"Legacy of Pander"...

Pedantic old me just realized something about the card "Legacy of Pander".. In its current wording, it says that each non-titled Pander gets one vote. Rulebook says "If you have a vote, it's considered a title". So.. each non-titled Pander gains a vote. And then by having a vote, they have a title.. so they lose the vote.. so they gain it back again.. ad infinitum.. Whether they have a vote or not is in a quantum state ;) I haven't seen the old wording, but I'm assuming it says each non-titled Pander *gains* one vote, and thereby presumed stackable. For the same rulebook-citation as above, though, in seriousness, it wouldn't be stackable (unless the original wording didn't have the "non-titled" part). By having one vote, they now have a title.

Jozxyqk wrote: > > Pedantic old me just realized something about the card > "Legacy of Pander".. In its current wording, it says that > each non-titled Pander gets one vote. > > Rulebook says "If you have a vote, it's considered a title". No, it doesn't. > So.. each non-titled Pander gains a vote. And then by > having a vote, they have a title.. so they lose the vote.. > so they gain it back again.. ad infinitum.. > Whether they have a vote or not is in a quantum state ;) Moot. -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. Links to revised rulebook, rulings, errata, and tournament rules: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

LSJ <vte...@white-wolf.com> wrote: > Jozxyqk wrote: >> >> Pedantic old me just realized something about the card >> "Legacy of Pander".. In its current wording, it says that >> each non-titled Pander gets one vote. >> >> Rulebook says "If you have a vote, it's considered a title". > No, it doesn't. I was remembering this: [6.3.3] Other vampires may have votes (as listed on card text)... Such a vampire is considered "titled" for game purposes... I only assumed that gaining semi-permanent votes, such as from Legacy, would bestow a "title" as illustrated there. But I guess it doesn't work that way...

"Jozxyqk" <jfeu...@eecs.tufts.edu> a écrit dans le message news: q99x6.7074$WZ4.9...@typhoon.ne.mediaone.net... [ quoted text not captured ] No, this is not the case ? really ? Imagine Regina Giovanni or Thetmes not being able to block a propaganda because she/he has two votes ??

I'm confused here... Are the Panders considered titled or not when the Legacy of Pander is in play? Can't see why they shouldn't be, according to the rulebook... Jozxyqk skrev i meddelandet ... [ quoted text not captured ]