rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

Edge Explosion burned, confusion ensues

3 messages from 3 participants · 18 May 2007
original thread on Google Groups

Petri Wessman

The following came up in a game last night: an Imbued deck had Edge Explosion out and had used it to play Powers on Imbued who didn't have the matching creeds. Soon after, the Edge Explosion was burned (with a Black Hand Ritual). After this, we tried to figure out what happens to the Powers on the Imbued who had gotten them via the Edge Explosion, and became generally confused. Do they burn, too, since the card (EE) enabling them to "have and use" them is burned? Do they just become unusable (but stay on the Imbued)? Do they stay in game and usable (since they are already in play when EE got burned)? Do aliens from Atlantis come over and wipe your memory (and steal your cards)? Only the Shadow knows... Seriously, anyone have a clue or a relevant ruling? Not that this is a very common occurrence, but it still would be interesting to know. For reference: Edge Explosion: Gehenna. Requires at least one other Gehenna card in play. Each imbued can have (and use) one power card for which he or she doesn't meet the requirements. An imbued who performs a successful action may gain 1 conviction from his or her ash heap. An imbued can only gain 1 conviction this way each turn.

Bram Vink

[ quoted text not captured ] I'd assume the following: It's possible to have cards you do not fulfill the requirements for. As far as I know the requirement on most cards that stick into play is checked (bar cardtext) only when playing the card. The difficult part is that it's not clear wether the requirement translates to the use of the power card. Since there's no clear indication towards the use of powers requiring anything else than tapping/conviction, I'd guess you both retain your powers, and can use them. So my guess would be that in essence the text on Edge Explosion is slightly misleading, and the "have (and use)" basically refers to the successful retrieval of one single power card, but is in common use clearer in wording as it is. Cheers, Bram

LSJ

Petri Wessman wrote: > The following came up in a game last night: an Imbued deck had Edge > Explosion out and had used it to play Powers on Imbued who didn't have > the matching creeds. > > Soon after, the Edge Explosion was burned (with a Black Hand Ritual). > > After this, we tried to figure out what happens to the Powers on the > Imbued who had gotten them via the Edge Explosion, and became > generally confused. Do they burn, too, since the card (EE) enabling > them to "have and use" them is burned? Do they just become unusable > (but stay on the Imbued)? Do they stay in game and usable (since they > are already in play when EE got burned)? Do aliens from Atlantis come > over and wipe your memory (and steal your cards)? Only the Shadow > knows... Stay and are usable. [ quoted text not captured ]