rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

NRA vs Card in Play

4 messages from 4 participants · 23 February 2009 – 24 February 2009
original thread on Google Groups

Jeff Kuta

I was just reading some old rulings and got confused (mainly since the text for Archon changed). Vamp A has Pulled Fangs on them. Can they take an action to burn the fangs, Freak Drive to untap, then burn the fangs again? I would say no since Pulled Fangs is a card in play. Vamp B is Tariq. Tariq rushes a vampire using his special enter combat action, gets all nasty and diablerizes the vampire. Can Tariq freak drive to untap, then rush another vampire? I'd say no because Tariq is a card in play. The old Archon didn't stay in play, just made the vamp an Archon which had that ability and it was ruled to be not restricted by NRA. Are there any actions aside from the defined ones that can get around the NRA rule? Thanks. Jeff

Juggernaut1981

[ quoted text not captured ] My understanding of the NRA rule, in an "intent" way is this: For every vampire you can: Bleed once Use a card of a particular name once from your hand Use the text of a card in play once, Multiple copies of a card in play with the same name are treated as separate cards Other actions that do not require cards, can be performed multiple times.

carn...@gmail.com

On Feb 23, 4:00 pm, Jeff Kuta <jeff.k...@gmail.com> wrote: > I was just reading some old rulings and got confused (mainly since the > text for Archon changed). > > Vamp A has Pulled Fangs on them. Can they take an action to burn the > fangs, Freak Drive to untap, then burn the fangs again? I would say no > since Pulled Fangs is a card in play. He cannot (you are correct.) > Vamp B is Tariq. Tariq rushes a vampire using his special enter combat > action, gets all nasty and diablerizes the vampire. Can Tariq freak > drive to untap, then rush another vampire? I'd say no because Tariq is > a card in play. He cannot (you are correct.) > The old Archon didn't stay in play, just made the vamp an Archon which > had that ability and it was ruled to be not restricted by NRA. That is why Archon got changed, because you could make some really broken loops with Tyler, among other problems (rush, amaranth, untap, rush again, etc.) > Are > there any actions aside from the defined ones that can get around the > NRA rule? Not that I can think of offhand, those loopholes have generally been closed when found. > Thanks. > > Jeff -John Flournoy

LSJ

[ quoted text not captured ] Depends on what you mean "get around". Hunting "gets around" the NRA rule, by not being restricted by it. Similarly rescuing and diablerie (and burning incapacitated imbued, aka pillow facing). And the action to put a card in play is different than the action provided by the card (so, you could put a Call the Great Beast card in play, untap, and take the action to add a ritual counter to it; Clandestine Contract is another favorite example of this).