VTES rules archive

LSJ- Perfectionist & Follow the Blood

15 messages from 9 participants · 07 March 2011 – 09 March 2011 · vekn.net/forum
the topic on the V:EKN forum

XZealot

A vampire with Perfectionist successfully hunts and a reacting vampire plays Follow the blood. Does the acting vampire gain the blood from Perfectionist?

Hakuron

Perfectionist Type: Master Master: archetype. Put this card on a vampire you control. Once per turn, when this vampire sucessfully performs an action and no reaction cards are played, he or she gains 1 blood after the action is resolved. A vampire can have only one archetype. Since "Follow the Blood" is a reaction card, "Perfectionist" does not trigger. National Coordinator Germany nc [dot] germany [at] magenta [dot] de

M@rc00_L

@Hakuron Technically, if you look at the timing, the requirements of perfectionist have been met before Follow the Blood can be played > Perfectionist wrote: > Master: archetype. Put this card on a vampire you control. Once per turn, when this vampire sucessfully performs an action and no reaction cards are played, he or she gains 1 blood after the action is resolved. A vampire can have only one archetype. > > Non-existant user wrote: > Requires a Black Hand vampire. Only usable when a hunt action is successful, after resolution. This Black Hand vampire taps and enters combat with the acting vampire. This reacting vampire gets an optional maneuver or press in that combat. > i.e. Action is successful and resolved then follow the blood is played so the vampire still gets his additional blood then enters combat.

Shockwave

I'd think the Vampire does not receive the blood, for precisely the bolded sections provided by M@rc00_L. Perfectionist effectively checks it's text at the end of the action, after there is no window to play further cards. In effect, gaining the Perfectionist blood confirms the action is over. Incidentally, I'd say it's fairly poor wording on Follow the Blood just because you shouldn't be playing Reactions to Actions after they're resolved, that's surely the point, but I'd guess the intent of that is to make it clear the combat is NOT part of the Action, but is entirely seperate. Here we go again.... Dave Knowles (Advanced) Sabbat Bishop of Manchester

M@rc00_L

i read the requirements as such: If action is successful and no reaction is played (during that action), then you can get +1 blood after that action is resolved. and since follow the blood has to be played after the resolution, the perfectionist's requirements have already been met so the blood is gained before they enter combat.

Boris The Blade

I think it is the same as for Freak Drive / Concoction of Vitality: Freak Drive is still part of the action, so you can't play it under Concoction. Here, follow by the blood is still part of the action, so you don't gain the blood. groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/browse_thread/thread/1e3484dbc99eff73/82b3f146e4d4f4dc?lnk=gst&q=Concoction+of+Vitality+freak+drive+author%3ALSJ+group%3Arec.games.trading-cards.jyhad#82b3f146e4d4f4dc

Pascal Bertrand

I think Perfectionist triggers immediately after resolution, which is before any reacting player would get the impulse to play Follow the Blood. Thus, gain 1+1 blood, and then Follow the Blood gets played. EDIT: And that's also LSJ's position: boardgamegeek.com/article/6401929#6401929 @ Shockwave: Perfectionist triggers after resolution, but before the end of the action. For instance, the vampire could play Freak Drive after gaining that blood (or before, same window). It's also in that window that the reacting vampire (in a different scenario) could play Touch of Pain. @ Boris: The difference here is that Perfectionist doesn't trigger as the action ends, but right after it is successful. Freak Drive can be played after gaining Perfectionist's blood Concotion of Vitality extends to the end of the action, which is after Freak Drive's window.

Kushiel

> Shockwave wrote: > ...but I'd guess the intent of that is to make it clear the combat is NOT part of the Action, but is entirely seperate. > There's no way for combat to occur except as part of an action.

M@rc00_L

> Kushiel wrote: > > > Shockwave wrote: > > ...but I'd guess the intent of that is to make it clear the combat is NOT part of the Action, but is entirely seperate. > > > There's no way for combat to occur except as part of an action. > Well Follow the Blood is a way to enter combat not as part of an action, since it happens after the action has been resolved.

jhattara

After it has resolved, but before it has ended. Timing can be a bitch. Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Pascal Bertrand

See also Siren's Lure. And Hidden Lurker. And others.

jhattara

www.boardgamegeek.com/article/6401929#6401929 > LSJ wrote: > > > floppyzedolfin wrote: > > wrote: > > Does A gain 1 blood from Perfectionist before B plays Follow the Blood? > > > > I'm under the impression that Perfectionist is immediately triggered after resolution of the action, Therefore, A gains Perfectionist's blood, and, then, B plays Follow the Blood. > > Is that correct? > > > Yes. > Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Hakuron

Thanks for this lesson ... would not have expected the case to be so tricky ... National Coordinator Germany nc [dot] germany [at] magenta [dot] de

Drain

> Shockwave wrote: > Incidentally, I'd say it's fairly poor wording on Follow the Blood just because you shouldn't be playing Reactions to Actions after they're resolved, that's surely the point, but I'd guess the intent of that is to make it clear the combat is NOT part of the Action, but is entirely seperate. > This same poor wording once had me going around in circles searching the web for official rulings. The idea was thus: To force a combat through Follow the Blood that wasn't generated during an action (something that Fast Reaction and Hidden Lurker strictly do not permit, but that FtB seemed to allow), followed by deploying Illusions of the Kindred and transfering all of the Illusion's blood to another one of my vampires via Heidelberg, which could be used in this very particular combat due to its not being "during an action". Eventually I came to realize that "You Can't Do That"(tm) Drain

Pascal Bertrand

> Drain wrote: > > > Shockwave wrote: > > Incidentally, I'd say it's fairly poor wording on Follow the Blood just because you shouldn't be playing Reactions to Actions after they're resolved, that's surely the point, but I'd guess the intent of that is to make it clear the combat is NOT part of the Action, but is entirely seperate. > > > This same poor wording once had me going around in circles searching the web for official rulings. > > The idea was thus: To force a combat through Follow the Blood that wasn't generated during an action (something that Fast Reaction and Hidden Lurker strictly do not permit, but that FtB seemed to allow), followed by deploying Illusions of the Kindred and transfering all of the Illusion's blood to another one of my vampires via Heidelberg, which could be used in this very particular combat due to its not being "during an action". > > Eventually I came to realize that "You Can't Do That"(tm) > > Drain > You can't do that for a certain reason: you're still in the action. I think it's easier to consider it this way: If there's no blocking minion, and action is successful, there is a window ("after resolution") that is still in the action (as much as "before range is set" or "end of the round" windows are part of the round). The action will end when (and only when) all players have passed using effects in that window. This window is when Perfectionist (which is a mandatory effect) triggers. This is also when Follow the Blood, Freak Drive, and other stuff happen. Still part of the action, since before the end of the action. Similrly, can't transfer 1 blood with Heidelberg Castle, and then play Freak Drive.