rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

question: Once per action

6 messages from 4 participants · 28 March 2008
original thread on Google Groups

Baaliprimogen

Hi I might have a very stupid question, but suddenly I got very unsecure. Here is the question: If there is an effect on a minion to burn something. May they then burn more of that to gain more of the same effect? Exsample: Maman Boumba Clan: Imbued (group 4) Capacity: 4 Disciplines: inn mar During a referendum, Maman may burn a conviction [1 CONVICTION] to get 3 votes against the referendum. You may tap Maman before range is determined in a combat between two monsters to end that combat. -May she burn 2 conviction to get 6 votes? Amaravati Clan: Assamite (group 4) Capacity: 8 Disciplines: DOM OBF QUI ani chi Independent: During a political action, Amaravati may burn 2 blood to give each ready Assamite you control an additional vote. Blood Cursed. -May Amaravati burn 4 blood to give each assamite 2 votes? Callirus Clan: Ravnos (group 4) Capacity: 5 Disciplines: CHI FOR ani Independent: During your untap phase, Callirus can burn 1 blood to burn one card on him. -may Callirus burn 2 blood to burn 2 cards? You get the my meaning.

LSJ

Baaliprimogen wrote: > Hi I might have a very stupid question, but suddenly I got very > unsecure. Here is the question: > If there is an effect on a minion to burn something. May they then > burn more of that to gain more of the same effect? Depends on whether card text allows it. > Exsample: > Maman Boumba > Clan: Imbued (group 4) > Capacity: 4 > Disciplines: inn mar > During a referendum, Maman may burn a conviction [1 CONVICTION] to get > 3 votes against the referendum. You may tap Maman before range is > determined in a combat between two monsters to end that combat. > > -May she burn 2 conviction to get 6 votes? No. "During X, do Y" limits Y to once per X. So Once each referendum, Maman may burn a conviction to... > Amaravati > Clan: Assamite (group 4) > Capacity: 8 > Disciplines: DOM OBF QUI ani chi > Independent: During a political action, Amaravati may burn 2 blood to > give each ready Assamite you control an additional vote. Blood Cursed. > > -May Amaravati burn 4 blood to give each assamite 2 votes? No. > Callirus > Clan: Ravnos (group 4) > Capacity: 5 > Disciplines: CHI FOR ani > Independent: During your untap phase, Callirus can burn 1 blood to > burn one card on him. > > -may Callirus burn 2 blood to burn 2 cards? No. > You get the my meaning. Yes.

Baaliprimogen

[ quoted text not captured ] > Thank you LSJ!- Skjul sitert tekst - > > - Vis sitert tekst - But, If they can't, why may Maris Streck use her ability more than once (as per all rulings from WW's pages)? Maris Streck [CE:V] Cardtype: Vampire Clan: Malkavian Group: 3 Capacity: 9 Discipline: ani dem dom AUS OBF Camarilla Malkavian Justicar: Maris can burn a blood to give a blocking minion +1 intercept. She can take a +1 stealth action to allow you to look at and rearrange the top 5 cards of your library.

Klai...@gmail.com

[ quoted text not captured ] > allow you to look at and rearrange the top 5 cards of your library.- Piilota siteerattu teksti - > > - Näytä siteerattu teksti - That is because Maris' text doesn't say 'During an action Maris can burn a blood to give a blocking minion +1 intercept.' So there is no 'during X' clause there.

Johannes Walch

Klai...@gmail.com schrieb: [ quoted text not captured ] Actually that is because she is broken ;-) But regarding the rules you are right ...

Baaliprimogen

On 28 Mar, 13:17, Johannes Walch <johannes.wa...@vekn.de> wrote: > Klaita...@gmail.com schrieb: [ quoted text not captured ] > are right ...- Skjul sitert tekst - > > - Vis sitert tekst - Ok. so during = once. Thanks guys