To avoid confusion, I thought I could put my older cards in sleeves with errated text on it. It would be a small piece of paper, with the errated text printed on it, put in front of the "normal" card text box of the sleeved card. To be clear this little piece of paper should not be greater than the card text and let thus the illustration and card name totally visible.
Should this be allowed in an official tournament and not bet considered as "proxies" ? and should be this mentioned to the judge before playing ? I should also mention it to other players before the round begins for clarity.
On my opinion it should be allowed, because the card ie a legal card with only an errata on it. But I prefer to ask.
In general old versions of a card always have the same cards as the newest version of the same card. Or are at least treated that way.
In principal you can put whatever you want in front of your cards, but the question is how this affects shuffling or the ability to tell if the next card(s) in your library is one with that piece of paper in front of it or not.
If you can determine what "type" the next card is, the judge/organizer must disallow the extra piece of paper in front of the card, because it's simply cheating. If it does not make a difference, it's still up to the judge/organizer if he allows it.
> pcmichke wrote:
> To avoid confusion, I thought I could put my older cards in sleeves with errated text on it. It would be a small piece of paper, with the errated text printed on it, put in front of the "normal" card text box of the sleeved card. To be clear this little piece of paper should not be greater than the card text and let thus the illustration and card name totally visible.
>
I've done this in a number of my decks, and it's great for casual play. It's much easier to just be able to pass the card over to someone to read rather than finding a version with the correct text (not to mention the various cards for which no printed version with the current text exists), and it's a great boon when loaning a deck to another player not to have to spend a chunk of time explaining which cards don't match their text.
> pcmichke wrote:
> Should this be allowed in an official tournament and not bet considered as "proxies" ? and should be this mentioned to the judge before playing ? I should also mention it to other players before the round begins for clarity.
>
> On my opinion it should be allowed, because the card ie a legal card with only an errata on it. But I prefer to ask.
>
I would also like to see this allowed, although that's entirely up the judge.
In my experience, provided you're using opaque sleeves and not printing on particularly thick paper, there's no effect on shuffling and no information leakage when playing the deck. I've found clear sleeves to be more problematic - especially the cheaper ones - they're generally thinner, and don't fit the cards as snugly, so if the paper shifts, it can be seen from behind the card.
--
National Coordinator
South Africa
> pcmichke wrote:
> Should this be allowed in an official tournament and not bet considered as "proxies" ? and should be this mentioned to the judge before playing ? I should also mention it to other players before the round begins for clarity.
>
> On my opinion it should be allowed, because the card ie a legal card with only an errata on it. But I prefer to ask.
>
As long as it doesn't interfere with section 130 - Marked Cards of the Judges Guidelines, I think it can be allowed.
However, I wouldn't recommend it. Either have a list of updated cardtexts, or call for a judge when a card is played without its up-to-date cardtext printed on it. I'd rather not recommend it, because this way you learn which cards have been updated and which haven't been.
When playing with a little paper for card X, you know its cardtext was updated, and you only know the correct cardtext when the card is in your hand / on the table. When someone else plays that card, the only thing that you can do is say : "I think its cardtext changed." It only costs a little amount of memory to remember the "important" changes - Aanrch Revolt, for instance.
> floppyzedolfin wrote:
> However, I wouldn't recommend it. Either have a list of updated cardtexts, or call for a judge when a card is played without its up-to-date cardtext printed on it. I'd rather not recommend it, because this way you learn which cards have been updated and which haven't been.
>
> When playing with a little paper for card X, you know its cardtext was updated, and you only know the correct cardtext when the card is in your hand / on the table. When someone else plays that card, the only thing that you can do is say : "I think its cardtext changed." It only costs a little amount of memory to remember the "important" changes - Aanrch Revolt, for instance.
>
This seems a rather strange position to me.
a) From personal experience, I'd argue that determining which cards are sufficiently errata'ed to be worth printing corrected text for is quite a good way of learning which card texts have changed.
b) How is something which helps speed up the game by reducing calls to the judge a bad thing?
c) What constitutes important? Is the current errata on zip gun ("Bearer takes 1 damage during strike resolution when striking with this gun" as opposed to the CE printing "when this gun is used") something you remember? It's a minor detail, but, because of Immortal Grapple, it's something that can come up and enough close games turn on whether a single vampire has enough blood left to play a given card that forgetting it can potentially decide a game.
--
National Coordinator
South Africa
The thing is: genuine cards are what they are. They can't be altered. They were printed that way. Anything that is not a genuine card can't be taken for certain. I'm not saying using pieces of paper enables cheating, but suppose someone uses FELDB's cardtexts (or ARDB, or .. or anything that isn't directly generated by WW / CCP / the VEKN) rather than the official cardtexts as their source, their prints can be incorrect.
a) You don't need to start checking for updated cardtexts the day before the event. You could practice before that, and then the need for papers has gone.
b) It's good if the judge trusts the players. I, as a judge, don't. That's another discussion, but basically, it ensures that if the same question is asked at two tables, they get the same answer ( == mine).
c) My criterium would be - if you play the card, you should know what the erratum / .. is. Otherwise, being aware that the printed cardtext isn't up-to-date is enough. The judge (or the other players, if everyone trusts one another on rules questions) could be called if the exact cardtext can't be given.
You can do basically the same thing, but have them off to the side. So print up the legal text on say index cards and show them to a judge before the tourney starts and have him sign them to show that he recognizes them as legal text, then if a player want the legal text, you pull out the text for that card. If they want the judge to come over still it should only be one trip, if the player constantly want judge approval dispute this, call for stalling.
> Pullen wrote:
> You can do basically the same thing, but have them off to the side. So print up the legal text ...
>
like the Offline Judges Kit...
www.vekn.net/images/stories/downloads/vtes-offline-judges-kit.zip
Just use the sticky part of a post-it and everything should be fine. If I'd be the judge of the tournament I'd not have any problem. As long as the piece of paper doesn't show at the corner of the sleeve and is thin enough to allow normal shuffling there is nothing wrong about it. I sticked little names on my War Ghouls I played. That never caused anyone to protest. Most people liked the idea to 'personalize' the Ghouls to make clear announcements who tries to block.
Baron of Frankfurt
> Joscha wrote:
> I sticked little names on my War Ghouls I played. That never caused anyone to protest.
>
Similarily a couple of years ago in EC (Göteborg/Gothenburg IIRC) I seem to recall one guy playing an Embrace deck with all Embraces having different pics of the same porn star (Jenna Jameson?). Good fun especially as no naughty bits were in the pics.
Finnish Politics!
Personally, I'd be wanting players with cards that have alternate card-text to the printed text to bring the correct text on something like index cards. Firstly so they can conceal the fact they are using the card until they play a copy. Secondly so that as a Judge it could be easily checked/edited. Thirdly, so that people on the table can just get handed the index card with the information on it.
Of course, many people might find that too much setup. I understand that. But honestly if you did it slowly over time (say in the down-time between social games at your FLGS) then the burden is far less and index cards are pretty darn cheap.
Retired Baron of Sydney, Australia, 418
What a dispute !
The purpose of my question was indeed to speed up the control of the text by using some of post-it like things to put the errated text from the white wolf site on the card without altering the card itself.
The main argument I read against this was the confidence the judge can have in this text. It can be true that a player could use an incorrect text on it. And it can be an issue. But isn't using an older text without correction the same issue ?
So the main issue could be: the confidence in player.
The other agument was the effect it has on shuffling and information leakage. As I mentioned it on the first post, my intention was to replace the text box by a piece of paper of the same size on the same position. A post-it for instance is a possibility. In this case and since the cards are sleeved, it exclude the information leakage and has no effect on shuffling.That problem can thus be avoided.
So it seems that it could be accepted or not depending on the judge meaning about this....
The other alternative is to use an index. But that means that the other players (or at least one of them) must know that the card is errated, react on it when played and know what the correct text is. And we come again on the first issue : the confidence in the player.
Looking in an index or call the judge can take some time. And if a Methuselah is playing only older cards (say Jyhad ones) it could be much time consuming.
The absolute solution should be then to know the correct text. Of course ! But if you exchange a card with somebody else after casual play or buy it on the inernet, you have to know the correct text of it.And it can lead to know ALL the errata's of ALL the cards ! And in tournament say to the other players what the correct text is. And the other players have to trust you ! Back again on the first issue !
So on one hand we have to trust somebody with every cheating possibility it can bring with it, and on the other hand we have an absolute but much time consuming solution, the index or call to the judge.
But after all this it seems that no consesual answer on my question simply exists.
I don't know. I'm pretty sure that the vast majority of players would be thankful because of your post-its. So just do it. The guys just mentioned your note should not be noticeable from the backside of the card and that you want to make sure by sticking it. So AFAIS nobody here has a problem with it.
Go confide!
Baron of Frankfurt
In my own opinion:
If you're going to make the post-its, you might as well make a simple index card (just some card about the size of a playing card) with the correct text on it. Then if people ask what the card-text is, you can show them the index card. If you want certainty that its the correct text, either use the official Cardtexts or have the Judge mark on the index card that it's the correct text. I'd happily go through a small pile (say around 4 or 5) different texts, search them up and just initial the bottom of the index card.
If you want to stick with the post-its, then make sure they cannot be seen from behind in either clear or coloured sleeves.
Retired Baron of Sydney, Australia, 418