[LSJ] Nightmare Curse legal targets

Name: Nightmare Curse [BL] Cardtype: Action Cost: 2 blood Discipline: Auspex & Chimerstry [chi] (D) Tap a ready minion and untap this acting vampire. [aus][chi] (D) Put this card on a ready minion and tap that minion. This minion doesn't untap as normal. During this minion's controller's untap, he or she may burn a pool to untap this minion. Burn this card when the acting vampire leaves play. [AUS][CHI] (D) Put this card on a ready minion and tap that minion. This minion doesn't untap as normal. Burn this card when the acting vampire leaves play. Can a vampire play Nightmare Curse at any of its three discipline levels on a TAPPED minion? Greetings, Damnans

"Damnans" <damna...@ono.com> wrote in message news:zyDq9.6788> >Can a vampire play Nightmare Curse at any of its three discipline levels on > a TAPPED minion? On the argument that you can tap a tapped minion I would say you can play any of the three with the tap a minion effect targeting an already tapped minion. -JTP

[ quoted text not captured ] None of the texts say that the card must be played on an "untapped" minion. And since you can tap a tapped minion I believe it is possible.

Damnans wrote: :: Name: Nightmare Curse :: [BL] :: Cardtype: Action :: Cost: 2 blood :: Discipline: Auspex & Chimerstry :: [chi] (D) Tap a ready minion (...) :: [AUS][CHI] (D) Put this card on a ready minion and tap that :: minion. (...) can be played on an untapped minion : see the contrast with Mind numb ;)

[ quoted text not captured ] Correct. -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. Links to V:TES news, rules, cards, utilities, and tournament calendar: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

> > > > "Damnans" <damna...@ono.com> wrote in message news:zyDq9.6788> > > >Can a vampire play Nightmare Curse at any of its three discipline levels on > > > a TAPPED minion? > > > > On the argument that you can tap a tapped minion > > I would say you can play any of the three with the > > tap a minion effect targeting an already tapped minion. > > Correct. Another Q: if i play a nightmare curse (basic level aus/chi) on a minion with an already existing nightmare curse (same basic level aus/chi) will the controller now pay 2 pool just to untap that minion? i hope the answer is yes :) johann

Johann wrote: > Another Q: if i play a nightmare curse (basic level aus/chi) on a > minion with an already existing nightmare curse (same basic level > aus/chi) will the controller now pay 2 pool just to untap that minion? No. It means that she'll have two different effects which allow her to pay 1 pool to untap him. [ quoted text not captured ]