Sudden Reversal Q

I may have already figured this one out, but I wanted to be sure and get some other players opinions. Here is the example of play: Mike plays Minion Tap. Brian plays Sudden Reversal to cancel the Minion Tap Mike plays Sudden Reversal to cancel Brian's Sudden Reversal. Is that a legal play? We finally decided that it was, and that the Minion Tap was successful. The only thing I was not sure about is whether or not you can play Sudden Reversal on your own turn, and it can only be played during another Methuselah's turn. Comments please. Thanks. -- Posted via Mailgate.ORG Server - http://www.Mailgate.ORG

Brian Iverson wrote: > > I may have already figured this one out, but I wanted to be sure and get > some other players opinions. > > Here is the example of play: > > Mike plays Minion Tap. > Brian plays Sudden Reversal to cancel the Minion Tap > > Mike plays Sudden Reversal to cancel Brian's Sudden Reversal. > > Is that a legal play? We finally decided that it was, and that the > Minion Tap was successful. No. > The only thing I was not sure about is whether or not you can play > Sudden Reversal on your own turn, and it can only be played during > another Methuselah's turn. See 1.6.2.3 -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. Links to revised rulebook, rulings, errata, and tournament rules: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

"LSJ" <vte...@white-wolf.com> wrote in message news:3C67DDF1...@white-wolf.com... > Brian Iverson wrote: > > Mike plays Minion Tap. > > Brian plays Sudden Reversal to cancel the Minion Tap > > > > Mike plays Sudden Reversal to cancel Brian's Sudden Reversal. point 1- mike cannot play a master out of turn during his turn (barring special text on the card -example : Contengency planning) point 2- mike just played a master card. (If a card in play grants him a second maser phase action, it's okay to play a second one, as long as you don't violate point 2) > > Is that a legal play? We finally decided that it was, and that the > > Minion Tap was successful. > > No. As LSJ stated, you made a mistake. Brian's sudden could have been suddened by another player than mike, though =) > > The only thing I was not sure about is whether or not you can play > > Sudden Reversal on your own turn, and it can only be played during > > another Methuselah's turn. > > See 1.6.2.3 Errmm this is a shorter way to say "that means you cannot do so since the rulebook clearly states so." LSJ likes short answers, you know ;) [ quoted text not captured ]

LSJ wrote: > Brian Iverson wrote: > >>I may have already figured this one out, but I wanted to be sure and get >>some other players opinions. >> >>Here is the example of play: >> >>Mike plays Minion Tap. >>Brian plays Sudden Reversal to cancel the Minion Tap >> >>Mike plays Sudden Reversal to cancel Brian's Sudden Reversal. >> >>Is that a legal play? We finally decided that it was, and that the >>Minion Tap was successful. >> > > No. > > >>The only thing I was not sure about is whether or not you can play >>Sudden Reversal on your own turn, and it can only be played during >>another Methuselah's turn. >> > > See 1.6.2.3 > However if Bob (a third player) plays Sudden Reversal on Brian's Sudden Reversal then the Minion Tap would be successful. Archibald Zimonyi Malkavian Prince of Gothenburg

On Mon, 11 Feb 2002 23:42:35 +0100, "Reyda" <re...@noos.fr> wrote: >As LSJ stated, you made a mistake. Brian's sudden could have been suddened >by another player than mike, though =) Ermmmmm...can it? T

<Talo...@nospam.hotmail.com> wrote in message news:3c69869a.65326970@news... [ quoted text not captured ] of course ! you can a sudden with an other sudden, which can be suddened by a sudden from a fourth guy.

<Talo...@nospam.hotmail.com> wrote in message news:3c69869a.65326970@news... [ quoted text not captured ] Yes, Reyda is right. An OOT master can be canceled as it is played by Sudden Reversal just as well as a "normal" master. Josh suddening the sudden sudden (funny that "sudden" is usually the verb rather than "reverse" isn't it?)