Non repeat action rule q.!!

Jorge Ramirez wrote: > > what about an unsuccesfull action? (I mean an action blocked) You may not repeat an action even if it was unsuccessful. James -- James Hamblin je...@cornell.edu ------------------------------------------------------------------------ "Only one human captain has ever survived battle with the Minbari fleet. He is behind me. You are in front of me. If you value your lives, be somewhere else." -- Ambassador Delenn, "Babylon 5: Severed Dreams"

Hello, I have got a question: The exact rule about non repeating actions says: "no single vampire can repeat actions in a single turn", but then it says:"for example if a vampire succesfully bleeds his pray with computer hacking and then untaps with freak drive it cannot take any bleed action again" here goes my question: what about an unsuccesfull action? (I mean an action blocked) if I untap after a blocked bleed action (with Majesty for example), me I bleed again and again while blocked as far as my bleed succeeds? I think it would be O.K. because it does not allow any "break" combo (like ciclic gangrel one) and keeps the quality of cards like majesty. Some one knows official version of this? Thanks, anyway Jorge. Email answers to: A93...@zipi.fi.upm.es

On Wed, 20 Nov 1996, James Hamblin wrote: > Jorge Ramirez wrote: > > > > what about an unsuccesfull action? (I mean an action blocked) > > You may not repeat an action even if it was unsuccessful. That's only if you play with "Sensible Jyhad players rules," which in all terms is a "house rule." [ quoted text not captured ]

[ quoted text not captured ] Where did you get this rule from? This rule is not found in any rulebook or supplement. Unless you check the Sensible Jyhad Players rules, which, in any case is a set of "house rules." You do not have to play with these rules. M.

matthieu miyamoto <miya...@ece.orst.edu> writes: >On Thu, 21 Nov 1996, Jorge Ramirez wrote: >> The exact rule about non repeating actions says: "no single vampire >> can repeat actions in a single turn", but then it says:"for example if >> a vampire succesfully bleeds his pray with computer hacking and then >> untaps with freak drive it cannot take any bleed action again" here >> goes my question: >> what about an unsuccesfull action? (I mean an action blocked) if I >> untap after a blocked bleed action (with Majesty for example), me I >> bleed again and again while blocked as far as my bleed succeeds? >> I think it would be O.K. because it does not allow any "break" combo >> (like ciclic gangrel one) and keeps the quality of cards like majesty. >> Some one knows official version of this? (To answer the original query - the "no repeat actions" includes unsuccessful actions. A minion may not attempt the same action more than once per turn. The same minion may not attempt another bleed action if the first was blocked, even if he untaps with Majesy/Freak Drive) >Where did you get this rule from? >This rule is not found in any rulebook or supplement. Unless you check >the Sensible Jyhad Players rules, which, in any case is a set of "house >rules." You do not have to play with these rules. You mean: "Unless you want to play by the ocfficial DCI rules..." (which are not house rules). Official DCI rules are available from WotC's web page: http://www.wizards.com/DCI/VTES_Rules.html -- L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.sc.edu) | Eschew http://www.math.sc.edu/cgi-bin/sjohnson/home | Obfuscation Graphics Specialist and V:tES Rulemonger. |

matthieu miyamoto <miya...@ece.orst.edu> writes: >On Wed, 20 Nov 1996, James Hamblin wrote: >> Jorge Ramirez wrote: >> > what about an unsuccesfull action? (I mean an action blocked) >> >> You may not repeat an action even if it was unsuccessful. >That's only if you play with "Sensible Jyhad players rules," which in all >terms is a "house rule." It is part of the official DCI rules, and will probably be incorporated in the next release of the main rules. The DCI is by no terms a "house rule". SPTR: No repeat actions, no vote pushing. DCI: No repeat actions, PAs burned for votes aren't replaced 'til end of turn. [ quoted text not captured ]