rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

[LSJ] Flesh of Marble, Carrion Crows and Disarm

3 messages from 3 participants · 18 October 2005
original thread on Google Groups

JH

I attack with a vampire with ANI POT FOR against a vampire with PRO. Before range I play Carrion Crows and he play Flesh of Marble. Both strike hands for 1. In the strike resolution I prevent his hand strike for 1. Can he choose to suffer 1 damage from Carrion Crows and prevent my hand strike with Flesh of Marble thus preventing me from playing Disarm? Or do I as an acting minion choose which damage effect resolves first? What if my vampire was blocking minion?

LSJ

JH wrote: > I attack with a vampire with ANI POT FOR against a vampire with PRO. > Before range I play Carrion Crows and he play Flesh of Marble. Both > strike hands for 1. In the strike resolution I prevent his hand strike > for 1. > > Can he choose to suffer 1 damage from Carrion Crows and prevent my > hand strike with Flesh of Marble thus preventing me from playing Disarm? Yes. > Or do I as an acting minion choose which damage effect resolves first? No. The effects resolve simultaneously. > What if my vampire was blocking minion? Same.

Gregory Stuart Pettigrew

> I attack with a vampire with ANI POT FOR against a vampire with PRO. > Before range I play Carrion Crows and he play Flesh of Marble. Both > strike hands for 1. In the strike resolution I prevent his hand strike > for 1. > > Can he choose to suffer 1 damage from Carrion Crows and prevent my > hand strike with Flesh of Marble thus preventing me from playing Disarm? > Yes. > Or do I as an acting minion choose which damage effect resolves first? > They resolve simultaneously. Strike Resolution is the *only* time things resolve simultaneously. > What if my vampire was blocking minion? > Same. The Blocking Minion's strike, the Acting Minion's strike, and all "during strike resolution" environmental effects resolve simultaneously. -Gregory Stuart Pettigrew