Khalu and action cancellation

If Khalu cancels an action card with his special, does the acting minion still tap? "Khalu may burn 5 blood to cancel a minion card played by your predator or prey as it is played (no cost is paid)." Kevin Walsh

yes Kevin Walsh schreef: [ quoted text not captured ]

[ quoted text not captured ] No. Just like Direct Intervention. The card is canceled as-played, so the acting minion does not tap, and can even play another copy of the same action card.

[ quoted text not captured ] This always confuses me. Direct Intervention Cancel a minion card as it is played. -> minion DOESN'T use his minion-phase action Sudden Reversal Cancel a master card played by another Methuselah as it is played (no cost is paid). -> meth DOES lose his master action why? I dunno. Just coz. DI has more explicit text stating that the minion remains untapped etc, though this sounds like that is merely "reminder" text rather than over-ruling the default. Yet sudden doesn't doesnt have any text stating you DO lose your MPA, implying *that* is also the default.

RocketEddy <eddy...@aol.com> wrote: > LSJ wrote: > > Jozxyqk wrote: > > > Kevin Walsh <hja...@redbrick.dcu.ie> wrote: > > > > If Khalu cancels an action card with his special, does the acting > > > > minion still tap? > > > > > > > "Khalu may burn 5 blood to cancel a minion card played by your predator > > > > or prey as it is played (no cost is paid)." > > > > > > No. Just like Direct Intervention. The card is canceled as-played, so > > > the acting minion does not tap, and can even play another copy of the > > > same action card. > > > > Correct > This always confuses me. > Direct Intervention > Cancel a minion card as it is played. > -> minion DOESN'T use his minion-phase action > Sudden Reversal > Cancel a master card played by another Methuselah as it is played (no > cost is paid). > -> meth DOES lose his master action > why? Section 5 of the rulebook says (emphasis mine): "By default, you receive only one master phase action....You may use a master phase action to PLAY A MASTER CARD,..." Playing the card counts as your Master Phase Action, regardless of how the card resolves (or doesn't). Playing a minion card has no such restriction.

RocketEddy wrote: > LSJ wrote: > > Jozxyqk wrote: > > > Kevin Walsh <hja...@redbrick.dcu.ie> wrote: > > > > If Khalu cancels an action card with his special, does the acting > > > > minion still tap? > > > > > > > "Khalu may burn 5 blood to cancel a minion card played by your predator > > > > or prey as it is played (no cost is paid)." > > > > > > No. Just like Direct Intervention. The card is canceled as-played, so > > > the acting minion does not tap, and can even play another copy of the > > > same action card. > > > > Correct > > This always confuses me. > > Direct Intervention > Cancel a minion card as it is played. > -> minion DOESN'T use his minion-phase action A minion doesn't have a limit/quote on his minion-phase actions. That is, he doesn't receive a minion phase action which he may spend to attempt an action. Attempting an action, not playing a card, taps the minion. If the action card which would have begun the action is canceled, then the minion doesn't attempt the action (and therefore doesn't tap for the attempt). He played an action card. The card was canceled. The action is not begun. > Sudden Reversal > Cancel a master card played by another Methuselah as it is played (no > cost is paid). > -> meth DOES lose his master action He spent the MPA to play the card, yes. The card was indeed played (and canceled "as played", but played nonetheless). He spent an MPA. He played a master card. The card was canceled.

LSJ wrote: > If the action card which would have begun the action is canceled, then > the minion doesn't attempt the action (and therefore doesn't tap for > the attempt). > I can't find it now, but I seem to recall you ruling that costs for cancelled cards are not automatically refunded, and that this is a function of card text. If my memory is correct, does this mean that when Khalu uses his ability, cancelled action cards don't cost anything, but other cards which are cancelled do? Kevin Walsh

Kevin Walsh wrote: > I can't find it now, but I seem to recall you ruling that costs for > cancelled cards are not automatically refunded, and that this is a > function of card text. Correct. > If my memory is correct, does this mean that when Khalu uses his > ability, cancelled action cards don't cost anything, but other cards > which are cancelled do? No. Card text: "(no cost is paid)".