rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

Is this legal ?

11 messages from 9 participants · 05 March 1995 – 16 March 1995
original thread on Google Groups

Intimate apperal

I am trying to build a new deck, and want to know if the following procedure is legal: 1. Bring out smudge 2. Play a skill on him 3. Equip with arron's feeding razor 4. Put TWO blood dolls on him(I understand this takes two master phases ) 5. Hunt 6. On next turn, pull blood off, hunt again :-) 7. Repeat step 6 for remainder of game. Also, straighten me out on this - Day operation says "cannot be blocked" - this is quite lucid and consice(unlike other Jyhad cards :-) ) Is there any way to block it ? - tony

Harpua

In article <Pine.A32.3.91.950305...@blue.weeg.uiowa.edu>, Intimate apperal <abr...@blue.weeg.uiowa.edu> wrote: [ quoted text not captured ] about the blood dolls, i could be mistaken, but i think you can only have one blood doll on a vamp at a time. the reasoning, a blood doll is a blood doll- a physical slave to the methusala. there was some discussion about the day operation thingy, but i believe that it is not blockable. eagle's sight or anneke would be the only methods of blocking if at all, but i don't think so: unblockable means unblockable. if they use that to bleed you, telepathic counter. if they use it with fame, use the appropriate boon; it's either life boon or minor boon- i get them mixed up. harpua

L. Scott Johnson

Intimate apperal <abr...@blue.weeg.uiowa.edu> writes: >Also, straighten me out on this - Day operation says "cannot be blocked" >- this is quite lucid and consice(unlike other Jyhad cards :-) ) Is there >any way to block it ? Official mis-errata is that Eagle's Sight can block it. This stems from the fact that Eagle's Sight can block otherwise unblockable actions like the (mis-errata'ed) Rampage when used against yourself. Since we can block this "unblockable" action, we can block *any* unblockable action. Hrmph. The ruling is under dispute. (BTW, Rampage should've had errata stating that it is not a directed action when taken against oneself, but ...) Also, if a Brujah is taking the Day Op, you can Frenzy him, which blocks the action. (Not that Brujah typically have fortitude, but...) L. Scott

Martin Filion

[ quoted text not captured ] There's no way to block a Day Operation. Isn't that beautifull? And yes... The Blood Doll thing with your Caitiff is a good way to have "free" blood, but I know a better way... You tap Eco Terrorist to put a blood on an uncontrolled vampire, and you use 2 transfers to put the blood from your uncontrolled vampire to your blood pool. Martin Filion Montreal, Qb (Canada) mordillo@gmgate@gamemaster.qc.ca

Joseph Cochran

In article <D52z9...@rco.qc.ca>, Martin Filion <mord...@vircom.com> wrote: >> Also, straighten me out on this - Day operation says "cannot be blocked" >> - this is quite lucid and consice(unlike other Jyhad cards :-) ) Is there >> any way to block it ? > > There's no way to block a Day Operation. Isn't that beautifull? Except with Eagle's Sight. DTR from 10/6/94, question #27. No further DTR about this have been issued. | If you've got a hot lead on a new | *--Joe--* | PC game, call the announce line at | js...@vt.edu | ** csi...@discus.ise.vt.edu ** | +-------------------------------------+---------------------------------- "Carnivores, oy!" -- Timon, TLK

Thomas R Wylie

Joseph Cochran <js...@discus.ise.vt.edu> wrote: >>> Also, straighten me out on this - Day operation says "cannot be blocked" >>> - this is quite lucid and consice(unlike other Jyhad cards :-) ) Is there >>> any way to block it ? >> There's no way to block a Day Operation. Isn't that beautifull? > Except with Eagle's Sight. DTR from 10/6/94, question #27. No >further DTR about this have been issued. Actually, we're pretty sure this was reversed, and it simply never made it into a DTR. Specifically, Eagle's Sight is only allowing the vampire to ignore the usual restrictions as to which players may attempt to block an action, and does not override all restrictions such as Day Operation, Seduction, etc. Hopefully the reversal will be confirmed in the next DTR. Tom Wylie rec.games.trading-cards.* Network Representative for aa...@cats.ucsc.edu Wizards of the Coast, Inc.

James R. McClure Jr.

aa...@cats.ucsc.edu (Thomas R Wylie) wrote: > Joseph Cochran <js...@discus.ise.vt.edu> wrote: > >>> Also, straighten me out on this - Day operation says "cannot be blocked" > >>> - this is quite lucid and consice(unlike other Jyhad cards :-) ) Is there > >>> any way to block it ? > >> There's no way to block a Day Operation. Isn't that beautifull? > > Except with Eagle's Sight. DTR from 10/6/94, question #27. No > >further DTR about this have been issued. > > Actually, we're pretty sure this was reversed, and it simply never made it > into a DTR. Specifically, Eagle's Sight is only allowing the vampire to > ignore the usual restrictions as to which players may attempt to block > an action, and does not override all restrictions such as Day Operation, > Seduction, etc. Hopefully the reversal will be confirmed in the next DTR. Peace Thomas, YEAH! Unblockable Day Ops again! Just another reason for my change to Fame. Give Ventrue some respect again. Legal Manip + Day Ops + Conditioning! Nil carborundum illigitimi, James R. McClure Jr. The OS/2 Apostle <insert disclaimer here>

Alan Kwan

[ quoted text not captured ] Above combo is a balance problem of Fame, and Fame alone, and IMO should not have any influence on rulings concerning Day Operation. Sure you can do LM + DO + Conditioning combo, but you pay 3 blood right away and go to torpor. A Malk can do hard-to-block S&B for big bleeds anyway, without having to go to torpor. -- "Live Life with Heart." Alan Kwan kw...@cs.cornell.edu

James R. McClure Jr.

[ quoted text not captured ] Peace Alan, The two lines of my post (above) are not directly related. I was reiterating that Fame is broken (unblockable Day Op + Fame is another good reason for my suggested change to Fame). I was also saying that Ventrue might get some more respect now that they can do serious UNBLOCKABLE bleeds again. As Ventrue, about the only way you can do real bleeds, IMO, is lots of Majesty (can be countered by lots of Wakes) or Dawn/Day Ops to discourage/prohibit intercept. I'm glad that Day Ops is unblockable. [ quoted text not captured ]

Karl J. Hiller

Thomas R Wylie (aa...@cats.ucsc.edu) wrote: : Actually, we're pretty sure this was reversed, and it simply never made it : into a DTR. Specifically, Eagle's Sight is only allowing the vampire to : ignore the usual restrictions as to which players may attempt to block : an action, and does not override all restrictions such as Day Operation, : Seduction, etc. Hopefully the reversal will be confirmed in the next DTR. DTR means Design Team Ruling? Yes? Where does one find DTRs? Is there an ftp site? Brand -- br...@iglou.com "How fortunate for those in power, that people do not think." - A. Hitler "Hellllooooooooo Nurse!!!" - Yakko, Wakko, and Dot

Joseph Cochran

In article <D5Hn...@iglou.com>, Karl J. Hiller <br...@iglou.iglou.com> wrote: >DTR means Design Team Ruling? Yes? > >Where does one find DTRs? Is there an ftp site? As of now, there's no archive that I know of, but I'll put a copy of them up for anyone who wants them. Check Thursday, March 16, after 3:00pm. It'll be available via anonymous ftp from discus.ise.vt.edu in the directory pub/outgoing/jsciv. [ quoted text not captured ]