battles you shall never be in peril." -- Sun Tzu, *The Art of War* "Contentment...Complacency...Catastrophe!" -- Joseph Chevalier Please visit VTESville daily! vtesville.myminicity.com/ Facebook: www.facebook.com/groups/129744447064017

Pascal Bertrand

Mylan won't die if he dodges and the opponent plays sup' Catatonic Fear. In doubt, use LSJ's most recent answer (2007, 2010 over 2002). [LSJ 20100224] See also here: Complete Rules Reference Resolve strikes. [6.4.3.2] NOTE: Dodge doesn't resolve; it cancels the effect of the opposing strike on the dodging minion and non-Retainer cards on him. [6.4.5]

Squidalot

Also see the meld with a land rulings if required.