rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

[LSJ] Question about Gather

7 messages from 5 participants · 24 October 2004 – 12 November 2004
original thread on Google Groups

ThE_OnLy_VipeR

Hello My question about gather is if i can tap gather to move multiple vampires form my uncontrolled region to my ready region. the card says: "put this card in play tapped and select a younger gangrel in your uncotrolled region, during your influence pahse you can tap this card to move that vampire to your ready region whatever counter he or she has". now my interpretation is the next: i play gather and move a vampire from my uncontrolled region to my ready region, the card remains in possetion of the vampire who played it, so that would mean that in my next turn i can tap gather again and select another younger vampire in my uncontrolled region. so i can move as many younger vampires as i got in my uncontrolled region to my ready region while the vampire who owns gather remains ready and gather reamins in play. is my interpretation right, or i minundesrtanded the card? thanks :)

henrik isaksson

"ThE_OnLy_VipeR" <fina...@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:576ea13a.04102...@posting.google.com... > Hello Hi. > My question about gather is if i can tap gather to move multiple > vampires form my uncontrolled region to my ready region. > > the card says: "put this card in play tapped and select a younger > gangrel in your uncotrolled region, during your influence pahse you > can tap this card to move that vampire to your ready region whatever > counter he or she has". You have to choose the vampire when you play the card. Nothing in card text gives you oppurtunity to change vampire later. > now my interpretation is the next: i play gather and move a vampire > from my uncontrolled region to my ready region, the card remains in > possetion of the vampire who played it, so that would mean that in my > next turn i can tap gather again and select another younger vampire in > my uncontrolled region. Nope. However, you can use the same Gather to move the same vampire to the ready region later, if it has for instance been banished. > so i can move as many younger vampires as i got in my uncontrolled > region to my ready region while the vampire who owns gather remains > ready and gather reamins in play. > > is my interpretation right, or i minundesrtanded the card? The latter. > thanks :) np /henrik isaksson

LSJ

henrik isaksson wrote: > "ThE_OnLy_VipeR" <fina...@hotmail.com> wrote in message >>My question about gather is if i can tap gather to move multiple >>vampires form my uncontrolled region to my ready region. >> >>the card says: "put this card in play tapped and select a younger >>gangrel in your uncotrolled region, during your influence pahse you >>can tap this card to move that vampire to your ready region whatever >>counter he or she has". > > You have to choose the vampire when you play the card. Nothing in card text > gives you oppurtunity to change vampire later. Correct. >>now my interpretation is the next: i play gather and move a vampire >>from my uncontrolled region to my ready region, the card remains in >>possetion of the vampire who played it, so that would mean that in my Trivia: The card is never in the possession of the vampire who played it. It is simply "put into play" not "put on the acting vampire". >>next turn i can tap gather again and select another younger vampire in >>my uncontrolled region. > > Nope. However, you can use the same Gather to move the same vampire to the > ready region later, if it has for instance been banished. Correct. -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. Links to V:TES news, rules, cards, utilities, and tournament calendar: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

Peter D Bakija

ThE_OnLy_VipeR wrote: > My question about gather is if i can tap gather to move multiple > vampires form my uncontrolled region to my ready region. Only one. > > the card says: "put this card in play tapped and select a younger > gangrel in your uncotrolled region, during your influence pahse you > can tap this card to move that vampire to your ready region whatever > counter he or she has". When you put the card into play, you select the vampire. It doesn't allow you to change the vampire you have selected. Also note that the card doesn't leave play after the vampire in question is in play, so if you want to get another vampire out with another Gather, you'll need to take an action to remove the first one. > > now my interpretation is the next: i play gather and move a vampire > from my uncontrolled region to my ready region, the card remains in > possetion of the vampire who played it, so that would mean that in my > next turn i can tap gather again and select another younger vampire in > my uncontrolled region. Incorrect. > > so i can move as many younger vampires as i got in my uncontrolled > region to my ready region while the vampire who owns gather remains > ready and gather reamins in play. Nope. Gather chooses one vampire. When that vampire is in play, Gather is mostly useless. > > is my interpretation right, or i minundesrtanded the card? It looks like you have misunderstood the card. But that happens. Peter D Bakija pd...@lightlink.com http://www.lightlink.com/pdb6 "Mr. President, ask not what your rest home can do for you. Ask what you can do for your rest home." -Elvis

Gregory Stuart Pettigrew

> > > My question about gather is if i can tap gather to move multiple > > > vampires form my uncontrolled region to my ready region. > > > > Only one. > > > > > > > > the card says: "put this card in play tapped and select a younger > > > gangrel in your uncotrolled region, during your influence pahse you > > > can tap this card to move that vampire to your ready region whatever > > > counter he or she has". > > > > last question, let's say i have gathered Nadima, now nadima enters > combat and is burned by means of amranth let's say, now i had another > copy of nadima in my uncontrolled region, can i gather nadima again?? > i think that yes because gather has been asigned to nadima, i'm > correct? > Nope. Gather targets *that particular card*, not the Vampire by name.

LSJ

Gregory Stuart Pettigrew wrote: >>last question, let's say i have gathered Nadima, now nadima enters >>combat and is burned by means of amranth let's say, now i had another >>copy of nadima in my uncontrolled region, can i gather nadima again?? >>i think that yes because gather has been asigned to nadima, i'm >>correct? >> > Nope. Gather targets *that particular card*, not the Vampire by name. Correct. [ quoted text not captured ]

LSJ

"ThE_OnLy_VipeR" <fina...@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:576ea13a.04111...@posting.google.com... > Gregory Stuart Pettigrew <ethe...@sidehack.sat.gweep.net> wrote in message > > Nope. Gather targets *that particular card*, not the Vampire by name. > > what?? but the card says select a younger gangrel in your uncontrolled > region, and after that says, move THAT gangrel to your ready region, > so if i gather nadima again i would be moving THAT gangrel, not > another one No. THAT gangrel was burned. The copy of Nadima in your uncontrolled region is not THAT vampire. It is a different one (with the same name). See also Contracts, etc. http://groups.google.com/groups?selm=94hh29%24ikt%241%40nnrp1.deja.com -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. V:TES homepage: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/ Though effective, appear to be ineffective -- Sun Tzu