rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

TWD - 2011 Belgian National Championship

18 messages from 7 participants · 13 March 2011 – 27 March 2011 · vekn.net/forum
the topic on the V:EKN forum

D-dennis

Congratulations to Peter Bouwman for winning the Belgian National Championship. TWD will follow as soon as we receive it. 2011 Belgian National Championship Brussels Outpost Gamestore 13-3-2011 30 players Peter Bouwman Decklist <- on the way More tournament stories, reports and pictures will come. www.facebook.com/groups/vtes.belgium/

Adonai

2011 Belgian National Championship Brussels Outpost Gamestore March 13, 2011 30 players Peter Bouwman's Tournament Winning Deck Deck Name: Freaky Politicians Author: Peter Bouwman Description: An old skool Ventrue deck focussing on putting blood on uncontrolled vampires or use those cards to bleed heavily. Older versions had more freak drives. Thats were the name came from. This deck won the 2011 Belgian National Championship on March 13, 2011 in the Outpost Gamestore in Brussels. Crypt (12 cards; Capacity min=3 max=8 avg=5.92) =============================================== 1x Courtland Leighton 4 dom for pre Ventrue:1 2x Emerson Bridges 8 pot DOM FOR PRE Ventrue:1 1x Gideon Fontaine 3 PRE Ventrue:1 1x Jazz Wentworth 5 dom for PRE Ventrue:1 1x Luccia Paciola 6 for pre DOM Ventrue:1 1x Ranjan Rishi, Camarilla Scholar 5 for DOM PRE Ventrue:2 2x Sir Walter Nash 7 DOM FOR PRE Ventrue:1 2x Timothy Crowley 7 ani dom FOR PRE Ventrue:1 1x Violette Prentiss 4 dom PRE Ventrue:1 Library (88 cards) ================== Master (12) 2x Anarch Troublemaker 1x Barrens, The 2x Dreams of the Sphinx 1x Island of Yiaros 2x Life in the City 1x Pentex(TM) Subversion 2x Ventrue Headquarters 1x Villein Action (18) 4x Enchant Kindred 2x Entrancement 4x Fourth Tradition: The Accounting 4x Govern the Unaligned 4x Scouting Mission Political Action (17) 4x Kine Resources Contested 1x Neonate Breach 7x Parity Shift 1x Praxis Seizure: Amsterdam 1x Praxis Seizure: Berlin 1x Praxis Seizure: Cairo 1x Praxis Seizure: Geneva 1x Ventrue Justicar Action Modifier (25) 2x Awe 4x Bewitching Oration 5x Conditioning 5x Freak Drive 4x Seduction 5x Voter Captivation Reaction (7) 7x Deflection Combat (9) 5x Majesty 4x Soak

Oortje

He is not the author of the deck. Why did you edited it? The author is me Jeroen van Oort. Original source www.atfreeforum.com/vtesholland/viewtopic.php?t=577&start=30&mforum=vtesholland Have a cold long night, Jeroen van Oort Dutch National Coördinator

jhattara

For TWD the author is usually marked the same as the player. In description of the TWD there could be notes about the actual creator of the deck. Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Adonai

> Oortje wrote: > Why did you edited it? > I didn't edit it. I copied it from Extrala's link to the Secret Library. www.secretlibrary.info/index.php?deck=view&id=5689

jhattara

In Secret Library the current policy for TWDs is to mark the player as author. If the actual author of the deck is another person, mentioning in the deck's description is encouraged. Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

D-dennis

> jhattara wrote: > In Secret Library the current policy for TWDs is to mark the player as author. If the actual author of the deck is another person, mentioning in the deck's description is encouraged. > I followed Ralf's guidelins for posting the deck on SL. I'll add Jeroen as original author in the description. Dennis www.facebook.com/groups/vtes.belgium/

Oortje

It doesn't make sense. An author is somebody who writes things. In this case the player didn't write the deck, nor assembled the cards. There for the player is not the author, or visa versa. Have a cold long night, Jeroen van Oort Dutch National Coördinator

extrala

I was asking Jussi (as administrator/creator for Secret Library) a while ago to separate author from player (i.e. adding an additional field), especially for the TWDs. But he refused on the grounds, that it is a rare case, that player and author are separate persons. So as of today SL only knows the field "author".

jhattara

It can be changed in a future version of the Secret Library, but as long as I have work to do in here, I have absolutely no time to make code-level changes to the Secret Library, except for fixing critical errors. And as for it making no sense: It makes sense if you think of it as TWD repository. Or would you ask the TWD to display the actual assembler of the deck, before the player of the deck? The player might not have written the actual deck, but he wrote the story that made it win. Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Lönkka

> jhattara wrote: > And as for it making no sense: It makes sense if you think of it as TWD repository. Or would you ask the TWD to display the actual assembler of the deck, before the player of the deck? The player might not have written the actual deck, but he wrote the story that made it win. > If you use a deck that someone else designed and didn't change anything in it I do think that you aren't the author and you NEED to acknowledge the deck's original designer. If you use someone else's design and tweak it it would be very polite to acknowldge the original designer. The less you change the deck, the more you need to mention the original designer. For example, I think that people who have been using "Girls" deck have tended very often to acknowledge the original designers. Finnish Politics!

jhattara

Of course the original designer should be credited, but in TWDA the player goes before (and the designer should be mentioned in the Description field). No matter how good deck you play, the player himself plays a significant part in VTES. I acknowledge that this is a design flaw in the Secret Library, but while there is only one field for the author, TWD should be credited to the player first. Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Oortje

Thanks for the responds. I agree with the fact that you should invest time in more important matters then this. It's just strange that the deck list got changed since I posted it. Do you or extrala actually enter it in secret library after people post an text extraction of secret library? Have a cold long night, Jeroen van Oort Dutch National Coördinator

jhattara

extrala has mostly handled the TWDA in the Secret Library. Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

D-dennis

> Oortje wrote: > Thanks for the responds. > I agree with the fact that you should invest time in more important matters then this. > It's just strange that the deck list got changed since I posted it. Do you or extrala actually enter it in secret library after people post an text extraction of secret library? > I have posted your/peter's deck on SL, and changed the author-field from your name to the name of the tournament winner. www.facebook.com/groups/vtes.belgium/

jhattara

> D-dennis wrote: > > > Oortje wrote: > > Thanks for the responds. > > I agree with the fact that you should invest time in more important matters then this. > > It's just strange that the deck list got changed since I posted it. Do you or extrala actually enter it in secret library after people post an text extraction of secret library? > > > I have posted your/peter's deck on SL, and changed the author-field from your name to the name of the tournament winner. > You should change the deck's title into: 2011 Belgian National Championship: Freaky Politicians Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Ankha

All of this wouldn't have happened if I had won Prince of Paris, France Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director

D-dennis

I posted a report of the tournament on bgg www.facebook.com/groups/vtes.belgium/