I know that multiple vampires can be tapped for the same Brujah Debate in the Master Phase. Can you tap a Brujah Vampire that was either tapped, or did not untap, during the Untap Phase in the Master Phase to meet Brujah Debate's requirements?
For example:
Count Germaine was subject to a Rotschreck and is currently in the Ready Region with the Rotschreck still in play. During the Untap phase, Rotschreck burns leaving Count Germaine still tapped. Can Count Germaine (assuming he is the largest Brujah I have) be 'tapped' for Brujah Debate?
I would think "Yes" purely because you are also allowed to tap the same Brujah multiple times for multiple Brujah debates. But it would be nice to have a ruling or at least a debate about it...
Brujah Debate
Master
Brujah :Bruj:
1
Master.
Put this card in play. During each Methuselah's master phase, he or she taps (one of) the highest capacity Brujah he or she controls (if any). Each Brujah gets +1 strength and an optional maneuver each combat. Any minion who is not Ventrue my burn this card as a action.
Retired Baron of Sydney, Australia, 418
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> I know that multiple vampires can be tapped for the same Brujah Debate in the Master Phase.
>
That's quite wrong. Brujah Debat uses the "During X, do Y" template, which means only one Brujah gets tapped by each Brujah Debate. Do you have a link to something that says that more than one Brujah can be tapped per Brujah Debate?
>
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> Can you tap a Brujah Vampire that was either tapped, or did not untap, during the Untap Phase in the Master Phase to meet Brujah Debate's requirements?
>
The state of that Brujah in the Untap Phase is quite irrelevent. What matters (well, I guess this is what this question is about) is his state in the Master Phase.
As you noticed, one Brujah can be tapped by several Brujah Debates (which is what always happens when you have more Brujah Debates than Brujahs of the highest cap). Brujah Debate doesn't read "Tap one of your oldest untapped Brujahs". [LSJ 20010501]
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> For example:
> Count Germaine was subject to a Rotschreck and is currently in the Ready Region with the Rotschreck still in play. During the Untap phase, Rotschreck burns leaving Count Germaine still tapped. Can Count Germaine (assuming he is the largest Brujah I have) be 'tapped' for Brujah Debate?
>
Better than "can", he must be tapped by Brujah Debate.
Actually, you could tap more than one Brujah assuming you have multiple vampires that are the 'largest capacity'. For example, if you have four or five 5-caps, you could potentially tap two or three of them for the Brujah Debates. Just doing so is unlikely to be to your advantage when you can tap the same one multiple times (but might be worth it if you don't want to take hunt actions with a couple of key minions).
I also dug around for a bit longer and exercised my Google-Fu and found a Google-Group thread where LSJ said you can target a tapped vampire (from something like Sense Dep or Rotschreck) during your Master Phase to "be tapped" by the Brujah Debates. Which suits the plans I had for a certain deck perfectly.
Retired Baron of Sydney, Australia, 418
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> Actually, you could tap more than one Brujah assuming you have multiple vampires that are the 'largest capacity'. For example, if you have four or five 5-caps, you could potentially tap two or three of them for the Brujah Debates.
>
Perhaps I misunderstood your first message, but I read it is "you can tap 3 Brujahs with a single Brujah Debate"
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> I also dug around for a bit longer and exercised my Google-Fu and found a Google-Group thread where LSJ said you can target a tapped vampire (from something like Sense Dep or Rotschreck) during your Master Phase to "be tapped" by the Brujah Debates.
>
Sounds like the link I gave
Basically, you can tap anything you want, even if it is tapped in the first place.
Classic applications: Rotschreck the acting minion (tapped for being acting); Deep Song on a tapped minion; sup' Telepathic Misdirection with a tapped minion (after Wake / On the Qui Vive); and, a bit more tricky, playing Force of Will (which, as all actions do, taps the acting minion, who is already tapped).
For the record, you can also untap untapped cards. For instance, untap your untapped Hunting with House of Sorrows when it's being stolen (Disputed Territory), so that the stealer gets it tapped instead of untapped.
You can also untap (once, due to the "During" keyword in the rules) each (untapped) Infernal minion during your untap phase - useful if you're doing the maths to Parity Shift someone right away.
What you can't do is use a "tap to .." effect on a tapped card. Example: you can't Wake + Hide the Heart to reduce a bleed against another player by 2. You also can't tap a tapped Barrens to discard (and draw) a card.
One Debate taps one of the highest capacity Brujah you control, who can be tapped already by another effect.
Two Debates tap 1 or 2 of the highest capacity Brujah you control, who can be tapped already by another effect.
Three Debates tap 1, 2 or 3 of the highest capacity Brujah you control, who can be tapped already by another effect.
Four Debates tap 1, 2, 3 or 4 of the highest capacity Brujah you control, who can be tapped already by another effect.
... and so on ...
Jussi Hattara
Webmaster Extraordinaire
Finnish Politics!
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> Floppy: The link I found was from 2008, yours is much older.
>
groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/browse_frm/thread/418be79e2067fcc3/e62898f0a62538d00
is as recent as I can find (the whole thread is interesting).
But all these messages say the same thing, so there's apply recent rulings over old ones, in this case, since they're the same.
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> Yes, but the main thing is that I can use Nocturn Theater with Brujah Debate and get both effects fully.
>
Yes. You can first use Nocturn Theater and tap a vampire controlled by your prey and then use the same big-cap Brujah with all the Brujah Debates you have.
Jussi Hattara
Webmaster Extraordinaire
Finnish Politics!
> Juggernaut1981 wrote:
> Yes, but the main thing is that I can use Nocturn Theater with Brujah Debate and get both effects fully.
>
Heh! That's cute. I remember thinking that Nocturn Theater would see a lot of play in decks that were using infernal vampires, for the same reason, but I assume that it hasn't due to the difficulty in needing to defend the Theater. But if you're already planning on defending the Debates, you're also set up for the Theater as well.