If a Nocturn is allowed to play a conditioning through another vampire playing mouthpiece, does the action resolve with the Nocturn bleeding at +2, or does the Nocturn just die?
Nocturn
[Ally}
[1 Blood]
Demon with 1 life. 1 strength, 1 bleed.
[obt] Move Nocturn to the ready region when recruited. If this is this vampire's first successful recruit action this turn, he or she untaps. Nocturn can play non-ally cards that require basic Obtenebration as a vampire. Burn Nocturn during your untap phase.
[OBT] As above, and this vampire may perform this action again this turn, with the cost increased by 1 blood.
Mouthpiece
[Action Modifier]
[dom] +1 bleed. You cannot play another action modifier to increase this bleed.
[DOM] Only usable by a ready vampire other than the acting minion. The acting minion may play cards that require basic Dominate as a vampire for the remainder of this action.
Conditioning
[Action Modifier]
[Dominate]
[1 Blood]
You cannot play another action modifier to increase this bleed amount.
[dom] +2 bleed
[DOM] +3 bleed.
Be careful when you fight the monsters, lest you become one.
-Friedrich Nietzsche
brandonsantacruz.blogspot.com/
I can see how that answer can be good or bad, depending on the situation. Thank you for the quick reply!
Be careful when you fight the monsters, lest you become one.
-Friedrich Nietzsche
brandonsantacruz.blogspot.com/
I have a version of this question.
Nocturn bleeds. Minion attempts to block. Block is successful. Before combat, Nocturn Meth "cycles" a mouthpiece and a conditioning. Nocturn dies. Is the blocking minion tapped?
> erewego wrote:
> Nocturn bleeds. Minion attempts to block. Block is successful. Before combat, Nocturn Meth "cycles" a mouthpiece and a conditioning. Nocturn dies. Is the blocking minion tapped?
>
Illegal. If the action was blocked, the action is unsuccessful and blocked [6.2.3], and you can't play action modifiers during combat [6.4].
Kevin M., Prince of Las Vegas
"Know your enemy and know yourself; in one-thousand battles
you shall never be in peril." -- Sun Tzu, *The Art of War*
"Contentment...Complacency...Catastrophe!" -- Joseph Chevalier
Please visit VTESville daily! vtesville.myminicity.com/
Facebook: www.facebook.com/groups/129744447064017
Just extending Kevin's answer slightly. There is a window after a block attempt is made and before the block attempt is successful where you could cycle the Mouth Piece and the Conditioning. However, the Nocturn would then die before the block was successful and minion attempting the block would not tap.
I would have to disagree with this. There is a window after an action is blocked but before combat begins during which action modifiers can be played. See cards such as Venenation, Power of One and Change of Target for examples of cards that can explicitly only be played during this window.
My understanding (based on this post about Venenation) is that the blocker would be tapped before you reach this window.
> Mael wrote:
> I would have to disagree with this. There is a window after an action is blocked but before combat begins during which action modifiers can be played. See cards such as Venenation, Power of One and Change of Target for examples of cards that can explicitly only be played during this window.
>
This is incorrect, re:the rulebook that I quoted. The reason these cards that you mention can be played at that time is that they have explicit text stating that they can be played at that time. Once the action is blocked, you can only play combat cards, excepting card which have specific text stating otherwise.
Kevin M., Prince of Las Vegas
"Know your enemy and know yourself; in one-thousand battles
you shall never be in peril." -- Sun Tzu, *The Art of War*
"Contentment...Complacency...Catastrophe!" -- Joseph Chevalier
Please visit VTESville daily! vtesville.myminicity.com/
Facebook: www.facebook.com/groups/129744447064017
However: There is a window after a block attempt has been declared but before the action is declared blocked in which action modifiers can be played.
Usually, that's when Lost in Crowds, sup' Bonding, et al. get played. But feel free to play Mouthpiece + Conditioning and no stealth.
> KevinM wrote:
>
> > Mael wrote:
> > I would have to disagree with this. There is a window after an action is blocked but before combat begins during which action modifiers can be played. See cards such as Venenation, Power of One and Change of Target for examples of cards that can explicitly only be played during this window.
> >
> This is incorrect, re:the rulebook that I quoted. The reason these cards that you mention can be played at that time is that they have explicit text stating that they can be played at that time. Once the action is blocked, you can only play combat cards, excepting card which have specific text stating otherwise.
>
Their text restricts them to only being played during that window, which illustrates the existence of that window.
Re the rulebook that you referenced, the text reads "If the action is blocked .... the blocking minion is tapped and enters combat ...". It does not say that the action is unsuccessful. It also does not say that no further action modifiers can be played (indeed there are others that can only be played after the combat).
If you treat "is tapped" and "enters combat" as two separate steps that normally happen sequentially, then we can infer a window between them for action modifiers to be played before the "enters combat" portion of the action begins.
The rulebook is unclear whether these should be treated as separate sequential steps, or as a single step, but the related ruling that I linked does provide clarity on that.
If you have a ruling that contradicts my reading of this, please do provide it.
> floppyzedolfin wrote:
> However: There is a window after a block attempt has been declared but before the action is declared blocked in which action modifiers can be played.
>
Correct. But that isn't what I keep responding to. Once the action is blocked, you cannot play action modifiers, except via explicit card text.
i.e. When the acting Methuselah states "You successfully blocked" then she may no longer play action modifiers, except via explicit card text.
Kevin M., Prince of Las Vegas
"Know your enemy and know yourself; in one-thousand battles
you shall never be in peril." -- Sun Tzu, *The Art of War*
"Contentment...Complacency...Catastrophe!" -- Joseph Chevalier
Please visit VTESville daily! vtesville.myminicity.com/
Facebook: www.facebook.com/groups/129744447064017
Venenation requires a successful block before being played. So the 'before this action is blocked/before blocks are successful' window is long-closed.
The play sequence (for the Nocturn Sequence):
Vamp X has declared a block attempt to block Nocturn
Now other action modifiers can be played (such as stealth cards)
The Nocturn would now be blocked once the acting Methuselah passes on impulse and the blocking Methuselah does so as well.
Then the block is successful and the minion taps for blocking.
Then combat begins.
So in the space before you started the block attempt and the block being declared successful by both Methuselahs, there is space to play Mouthpiece, etc. If somehow the Nocturn cannot continue the action or dies, the action ends unsuccessfully, the block fails (since there is nothing to block) and the blocking minion untaps.
Retired Baron of Sydney, Australia, 418
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> Venenation requires a successful block before being played. So the 'before this action is blocked/before blocks are successful' window is long-closed.
>
> The play sequence (for the Nocturn Sequence):
>
> Vamp X has declared a block attempt to block Nocturn
> Now other action modifiers can be played (such as stealth cards)
> The Nocturn would now be blocked once the acting Methuselah passes on impulse and the blocking Methuselah does so as well.
> Then the block is successful and the minion taps for blocking.
> Then combat begins.
>
> So in the space before you started the block attempt and the block being declared successful by both Methuselahs, there is space to play Mouthpiece, etc. If somehow the Nocturn cannot continue the action or dies, the action ends unsuccessfully, the block fails (since there is nothing to block) and the blocking minion untaps.
>
To be a bit more precise, the block is only declared successful by the acting player, when her predator passes on using the impulse during an action where the attempt to block has equal or more intercept than the acting minion's stealth.
Blocking minion definitely doesn't untap if Nocturn dies. He does not tap, which is clearly different (Wake with Evening's Freshness, ...) See Change of Target's cardtext.
Regarding the Tapping vs Entering combat, the Complete Rules Reference seems to show there are two different steps (IV. D 3 b, IV D 3 c) (also notice: action is unsuccessful). But that doesn't mean that you can squeeze something inbetween.
For example, it's been asked: Can I successfully block, tap, play Forced Awakening + Obedience? (in order to cycle a Forced Awakening)
Answer is no. (linked to that thread: groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/browse_frm/thread/807c408323f5e55a/60076d826f9eca3e )
@ Mael: You cannot play action modifiers when an action is blocked. You similarly cannot play action modifiers after action has resolved. Of course, rule 1.4 takes precedence.
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> If somehow the Nocturn cannot continue the action or dies, the action ends unsuccessfully, the block fails (since there is nothing to block) and the blocking minion untaps.
>
Slightly off tagnet, could this method be used to ged rid off No Secrets from Magaji? Bleed with nocturn, Magaji attempts to block, Nocturn dies before combat --> burn No Secrets?
> Whisker wrote:
>
> > Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> > If somehow the Nocturn cannot continue the action or dies, the action ends unsuccessfully, the block fails (since there is nothing to block) and the blocking minion untaps.
> >
> Slightly off tagnet, could this method be used to ged rid off No Secrets from Magaji? Bleed with nocturn, Magaji attempts to block, Nocturn dies before combat --> burn No Secrets?
>
maybe. except No Secrets card text only mentions vampires.
Well, I would want a ruling from LSJ on the No Secrets thing.
I'm not sure if the block attempt would 'fail' in the sense of "If a minion fails to block" or if the block attempt is also cancelled since the action is cancelled because it cannot be continued...
Retired Baron of Sydney, Australia, 418
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> Well, I would want a ruling from LSJ on the No Secrets thing.
>
Define "thing".
Do you want a clarification on why No Secrets doesn't burn when the Magaji attempts to block a Nocturn who plays Conditioning?
That's because of cardtext.
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> I'm not sure if the block attempt would 'fail' in the sense of "If a minion fails to block" or if the block attempt is also cancelled since the action is cancelled because it cannot be continued...
>
No Secrets from the magaji doesn't require the block attempt to fail in order to burn.
It only requires the block attempt to be unsuccessful (and the acting minion to be a vampire).
Which part is unclear?
I would also like to point out that Magaji who knows all secrets has nothing to do blocking an ally, as their secrets are well hidden B) B)
+1 stealth action. Requires a ready magaji. Put this card on this magaji and untap him or her. The magaji with this card gets +1 intercept when attempting to block vampires. If this magaji is tapped, he or she may attempt to block a vampire as if untapped. Burn this card if this magaji attempts to block a vampire but is not successful. A vampire may have only one No Secrets From the Magaji.
> floppyzedolfin wrote:
> Regarding the Tapping vs Entering combat, the Complete Rules Reference seems to show there are two different steps (IV. D 3 b, IV D 3 c) (also notice: action is unsuccessful). But that doesn't mean that you can squeeze something inbetween.
> For example, it's been asked: Can I successfully block, tap, play Forced Awakening + Obedience? (in order to cycle a Forced Awakening)
> Answer is no. (linked to that thread: groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/browse_frm/thread/807c408323f5e55a/60076d826f9eca3e )
>
> @ Mael: You cannot play action modifiers when an action is blocked. You similarly cannot play action modifiers after action has resolved. Of course, rule 1.4 takes precedence.
>
Thank you for the link, this part
>
> These were all options in a1.
> There is no separate b1.
>
does conclusively answer the question. (for anyone who doesn't want to read that thread, a and b refer to a - tapping and b - entering combat)
Otherwise all the rules I could see were either inconclusive or were pointing to the existence of a separate window between those.