rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

Remove from game = Burn?

6 messages from 5 participants · 05 March 2007 – 06 March 2007
original thread on Google Groups

adam....@gmail.com

Just curious, when a card in play is "removed from game" is that card considered burned? Looking at some sort of Reanimated Corpse + Consume the Dead combo...

LSJ

adam....@gmail.com wrote: > Just curious, when a card in play is "removed from game" is that card > considered burned? No.

PaulW...@gmail.com

When you remove a card from the game it is not placed in your discard pile. It can therefore not be retrieved with cards which allow you to retrieve burned cards. The card is truly removed from the game for the duration of the game. You can see it as if the card wasn't in your library in the first place.

Jozxyqk

PaulW...@gmail.com wrote: > When you remove a card from the game it is not placed in your discard > pile. > It can therefore not be retrieved with cards which allow you to > retrieve burned cards. I think the original poster was trying to ask if "when a card is burned" effects are triggered when a card is removed from the game. (The answer is still no). > The card is truly removed from the game for the duration of the game. > You can see it as if the card wasn't in your library in the first > place. Not quite. Contested cards are "removed from the game" during their contestation, but they come back. So are vampires who have used Descent into Darkness, or cards on a Banished vampire, etc.

LSJ

Jozxyqk wrote: >> The card is truly removed from the game for the duration of the game. >> You can see it as if the card wasn't in your library in the first >> place. > > Not quite. Contested cards are "removed from the game" during their > contestation, but they come back. So are vampires who have used > Descent into Darkness, or cards on a Banished vampire, etc. Not quite. Contested cards are out of play (for the duration of the contest, except with respect to being further contested), but are not removed from the game. Similarly, Descent into Darkness, Banishment cards, &c. are not removed from the game.

gpett...@gmail.com

On Mar 5, 10:37 am, "adam.hu...@gmail.com" <adam.hu...@gmail.com> wrote: [ quoted text not captured ] I believe the answer you want is no. A burned card is burned. A card that is removed from the game never enters the ash heap and does not trigger "when this card is burned" effects. -- - Gregory Stuart Pettigrew