rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

(LSJ) Quick Rotschreck vs S:CE Question

4 messages from 3 participants · 25 November 2009 – 27 November 2009
source archive

Peter D Bakija

This just came up on JOL, and there is a dispute. And the various answers we found by searching, while answering the question, aren't as direct as the following: Situation: I block my opponent. In combat, my opponent plays Form of Mist at superior to end combat and continue the action at +1 stealth. I declare an aggravated hand strike with Chiropteran Marauder. I then play Rotschreck. Does this immediately end combat and send my opponent to torpor? Thanks, -Peter

LSJ

Peter D Bakija wrote: > This just came up on JOL, and there is a dispute. And the various > answers we found by searching, while answering the question, aren't as > direct as the following: > > Situation: I block my opponent. In combat, my opponent plays Form of > Mist at superior to end combat and continue the action at +1 stealth. > I declare an aggravated hand strike with Chiropteran Marauder. I then > play Rotschreck. > > Does this immediately end combat and send my opponent to torpor? Yes.

Peter D Bakija

On Nov 24, 9:54 pm, LSJ <vtes...@white-wolf.com> wrote: > Peter D Bakija wrote: > > This just came up on JOL, and there is a dispute. And the various > > answers we found by searching, while answering the question, aren't as > > direct as the following: > > > Situation: I block my opponent. In combat, my opponent plays Form of > > Mist at superior to end combat and continue the action at +1 stealth. > > I declare an aggravated hand strike with Chiropteran Marauder. I then > > play Rotschreck. > > > Does this immediately end combat and send my opponent to torpor? > > Yes. Thank you for the quick answer! -Peter

Salem

Peter D Bakija wrote: > On Nov 24, 9:54 pm, LSJ <vtes...@white-wolf.com> wrote: >> Peter D Bakija wrote: >> > This just came up on JOL, and there is a dispute. And the various >> > answers we found by searching, while answering the question, aren't as >> > direct as the following: >> >> > Situation: I block my opponent. In combat, my opponent plays Form of >> > Mist at superior to end combat and continue the action at +1 stealth. >> > I declare an aggravated hand strike with Chiropteran Marauder. I then >> > play Rotschreck. >> >> > Does this immediately end combat and send my opponent to torpor? >> >> Yes. > > Thank you for the quick answer! How did you not know the answer to that Peter? That's the classic anti-s:ce use of Rotschrek! The fact that FoM has a 'continue action' instead of Majesty's 'untap' makes no difference at all. :) -- salem (got rotschreked. then when my grandprey got rotschrecked i told him he could save himself with a psyche! then realised i'd had a psyche in hand when i was rotschreked. *facepalm*)