Echo of Harmonies

Is the superior version of Echo of Harmonies chainable? i.e. if you use the vote card which was placed on the "Echoing" minion, can another minion then play Echo of Harmonies to take the card for themselves? What about referenda that don't require cards (such as the vote to burn certain cards-in-play)? Can you play this ability on those types of votes at all?

In message <cJTS7.18159$5W5.8...@typhoon.ne.mediaone.net>, Jozxyqk <jfeu...@eecs.tufts.edu> writes: >Is the superior version of Echo of Harmonies chainable? >i.e. if you use the vote card which was placed on the "Echoing" >minion, can another minion then play Echo of Harmonies to take the >card for themselves? I can't see any reason why not. It does appear that the card is still used to call the referendum the second time around, so qualifies under the text "Move the political action card used to call the referendum from your ash heap to this vampire at the end of the action." >What about referenda that don't require cards (such as the vote >to burn certain cards-in-play)? Can you play this ability on >those types of votes at all? Nope, because there's no political action card to play with. -- James Coupe PGP 0x5D623D5D It's been a long road, getting from there to here EBD690ECD7A1FB457CA213D7E It's been a long time, and my time is finally near 668C3695D623D5D I will see my dream come alive at last, I will touch the sky And they're not gonna hold me down no more, no they're not gonna change my mind

"Jozxyqk" <jfeu...@eecs.tufts.edu> wrote in message news:cJTS7.18159$5W5.8...@typhoon.ne.mediaone.net... > Is the superior version of Echo of Harmonies chainable? > i.e. if you use the vote card which was placed on the "Echoing" > minion, can another minion then play Echo of Harmonies to take the > card for themselves? Sure, it doesn't care wether the card came from your hand or not, just that the card is in the ash heap. > What about referenda that don't require cards (such as the vote > to burn certain cards-in-play)? Can you play this ability on > those types of votes at all? If the card is not a Political Action card ( like Anarch Revolt ), definately not. I can think of a case that I'm not sure of though. I've put a Rumors of Ghenna in play in a previous turn. I call a vote to burn it and it passes. Can I now play Echo of Harmonies?

What happens if Echo of Harmonies is used at superior with Ancient Influence or Political Stranglehold? Since the card moves from the ash heap to the minion and is later burned off the minion to be called again(rather than being played from a methuselah's hand) can the vote be called again? Thanks Doug

"GreySeer" <e...@i.think.not> wrote in message news:u1od5id...@news.supernews.com... [ quoted text not captured ] I think a better question would be can I call multiple Ancient Influence/Political Strangleholds with Echo of Harmonies?

GreySeer wrote: > I can think of a case that I'm not sure of though. > > I've put a Rumors of Ghenna in play in a previous turn. > I call a vote to burn it and it passes. > Can I now play Echo of Harmonies? No. -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. Links to revised rulebook, rulings, errata, and tournament rules: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

The Emperor wrote: > I think a better question would be can I call multiple Ancient > Influence/Political Strangleholds with Echo of Harmonies? No. The requirements of playing the card still have to be met. [ quoted text not captured ]

James Coupe <ja...@zephyr.org.uk> wrote in message news:<H6eVlN9Z...@gratiano.zephyr.org.uk>... > In message <cJTS7.18159$5W5.8...@typhoon.ne.mediaone.net>, Jozxyqk > <jfeu...@eecs.tufts.edu> writes: > >Is the superior version of Echo of Harmonies chainable? > >i.e. if you use the vote card which was placed on the "Echoing" > >minion, can another minion then play Echo of Harmonies to take the > >card for themselves? > > I can't see any reason why not. It does appear that the card is still > used to call the referendum the second time around, so qualifies under > the text "Move the political action card used to call the referendum > from your ash heap to this vampire at the end of the action." But. It's not moving from your ash heap...it's moving from another meth's ash heap.. LSJ??? Eric

[ quoted text not captured ] Only if you stole the DoC after it played EoH. Typically, the DoC will be using your PA card, so it will be going to your ash heap (and you can pick it up again with another EoH). [ quoted text not captured ]