VTES rules archive

Basic Bleed Question RE: Bounce

11 messages from 7 participants · 14 February 2011 – 28 February 2011 · vekn.net/forum
the topic on the V:EKN forum

Shockwave

So, after playing for 10 years I shouldn't be asking this, but I've managed to confuse myself because Lasombra posted the FAQ's again... Taken from the FAQ: > > When can I play Deflection / My Enemy's Enemy / Lost in Translantion / Redirection / Telepathic Misdirection? > You may play the bleed bounce cards: > > when the bleed is announced. (decline to block, then bounce) > after a stealth card is played. (decline to block, then bounce) > after a bleed modifier is played. (decline to block, then bounce) > after a card is played that makes the action unblockable. (decline to block, then bounce) > after a declaration that you will not block. (always required) > after someone else bounces the bleed to you (decline to block, then bounce) > So, we know the following is true: A. Announces Bleed B. Decline to block A. Conditioning, +3 Bleed B. Deflection to C. and the following is true... A. Announces Bleed B. Decline to block, Deflection to C. Is the following true? A. Announce Bleed B. Decline to block A. Bleed for one. B cannot now play Deflection? I don't know why, but somehow reading the FAQ has made me really unsure all over again. Here we go again.... Dave Knowles (Advanced) Sabbat Bishop of Manchester

mika

Of course B can deflect. Like you said earlier: You may play the bleed bounce cards: after a declaration that you will not block. (always required) Unless, of course, the voices inside your head convince you to otherwise, you silly bloodsucker.

drnlmza

> Shockwave wrote: > A. Announce Bleed > B. Decline to block > A. Bleed for one. > > B cannot now play Deflection? I don't know why, but somehow reading the FAQ has made me really unsure all over again. > Quoting from Section 6.2.2 of the rulebook: > Note that moving past the block attempts (when all Methuselahs have declined to block) is an event and so allows the acting Methuselah (and others) to play more cards and effects. > So, in response to this event, B can still play deflection, after A declares he's not playing an action modifier. -- National Coordinator South Africa

Juggernaut1981

Option 1 MethA: Declare no Blocks MethB: Declares bleed amount MethA: May declare a deflection/flick Option 2 MethA: Declare no Blocks MethB: Declares bleed amount OR plays bleed modifier (and declares new amount) MethA: Declares deflection/flick Retired Baron of Sydney, Australia, 418

Shockwave

Thanks guys, that's four confirmations (once from jhattara too on IRC) so I'll stop being silly now. I think I just confused myself re-reading it for the first time in a while. Here we go again.... Dave Knowles (Advanced) Sabbat Bishop of Manchester

jhattara

Declining to block is an event, so the following chains are both acceptable. A. Announces a Bleed for 1 B. Decline to block A. Bleed for one. (pass) B. No reactions. (pass, burns 1 pool) OR A. Announces a Bleed for 1 B. Decline to block A. Bleed for one. (pass) B. Bounce forward Jussi Hattara Webmaster Extraordinaire Finnish Politics!

Juggernaut1981

Just as a side-thing remember: A successful bleed does pool damage (so a 0-bleed is not a successful bleed action) but any unblocked and uncancelled action is a successful action (so a 0-bleed is a successful action but unsuccessful bleed as long as it is not cancelled or blocked). Retired Baron of Sydney, Australia, 418

Pascal Bertrand

Also remember that, if B declines block, A only gets the impulse to play her Conditioning once C, D and E have declined blocks (in case Anneke / Eagle's Sights are around).

pcmichke

i have another question about bounce. Shoud this sequence be legal : A: Bleed B: have all minions tapped and thus decline to block A: increase bleed B: Plays "On the qui vive" to play a bounce reaction card The question is thus since "On the qui vive" says that the tapped minion can attempt to block and play reaction cards as untapped, could this only be used after block decline to play a bounce reaction card card like "redirection" or "Telepathic misdirection" ?

drnlmza

> pcmichke wrote: > The question is thus since "On the qui vive" says that the tapped minion can attempt to block and play reaction cards as untapped, could this only be used after block decline to play a bounce reaction card card like "redirection" or "Telepathic misdirection" ? > Since "On the Qui Vive" doesn't commit the minion to a block attempt, that's perfectly legal. Using something like "Eluding the Arms of Morpheus" , for example, wouldn't be allowed at this point since it requires a a block attempt. -- National Coordinator South Africa

pcmichke

thanks for confirming this. I already played it like this, but once a player told me that it wasn't legal because of the "and" between block and reaction. I did not agree, but I didn't took it back to prevent to argue with him since it was casual play. and i asked confirmation for sure.