VTES rules archive

Reducing subdivision amounts (UK, Thailand, etc.)

13 messages from 5 participants · 13 March 2011 – 14 March 2011 · vekn.net/forum
the topic on the V:EKN forum

jhattara

Hello, I was thinking that I should edit the subdivision (state) list of some countries to reduce the amount of subdivisions in the search by state functions. E.g. United Kingdom has 231 subdivision units, which makes the search by subdivision rather useless. Here are some of the countries that might have some issues with the large amount of subdivisions: United Kingdom (231 subdivisions) Macedonia, FYRO (84 subdivisions, no players atm) Thailand (77 subdivisions) Malta (68 subdivisions, no players atm) There are probably others too. I'll list on a following post the amount of subdivisions of each country, so that everyone can tell their opinion on other countries with high amount of subdivisions. Here are few alternatives that could be used for each country in question: United Kingdom Option 1 Regions of England (9) Northern Ireland (1) Scotland (1) Wales (1) = 12 Option 2 Counties of England (48) Counties of Northern Ireland (6) Regions of Scotland (12) Counties of Wales (8) = 74 Option 3 Metropolitan and non-metropolitan counties of England (83) Districts of Northern Ireland (26) Council Areas of Scotland (32) Unitary Authorities of Wales (22) = 163 Option 4 (Current ISO 3166-2:GB) England (151) Northern Ireland (26) Scotland (32) Wales (22) = 231 ISO 3166-2:GB Regions of England Counties of England Metropolitan and non-metropolitan counties of England Counties of Northern Ireland Local government in Northern Ireland Subdivisions of Scotland Regions and islands areas Preserved counties of Wales Local government in Wales Macedonia Current: 84 municipalities (out of which 10 constitute Greater Skopje) Option: 8 Statistical Regions of Macedonia Municipalities of the Republic of Macedonia Statistical Regions of Macedonia Thailand Current: 75 provinces and 2 special administrative regions Option: 6 regions and Bangkok (total 7) Provinces of Thailand Malta Current: 68 local councils Option: 6 districts Local councils of Malta Districts of Malta Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

jhattara

231 - United Kingdom 84 - Macedonia, the former Yugoslav Republic of 83 - Russian Federation 81 - Turkey 77 - Thailand 76 - Azerbaijan 68 - Malta 64 - Viet Nam 64 - Bangladesh 57 - United States 48 - Algeria 47 - Japan 43 - Hungary 42 - Romania 37 - Nigeria 37 - Moldova, Republic of 35 - India 35 - France 34 - Afghanistan 34 - China, People's Republic of 33 - Latvia 33 - Indonesia 33 - Colombia 32 - Dominican Republic 32 - Bahamas 32 - Mexico 30 - Serbia 30 - Iran, Islamic Republic of 29 - Egypt 28 - Bulgaria 27 - Brazil 27 - Ukraine 26 - Switzerland 26 - Tanzania, United Republic of 26 - Peru 25 - Seychelles 25 - Venezuela, Bolivarian Republic of 25 - Sudan 24 - Tunisia 24 - Argentina 24 - Ecuador 24 - Cambodia 23 - China, Republic of (Taiwan) 22 - Guatemala 22 - Mongolia 22 - Libyan Arab Jamahiriya 22 - Chad 21 - Croatia 21 - Sweden 21 - Norway 21 - Yemen 21 - Montenegro 20 - Maldives 20 - Italy 20 - Portugal 20 - Papua New Guinea 20 - Bhutan 19 - Côte d'Ivoire 19 - Spain 19 - Uruguay 18 - Angola 18 - Paraguay 18 - Iraq 18 - Somalia 18 - Honduras 17 - Central African Republic 17 - Burundi 17 - Philippines 17 - New Zealand 17 - Mauritius 17 - Nicaragua 16 - Germany 16 - Morocco 16 - Malaysia 16 - Kazakhstan 16 - Palau 16 - Trinidad and Tobago 16 - Lao People's Democratic Republic 16 - Korea, Republic of 16 - Poland 15 - Chile 15 - Estonia 15 - Cuba 15 - Liberia 14 - Senegal 14 - Uzbekistan 14 - Myanmar 14 - Nauru 14 - Jamaica 14 - Czech Republic 14 - El Salvador 14 - Syrian Arab Republic 13 - Canada 13 - Namibia 13 - Greece 13 - Mauritania 13 - Saudi Arabia 13 - Timor-Leste 13 - Burkina Faso 12 - Panama 12 - Benin 12 - Albania 12 - Slovenia 12 - Georgia 12 - Netherlands 12 - Jordan 11 - Ethiopia 11 - Korea, Democratic People's Republic of 11 - Congo, Democratic Republic of the (Kinshasa) 11 - Saint Lucia 11 - Congo, Republic of the (Brazzaville) 11 - Samoa 11 - Armenia 11 - Barbados 11 - Mozambique 11 - Liechtenstein 11 - Belgium 10 - Solomon Islands 10 - Lesotho 10 - Haiti 10 - Dominica 10 - Cameroon 10 - Lithuania 10 - Suriname 10 - Ghana 10 - Guyana 10 - Zimbabwe 9 - Qatar 9 - Iceland 9 - Guinea-Bissau 9 - South Africa 9 - United States Minor Outlying Islands 9 - San Marino 9 - Bolivia, Plurinational State of 9 - Oman 9 - Zambia 9 - Sri Lanka 9 - Gabon 9 - Botswana 9 - Mali 9 - Austria 8 - Kenya 8 - Australia 8 - Niger 8 - Antigua and Barbuda 8 - Guinea 8 - Lebanon 8 - Tuvalu 8 - Pakistan 8 - Kyrgyzstan 8 - Slovakia 7 - Equatorial Guinea 7 - Belarus 7 - Andorra 7 - Grenada 7 - United Arab Emirates 7 - Costa Rica 6 - Saint Vincent and the Grenadines 6 - Cyprus 6 - Turkmenistan 6 - Finland 6 - Madagascar 6 - Kuwait 6 - Belize 6 - Israel 6 - Djibouti 6 - Eritrea 6 - Vanuatu 6 - Gambia 5 - Nepal 5 - Togo 5 - Denmark 5 - Singapore 5 - Bahrain 5 - Fiji 5 - Rwanda 5 - Tonga 4 - Micronesia, Federated States of 4 - Swaziland 4 - Uganda 4 - Brunei Darussalam 4 - Sierra Leone 4 - Greenland 4 - Ireland 3 - Tajikistan 3 - Luxembourg 3 - Comoros 3 - Saint Helena, Ascension and Tristan da Cunha 3 - Kiribati 3 - Malawi 3 - Bosnia and Herzegovina 2 - Cape Verde 2 - Marshall Islands 2 - São Tomé and Príncipe 2 - Saint Kitts and Nevis Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Thargor

I'd probably say something in between options 1&2, as per how the BBC website splits the UK up: England (10): North West England North East England Yorkshire & Lincolnshire West Midlands East Midlands West & South West East South London & South East Isle of Man & Channel Island N.Ireland (1): All of Scotland (6): Edinburgh, Fife & East Glasgow & West Highlands & Islands North East, Orkney & Shetland South Scotland Tayside & Central Wales (5): North West North East Mid South West South East I make that 22 location-areas...

Squidalot

I don't think it really matters that much but I would at a minimum split UK by country/province hence England, Scotland, Wales, NI.

jhattara

This is what I found from the BBC site: BBC - Select your local site The option 1 is based on the Nomenclature of Territorial Units for Statistics . Options 2 and 3 are what I scrounged on the Wikipedia site. The main points in here would be to divide the country into meaningful sized regions, that would be preferably immediately recognizable to local population, and be verifiable by non-local population. Dividing to countries would probably serve the recognition purpose, but they would probably be geographically too large for locating events and stuff. Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Pascal Bertrand

France: I suggest - Ile-de-France - Grand Nord - Nord-Ouest - Sud-Ouest - Sud-Est - Rhône-Alpes - Centre - Grand Est These areas cover ~100 players each. The travel-time to cross one such regions is ~4h by car at max.

jhattara

The current division of France is done into the 22 regions. The rest of the regions are overseas territories. As those are the official ISO 3166-2 subdivisions of France, and comprise of meaningful sized and officially used regions, I don't think those should be changed. Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

KzArashi

Brazil is divided in 5 Regions. You can use that. Is something natural to all brazilians. When asked from where we are, we answer saying our city, state and region. Geographic and Economic Regions of Brazil: North Region Acre Amapá Amazonas Pará Rondônia Roraima Tocantins Northeast Region Alagoas Bahia Ceará Maranhão Paraíba Pernambuco Piauí Rio Grande do Norte Sergipe Central-West Region Distrito Federal Goiás Mato Grosso Mato Grosso do Sul Southeast Region Espírito Santo Minas Gerais Rio de Janeiro São Paulo South Region Paraná Rio Grande do Sul Santa Catarina Priest of Rio de Janeiro My blog: Portal Distant Kingdoms Facebook: Distant Kingdoms Youtube: Distant Shore

jhattara

Brazil isn't among those that I would see as a problem. The point in here is to reduce the amount of subdivisions in areas, where the amount of subdivisions is extremely high compared to the surface area of the country. United Kingdom: 231 subdivisions, 245,610km2 == 1055 km2/subdiv. Thailand: 77 subdivisions, 513,120 km2 == 6664 km2/subdiv. France: 37 subdivisions, 22 in Metropolitan France, 551,695 km2 == 25,100 km2/subdiv. USA: 57 subdivisions, 9.8 million km2 == 172,000 km2/subdiv. Russian Federation: 83 subdivisions, 17 million km2 == 205,000 km2/subdiv Brazil: 27 subdivisions, 8.5 million km2 == 315,000 km2/subdiv. Do you see the point with UK and Thailand? And also why e.g. France and Brasil do not need the reduction, but countries like UK and Thailand would need the reduction. Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

jhattara

Would this division make sense to people in UK? East Midlands East of England Greater London North East England North West England South East England South West England West Midlands Yorkshire and the Humber West Wales and The Valleys East Wales Eastern Scotland South Western Scotland North Eastern Scotland Highlands and Islands Northern Ireland Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Thargor

Given that Wales is taller than it is wide, I'd say East & West isn't the best split. I'd probably go with: North Mid South-West South-East

jhattara

Like this? North Wales (Gwynedd and Clwyd) Mid Wales (Dyfed and Powys) South-West Wales (Glamorgan) South-East Wales (Gwent) Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Thargor

Yes, I'd say that's a decent way to split it up...