rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

VTES 3rd Ed Preview page is up (rules additions, changes)

29 messages from 16 participants · 08 August 2006 – 10 August 2006
original thread on Google Groups

atomweaver

Alas... no previews, yet. http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/index.php?line=Checklist_ThirdEdition A few new/changed rules are there though; New Rules Remember that updated rules don't go into effect until the set is legal for play. Trifles: This set updates the trifle rules both to remove the restriction against playing more than one trifle in each master phase (although only the first one grants an additional master phase action), and to handle out-of-turn trifles (which function just as you would expect). Draft effects: New to this set, some of the booster cards (reprints included) that require a Discipline or clan to use have additional texts on them which give them an alternate way of being used in draft and sealed tournaments. Sometimes this alternate use is the same effect as the normal usage, but with a different requirement. Other times, it is a different usage (and often both). The alternate uses are clearly labeled with "DRAFT:" text and set apart from the normal card text. The alternate effect is only usable in draft and sealed play. In standard constructed play, the draft text is ignored. end quote New trifle change looks A-OK AFAIC... I hope the draft effects don't clutter/confuse the cards overmuch, but otherwise the mechanism looks to be a smart 'un. Way to go, Design Team! DaveZ Atom Weaver

Jozxyqk

> Draft effects: New to this set, some of the booster cards (reprints > included) that require a Discipline or clan to use have additional texts > on them which give them an alternate way of being used in draft and > sealed tournaments. One question about this (already): Is the Draft Effect a part of "Most Recent Printing" of the card? For example, will I have to remember what the "DRAFTFERIOR" of Claws of the Dead is, when I'm drafting Anarchs?

LSJ

[ quoted text not captured ] No. It only applies when drafting from the pack it is in.

pd...@lightlink.com

Jozxyqk wrote: > One question about this (already): > > Is the Draft Effect a part of "Most Recent Printing" of the card? > > For example, will I have to remember what the "DRAFTFERIOR" of Claws of > the Dead is, when I'm drafting Anarchs? Fine question. And more importantly, fine introduction of good lingo :-) -Peter

Jozxyqk

pd...@lightlink.com wrote: [ quoted text not captured ] Heh. I was going to try to lobby for something more creative. Like "transferior". Or "cheatferior". But "draftferior" just seems like it's going to stick, I think.

Jozxyqk

[ quoted text not captured ] So, does this mean that we could theoretically see: *...another set with Claws of the Dead in it, with yet another Draft Effect? *...a single set with multiple different versions of Claws of the Dead with different Draftferiors? Sorry to speak hypothetically, and sorry to pick on Claws, but it's the only card we know has one of these effects... This is purely a speculative post, and I'm not necessarily looking for an LSJ answer to it. :)

The Lasombra

On Tue, 08 Aug 2006 14:40:54 GMT, atomweaver <atomw...@hotmail.com> wrote: >http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/index.php?line=Checklist_ThirdEdition Each preconstructed deck contains 6 new vampires that aren't found in the boosters, many of which are included twice in their respective starters.

Damnans

[ quoted text not captured ] Crap sometimes sticks as well :-) "Draft effect" suffices. It has 3 syllables, so it is shorter than "draftferior", which has 4 syllables, and helps create redundances such as "draftferior effect". -- Damnans http://www.almadrava.net/damnans http://www.vtes.net http://es.groups.yahoo.com/group/vteshispania/

LSJ

Jozxyqk wrote: > LSJ <vte...@white-wolf.com> wrote: > > Jozxyqk wrote: > > > Is the Draft Effect a part of "Most Recent Printing" of the card? > > > > > > For example, will I have to remember what the "DRAFTFERIOR" of Claws of > > > the Dead is, when I'm drafting Anarchs? > > > No. It only applies when drafting from the pack it is in. > > So, does this mean that we could theoretically see: > *...another set with Claws of the Dead in it, with yet another Draft Effect? > > *...a single set with multiple different versions of Claws of the Dead with > different Draftferiors? Theoretically, sure. Probably not in practice, though. But if you're drafting 3rd Ed and Sabbat War, only the 3rd Ed cards will have draft effects on them. The copies of those same cards found in SW will just be "plain".

John Flournoy

Damnans wrote: > Jozxyqk wrote: > > pd...@lightlink.com wrote: > > > > > Jozxyqk wrote: > > > > One question about this (already): > > > > > > > > Is the Draft Effect a part of "Most Recent Printing" of the card? > > > > > > > > For example, will I have to remember what the "DRAFTFERIOR" of Claws of > > > > the Dead is, when I'm drafting Anarchs? > > > > > Fine question. And more importantly, fine introduction of good lingo > > > :-) > > > > Heh. > > I was going to try to lobby for something more creative. > > Like "transferior". Or "cheatferior". > > But "draftferior" just seems like it's going to stick, I think. > > Crap sometimes sticks as well :-) > > "Draft effect" suffices. It has 3 syllables, so it is shorter than > "draftferior", which has 4 syllables, and helps create redundances such > as "draftferior effect". Speaking as the person who suggested it to Josh on IRC, I vote for draftferior (if only to irritate Gines. :P ) -John Flournoy

Jozxyqk

LSJ <vte...@white-wolf.com> wrote: > Jozxyqk wrote: > > > Draft effects: New to this set, some of the booster cards (reprints > > > included) that require a Discipline or clan to use have additional texts > > > on them which give them an alternate way of being used in draft and > > > sealed tournaments. I actually have another question about this same "draftferior" mechanic: In draft, are you allowed to use the basic, regular, effect of the card, or are you *only* allowed to use the draftferior effect(s)?

atomweaver

"John Flournoy" <carn...@gmail.com> wrote in news:1155055831....@75g2000cwc.googlegroups.com: [ quoted text not captured ] Ug. I stumble over it when spoken aloud... The -ftf- in the middle gets me. Maybe it can be contracted, ala "Dra'ferior"..? Hmm. Draft is only one version of Limited... Limferior? DaveZ Atom Weaver muddying the vernacular

Jozxyqk

atomweaver <atomw...@hotmail.com> wrote: > Ug. I stumble over it when spoken aloud... The -ftf- in the middle > gets me. Maybe it can be contracted, ala "Dra'ferior"..? > Hmm. Draft is only one version of Limited... Limferior? Well, there's also "exterior". It's a real word, and it kind of describes the effect. i.e. Prince Josh teaching a newbie to play (constructed) with 3E cards. "What does this 'DRAFT' part mean?" "Oh, that's just an *exterior* effect. You can ignore it for now."

OctavianCMB

atomweaver wrote: > Hmm. Draft is only one version of Limited... Limferior? > > DaveZ > Atom Weaver > muddying the vernacular Limferior would be particularly amusing if Disarm had a Draft effect. Limbfeariority complex. cmb

Joshua Duffin

"atomweaver" <atomw...@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:Xns98198FC792...@207.115.17.102... [ quoted text not captured ] Heh, I kind of like "limferior". It reminds me of "limburger". I'm still sad that "inferior" got replaced by "basic" in the rulebook back when that happened. (Whenever that was.) Josh muddy all over

Fred Scott

"atomweaver" <atomw...@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:Xns98198FC792...@207.115.17.102... > Ug. I stumble over it when spoken aloud... The -ftf- in the middle > gets me. Maybe it can be contracted, ala "Dra'ferior"..? > > Hmm. Draft is only one version of Limited... Limferior? Even less likely. We don't need no card effect what sounds like stinky cheese.

LSJ

Joshua Duffin wrote: > I'm still sad that "inferior" got replaced by "basic" in the rulebook back > when that happened. (Whenever that was.) Never, AFAICT. The Jyhad Rules failed to give any term to the basic, merely defining superior. The 1995 VTES rules called the basic "basic".

atomweaver

"Fred Scott" <nos...@no.spam.dot.com> wrote in news:lU4Cg.21201$_c1.1780 @fed1read05: [ quoted text not captured ] _Never_ malign stinky cheese in a reply to a post of mine, Fred. I will track you down... ;-) DaveZ Atom Weaver loves a good 'ol plate of stinky cheese

echia...@yahoo.com

atomweaver wrote: > Trifles: This set updates the trifle rules both to remove the > restriction against playing more than one trifle in each master phase > (although only the first one grants an additional master phase action), > and to handle out-of-turn trifles (which function just as you would > expect). A handful of questions about the new Trifle rules. LSJ, please confirm: #1. The new ruling states that "only the first one grants an additional master phase action." I play Life In the City but it gets Suddened. If I tap The Parthenon for a second master phase action and play another Life In the City, do I gain an extra master phase action from the Trifle? Based on the wording of the rules, I would say no since this is not "the first one." True? #2. Let's pretend an out-of-turn Trifle exists. If I play it during my prey's turn, can I play another out-of-turn Master (or Trifle) during my grandprey's turn? Based on previous rulings on Synesios (his ability does not allow you to play multiple Master OOT's), I would guess that you cannot do this. Right? #3. I play an out-of-turn Trifle during my predator's turn. Since this "function[s] just as [I] would expect", I assume I just get my normal master phase action during my turn. (1 is the base, -1 due to the Master OOT, +1 due to the Trifle = 1). Yes? #4. I play an out-of-turn Trifle during my predator's turn. During my turn, can I gain an additional master phase action by playing a Trifle now, or did I already benefit from it with the OOT I played earlier? Based on the wording of the rules, it seems like I can gain another master by playing a Trifle. Verdad? #5. I play an out-of-turn Trifle during my predator's turn and I burn a pool to use Synesios' special. I now get 2 master phase actions during my next master phase. Correct?

pd...@lightlink.com

Damnans wrote: > Crap sometimes sticks as well :-) > > "Draft effect" suffices. It has 3 syllables, so it is shorter than > "draftferior", which has 4 syllables, and helps create redundances such > as "draftferior effect". Uh, but "draftferior" is funny. And nicely echoes "inferior" and "outferior". Draftferior is is. -Peter

LSJ

echia...@yahoo.com wrote: > A handful of questions about the new Trifle rules. LSJ, please confirm: > > #1. The new ruling states that "only the first one grants an additional > master phase action." I play Life In the City but it gets Suddened. If > I tap The Parthenon for a second master phase action and play another > Life In the City, do I gain an extra master phase action from the > Trifle? Based on the wording of the rules, I would say no since this is > not "the first one." True? That's "based on the wording in the preview". In the rules, the wording is a little more stilted so as to handle all the angles: When a Methuselah plays a trifle (and it isn't canceled), she gains an additional master phase action. For an out-of-turn trifle, she gains a master phase action in her next master phase. A Methuselah can gain only one master phase action from trifles in a given master phase; others act like regular master cards. So if the first is canceled, it doesn't provide an additional MPA. If another MPA is available, and it is used to play a trifle, though, then that second one provides an MPA. > #2. Let's pretend an out-of-turn Trifle exists. If I play it during my > prey's turn, can I play another out-of-turn Master (or Trifle) during > my grandprey's turn? Based on previous rulings on Synesios (his ability > does not allow you to play multiple Master OOT's), I would guess that > you cannot do this. Right? Since "it functions as you would expect", correct. > #3. I play an out-of-turn Trifle during my predator's turn. Since this > "function[s] just as [I] would expect", I assume I just get my normal > master phase action during my turn. (1 is the base, -1 due to the > Master OOT, +1 due to the Trifle = 1). Yes? Correct. > #4. I play an out-of-turn Trifle during my predator's turn. During my > turn, can I gain an additional master phase action by playing a Trifle > now, or did I already benefit from it with the OOT I played earlier? > Based on the wording of the rules, it seems like I can gain another > master by playing a Trifle. Verdad? The actual rules text covers this angle as well (only one MPA in a master phase can come from trifles, which is "as one would expect" for an OOT trifle). > #5. I play an out-of-turn Trifle during my predator's turn and I burn a > pool to use Synesios' special. I now get 2 master phase actions during > my next master phase. Correct? Yes.

Damnans

[ quoted text not captured ] Crappy? Unnecessary? :-) [ quoted text not captured ]

Orpheus

> > Damnans wrote: > > > Crap sometimes sticks as well :-) > > > > > > "Draft effect" suffices. It has 3 syllables, so it is shorter than > > > "draftferior", which has 4 syllables, and helps create redundances such > > > as "draftferior effect". > > > > Uh, but "draftferior" is funny. And nicely echoes "inferior" and > > "outferior". > > > > Draftferior is is. > > Crappy? Unnecessary? :-) Crapferior ? Unnecessarior ? -- Orpheus ----------------------- I'm dead serious ! Well, mostly dead...

Fred Scott

"Orpheus" <orphe...@DEADSPAMfree.fr> wrote in message news:44d8f720$0$25144$636a...@news.free.fr... >> > Uh, but "draftferior" is funny. And nicely echoes "inferior" and >> > "outferior". >> > >> > Draftferior is is. >> >> Crappy? Unnecessary? :-) > > Crapferior ? Unnecessarior ? Argferior! :-P

Pat

<pd...@lightlink.com> wrote in message news:1155066493....@i42g2000cwa.googlegroups.com... [ quoted text not captured ] Agreed. :) Won't it be great when a Bloodlines discipline card is printed that has a draftferior, outferior, inferior, and superior effect? - Pat

mummy

Pat wrote: > Won't it be great when a Bloodlines discipline card is printed that has a > draftferior, outferior, inferior, and superior effect? > > - Pat Why, that card would be tetraferior!

illarion

> Won't it be great when a Bloodlines discipline card is printed that has a > draftferior, outferior, inferior, and superior effect? Don't forget a Reflex ;)

Orpheus

[ quoted text not captured ] I'll have to change glasses before the next expansion, I'm afraid... ------- Orpheus

XZealot

[ quoted text not captured ] No you won't. Those are going to be foils. Comments Welcome, Norman S. Brown, Jr XZealot Archon of the Swamp