[LSJ] Action failure (Chas Giovanni)

When Chas Giovanni (If I can recall correctly) attempts to perform an action, you can burn a master card as a master out-of-turn to "cause that action to fail". When a friend of mine played with Chas today, he claimed that Chas would be untapped if someone burned a master card. Is this so? Why?

"Tommy Engvik" <to...@tragisk.com> wrote in message news:27eca42e.02011...@posting.google.com... [ quoted text not captured ] The action not cancelled ( which would make him untap ) it's fails, in the same way that it would fail if it was blocked it's just that combat doesn't occur.

[ quoted text not captured ] Correct. Chas doesn't untap, since no card text indicates that he should. -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. Links to revised rulebook, rulings, errata, and tournament rules: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

On Fri, 11 Jan 2002, LSJ wrote: > GreySeer wrote: > > The action not cancelled ( which would make him untap ) it's fails, in the > > same way that it would fail if it was blocked it's just that combat doesn't > > occur. > > Correct. Chas doesn't untap, since no card text indicates that he should. also, just to clarify, if chas never announces the action....for example, if he has obf and decided to mask an action that was started by someone else, he can't be foiled by meddling masters? thanks, salem.

"....salem christ...." wrote: > also, just to clarify, if chas never announces the action....for example, > if [Chas] has obf and decided to mask an action that was started by someone > else, he can't be foiled by meddling masters? Correct. Mask is played after the "as announced" phase. [LSJ 05-NOV-2001] [ quoted text not captured ]