{LSJ} Earth-Feeding Earth-Feeders

Fish has an Earth-Feeder from a previous, successful Earth-Feeder hunt. Can he play another Earth-Feeder as an action to hunt at +3 stealth and discard the second Earth-Feeder (the one played on the action, rather than the one already on the vampire) if the action is successful? I assume he can. Otherwise, Earth-Feeder's text should probably be written similarly to Repulsion's (ie, "This vampire cannot have or play another Earth-Feeder"). John Eno

On May 29, 6:07 pm, Kushiel <invisibleking...@gmail.com> wrote: > Fish has an Earth-Feeder from a previous, successful Earth-Feeder > hunt. Can he play another Earth-Feeder as an action to hunt at +3 > stealth and discard the second Earth-Feeder (the one played on the > action, rather than the one already on the vampire) if the action is > successful? No. http://groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/msg/ef056cb49d6f2a23?hl=en& "The same reason you cannot attempt to equip with a Hawg (to cycle) when you already have a Sport Bike. (A minion can have only one Vehicle). " "Just because it doesn't technically come into play until the action resolves doesn't mean you can do something you're not allowed to." Earth-Feeder Action +2 stealth hunt action. Requires a ready Laibon. Hunt. If the hunt is successful, put this card on this acting Laibon. This Laibon gets +1 stealth when hunting. A vampire can have only one Earth-Feeder. [ quoted text not captured ]

witness1 wrote: > On May 29, 6:07 pm, Kushiel <invisibleking...@gmail.com> wrote: >> Fish has an Earth-Feeder from a previous, successful Earth-Feeder >> hunt. Can he play another Earth-Feeder as an action to hunt at +3 >> stealth and discard the second Earth-Feeder (the one played on the >> action, rather than the one already on the vampire) if the action is >> successful? > > No. > > http://groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/msg/ef056cb49d6f2a23?hl=en& > > "The same reason you cannot attempt to equip with a Hawg (to cycle) > when you already have a Sport Bike. (A minion can have only one > Vehicle). " > > "Just because it doesn't technically come into play until the action > resolves doesn't mean you can do something you're not allowed to." > > Earth-Feeder > Action > +2 stealth hunt action. Requires a ready Laibon. > > Hunt. If the hunt is successful, put this card on this acting Laibon. > This Laibon gets +1 stealth when hunting. A vampire can have only one > Earth-Feeder. Correct. >> I assume he can. Otherwise, Earth-Feeder's text should probably be >> written similarly to Repulsion's (ie, "This vampire cannot have or >> play another Earth-Feeder"). Repulsion's text is the way it is in order to prevent a vampire with Repulsion from playing another at the [obf] level.

"LSJ" <vte...@white-wolf.com> wrote in message news:Yef7i.12630$RX....@newssvr11.news.prodigy.net... [ quoted text not captured ] Or the [pre] level even. :) - Pat, knows LSJ can't be bothered to remember all those cards

Pat wrote: > "LSJ" <vte...@white-wolf.com> wrote in message >> Repulsion's text is the way it is in order to prevent a vampire with >> Repulsion from playing another at the [obf] level. > > > Or the [pre] level even. :) > > - Pat, knows LSJ can't be bothered to remember all those cards That is another effect of the wording, but it is not part of the reason the card is worded the way it is.

[ quoted text not captured ] I think maybe the point he was making was that it doesn't have an [obf] level. [obe], sure. [pre], as noted. but no [obf]. ;) Repulsion Type: Action Modifier Requires: Obeah/Presence [pre] Only usable when the acting vampire's action is announced. If this action is blocked, the acting vampire gets an optional maneuver, only usable to maneuver to long range, during the resulting combat. [obe] +1 stealth. [OBE] Put this card on this vampire. This vampire gets +1 stealth. Burn this card if this vampire goes to torpor. This vampire cannot have or play another Repulsion. -- salem (replace 'hotmail' with 'yahoo' to email)

Salem wrote: > LSJ wrote: >> Pat wrote: >>> "LSJ" <vte...@white-wolf.com> wrote in message >>>> Repulsion's text is the way it is in order to prevent a vampire with >>>> Repulsion from playing another at the [obf] level. >>> >>> >>> Or the [pre] level even. :) >>> >>> - Pat, knows LSJ can't be bothered to remember all those cards >> >> That is another effect of the wording, but it is not part of the >> reason the card is worded the way it is. > > I think maybe the point he was making was that it doesn't have an [obf] > level. [obe], sure. [pre], as noted. but no [obf]. ;) Perhaps. A bit of a stretch, but whatever puffs your sails. My knuckle nerve clusters automatically make me press f after o-b; they've been conditioned.

LSJ wrote: > Salem wrote: >> I think maybe the point he was making was that it doesn't have an >> [obf] level. [obe], sure. [pre], as noted. but no [obf]. ;) > > Perhaps. A bit of a stretch, but whatever puffs your sails. heh. i don't believe i have ever heard that expression before. however, it's cute. i shall try and use it in context at least once tonight while out drinking with some friends. :) > My knuckle nerve clusters automatically make me press f after o-b; > they've been conditioned. ooh, they lost +3 pool? [ quoted text not captured ]

"Salem" <salem_ch...@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:465fee5b$1...@dnews.tpgi.com.au... > LSJ wrote: >> A bit of a stretch, but whatever puffs your sails. > > heh. i don't believe i have ever heard that expression before. however, > it's cute. i shall try and use it in context at least once tonight while > out drinking with some friends. :) Whatever spins your buttons!

[ quoted text not captured ] you're not helping. nor did the alcohol, as i completely forgot to use this line. although i did collecta phone numebr, so it wasn't ll bad. i should not post when stil drunk though sorry veryone. if it's any onsolation the friends i was out with were vte sp player! :) [ quoted text not captured ]