rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

Banishment and Chanjelin Ward

2 messages from 2 participants · 19 December 2001
original thread on Google Groups

Andy Brown

My prey has a Kiasyd with Chanjelin Ward on it. My Vampire of higher capacity calls a Political Action, Banishment. There are no blockers, so I name the aforementioned Kiasyd. Does my Vampire have to burn a blood (an action against the Kiasyd with the Ward) and then can she burn it to cause the political action to fail, as it the Kiasyd is the target? I would have said no, as the political action is an undirected action to which the Kiasyd becomes part of the referenda, not a directed action against the Kiasyd named. However, obviously, my prey said otherwise. As I was half asleep at the time, I stated my arguement, but backed down, and as such, my Ventrue Prince lost a blood, and then the action failed as the Ward was burnt. Who was right? Cheers Andy Setite Ruler of Cambridge VEKN Prince

LSJ

Andy Brown wrote: > > My prey has a Kiasyd with Chanjelin Ward on it. > > My Vampire of higher capacity calls a Political Action, > Banishment. There are no blockers, so I name the aforementioned > Kiasyd. > > Does my Vampire have to burn a blood (an action against > the Kiasyd with the Ward) and then can she burn it to cause > the political action to fail, as it the Kiasyd is the target? No. It is not directed at the Kiasyd. > I would have said no, as the political action is an undirected > action to which the Kiasyd becomes part of the referenda, not > a directed action against the Kiasyd named. However, obviously, > my prey said otherwise. As I was half asleep at the time, I > stated my arguement, but backed down, and as such, my Ventrue > Prince lost a blood, and then the action failed as the Ward was > burnt. > > Who was right? You. -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. Links to revised rulebook, rulings, errata, and tournament rules: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/