Combat Questions (retry; post #2)

Hi all! Vampire A and B are in combat. Vampire B is the reacting minion. Vampire A plays S:CE. (Majesty, Staredown,...) 1. Can Vampire B still play his strike? 2. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws? 2.1. Can Vampire B play Rotschreck? 3. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws BEFORE the strike resolution? Thanks! .- Luis....@ip.pt

In article <36e5c...@news.ip.pt>, "Luis P. Duarte" <Luis....@ip.pt> wrote: > Hi all! > > Vampire A and B are in combat. > Vampire B is the reacting minion. > Vampire A plays S:CE. (Majesty, Staredown,...) > > 1. Can Vampire B still play his strike? Yes. > 2. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws? Yes. > 2.1. Can Vampire B play Rotschreck? NO. Vampires cannot play master cards. Any Methuselah (player) other than the controller of Vampire A (whose turn it is) can play Rotschreck if an attempt to use aggravated damage occurs. The Methusaleh playing Rotschreck would play it on Vampire B to send Vampire B to torpor if he played Wolf Claws in this case. > 3. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws BEFORE the strike resolution? Absolutely, yes. Carpe Noctem. Lasombra http://members.tripod.com/~Lasombra -----------== Posted via Deja News, The Discussion Network ==---------- http://www.dejanews.com/ Search, Read, Discuss, or Start Your Own

In article <36e5c...@news.ip.pt>, "Luis P. Duarte" <Luis....@ip.pt> wrote: > Hi all! > > Vampire A and B are in combat. > Vampire B is the reacting minion. > Vampire A plays S:CE. (Majesty, Staredown,...) > > 1. Can Vampire B still play his strike? > 2. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws? > 2.1. Can Vampire B play Rotschreck? > 3. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws BEFORE the strike resolution? > > Thanks! > .- Luis....@ip.pt Hey, that's MY deck idea!!!! Anyway the method of doing it as an action rather than a reaction is. Yes to all 3.5 questions. And if A is a Malkie and s/he's taking a Madness Network action then s/he can play all 3.5 too, and then you may laugh maniacally as your victim drips tears of blood onto their full hand of damage prevention cards ... and what is more, you will have joined the Conspiracy Of Malkav- legbiterists Beating Absolutely everybody into Torpor Regardless of how much Unlife is Left them and then diablErizing their sorry asSes. [COMBATRULES] [ quoted text not captured ]

TheLa...@hotmail.com wrote: > In article <36e5c...@news.ip.pt>, > "Luis P. Duarte" <Luis....@ip.pt> wrote: > > Hi all! > > > > Vampire A and B are in combat. > > Vampire B is the reacting minion. > > Vampire A plays S:CE. (Majesty, Staredown,...) > > > > 1. Can Vampire B still play his strike? > Yes. > > 2. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws? > Yes. > > > 2.1. Can Vampire B play Rotschreck? > > NO. Vampires cannot play master cards. Any Methuselah (player) > other than the controller of Vampire A (whose turn it is) can > play Rotschreck if an attempt to use aggravated damage occurs. > > The Methusaleh playing Rotschreck would play it on Vampire B > to send Vampire B to torpor if he played Wolf Claws in this case. Wrong! There were some clarifications about Rotschreck: A Methusaleh playing Rotschreck in this Combination would send Vampire A to tropor! > > 3. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws BEFORE the strike resolution? > > Absolutely, yes. > > Carpe Noctem. > > Lasombra --- garfield

In article <7c5dpl$849$1...@nnrp1.dejanews.com>, TheLa...@hotmail.com wrote: > In article <36e5c...@news.ip.pt>, > "Luis P. Duarte" <Luis....@ip.pt> wrote: > > Hi all! > > > > Vampire A and B are in combat. > > Vampire B is the reacting minion. > > Vampire A plays S:CE. (Majesty, Staredown,...) > > > > 1. Can Vampire B still play his strike? > > Yes. > > > 2. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws? > > Yes. > > > 2.1. Can Vampire B play Rotschreck? > > NO. Vampires cannot play master cards. Any Methuselah (player) > other than the controller of Vampire A (whose turn it is) can > play Rotschreck if an attempt to use aggravated damage occurs. > > The Methusaleh playing Rotschreck would play it on Vampire B > to send Vampire B to torpor if he played Wolf Claws in this case. No, under the 23/6 de-errata'd and correct interpretation of Rotschreck it is vampire A who can be made to take the dirt bath. But you're right that Rotshreck is played by a Methuselah, not a vampire. My mistake in my other contribution to this thread - sorry, Luis! > > > 3. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws BEFORE the strike resolution? > > Absolutely, yes. > > Carpe Noctem. > > Lasombra > > http://members.tripod.com/~Lasombra [ quoted text not captured ]

Thomas Gajdosik <garf...@hephy.oeaw.ac.at> wrote: > TheLa...@hotmail.com wrote: > > "Luis P. Duarte" <Luis....@ip.pt> wrote: > > > Hi all! > > > > > > Vampire A and B are in combat. > > > Vampire B is the reacting minion. > > > Vampire A plays S:CE. (Majesty, Staredown,...) > > > > > > 1. Can Vampire B still play his strike? > > Yes. > > > > 2. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws? > > Yes. > > > > > 2.1. Can Vampire B play Rotschreck? > > > > NO. Vampires cannot play master cards. Any Methuselah (player) > > other than the controller of Vampire A (whose turn it is) can > > play Rotschreck if an attempt to use aggravated damage occurs. > > > > The Methusaleh playing Rotschreck would play it on Vampire B > > to send Vampire B to torpor if he played Wolf Claws in this case. > > Wrong! > There were some clarifications about Rotschreck: > A Methusaleh playing Rotschreck in this Combination > would send Vampire A to torpor! Correct. (sorry for missing this point earlier). -- L. Scott Johnson (vte...@wizards.com) VTES Net.Rep for Wizards of the Coast. Links to revised rulebook, rulings, errata, and DCI (tournament) rules: http://www.wizards.com/VTES/VTES_Rules.html [ quoted text not captured ]

TheLa...@hotmail.com wrote: > > In article <36e5c...@news.ip.pt>, > "Luis P. Duarte" <Luis....@ip.pt> wrote: > > Hi all! > > > > Vampire A and B are in combat. > > Vampire B is the reacting minion. > > Vampire A plays S:CE. (Majesty, Staredown,...) > > > > 1. Can Vampire B still play his strike? > > Yes. > > > 2. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws? > > Yes. > > > 2.1. Can Vampire B play Rotschreck? > > NO. Vampires cannot play master cards. Any Methuselah (player) > other than the controller of Vampire A (whose turn it is) can > play Rotschreck if an attempt to use aggravated damage occurs. > > The Methusaleh playing Rotschreck would play it on Vampire B > to send Vampire B to torpor if he played Wolf Claws in this case. > > > 3. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws BEFORE the strike resolution? > > Absolutely, yes. Correct on all points. [ quoted text not captured ]

LSJ wrote: > > TheLa...@hotmail.com wrote: > > > > In article <36e5c...@news.ip.pt>, > > "Luis P. Duarte" <Luis....@ip.pt> wrote: > > > Hi all! > > > > > > Vampire A and B are in combat. > > > Vampire B is the reacting minion. > > > Vampire A plays S:CE. (Majesty, Staredown,...) > > > > > > 1. Can Vampire B still play his strike? > > > > Yes. > > > > > 2. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws? > > > > Yes. > > > > > 2.1. Can Vampire B play Rotschreck? > > > > NO. Vampires cannot play master cards. Any Methuselah (player) > > other than the controller of Vampire A (whose turn it is) can > > play Rotschreck if an attempt to use aggravated damage occurs. > > > > The Methusaleh playing Rotschreck would play it on Vampire B > > to send Vampire B to torpor if he played Wolf Claws in this case. > > > > > 3. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws BEFORE the strike resolution? > > > > Absolutely, yes. > > Correct on all points. Wouldn't it be vampire A that goes to torpor not B? Kevin

Lasombra> The Methusaleh playing Rotschreck would play it on Vampire B Lasombra> to send Vampire B to torpor if he played Wolf Claws in this case. LSJ> Correct on all points. *eyes widen* Say what? Noal -- "Excuse me. Are you a yuppie?" -woman at a gas station in Detroit [ quoted text not captured ]

In article <7c5dpl$849$1...@nnrp1.dejanews.com>, TheLa...@hotmail.com wrote: > In article <36e5c...@news.ip.pt>, > "Luis P. Duarte" <Luis....@ip.pt> wrote: > > Hi all! > > > > Vampire A and B are in combat. > > Vampire B is the reacting minion. > > Vampire A plays S:CE. (Majesty, Staredown,...) > > > > 1. Can Vampire B still play his strike? > > Yes. > > > 2. Can Vampire B play Wolf Claws? > > Yes. > > > 2.1. Can Vampire B play Rotschreck? > > NO. Vampires cannot play master cards. Any Methuselah (player) > other than the controller of Vampire A (whose turn it is) can > play Rotschreck if an attempt to use aggravated damage occurs. > > The Methusaleh playing Rotschreck would play it on Vampire A > to send Vampire A to torpor if B played Wolf Claws in this case. Sorry small misprint there should have been A in the above sentence. The corrected version appears above. Carpe Noctem. Lasombra http://members.tripod.com/~Lasombra I have a tendency to wear my mind on my sleeve, I have a history of taking off my shirt. [ quoted text not captured ]