rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

{LSJ} Scalpel Tongue vs. Conductor

4 messages from 2 participants · 05 January 2007 – 07 January 2007
original thread on Google Groups

Kushiel

Player A has five untapped Daughters of Cacophony in play. Angela Preston has a Conductor. Player B calls a vote, during which all five Daughters vote against. After Angela Preston votes, Player B plays Scalpel Tongue on her, cancelling her votes and tapping her. The other four Daughters retain their votes for the current referendum because they're already been cast, right? Thanks! John Eno

LSJ

[ quoted text not captured ] No. When she becomes tapped, the other DoCs lose the additional vote her special had provided.

Kushiel

[ quoted text not captured ] Hmm. Okay, so how does that work in terms of what votes the Daughters are casting? 1) All the Daughters are now casting 0 votes against? 2) All the Daughters are considered as not voting at all? I'd assume it's #2, but clearly I might be wrong. :) (This matters for cards that notice whether or not a vampire voted during a referendum.) John Eno

LSJ

[ quoted text not captured ] The two are equivalent. Casting no votes is note voting at all.