rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

(LSJ) More Final Loosening Q

4 messages from 3 participants · 01 April 2010 – 02 April 2010
original thread on Google Groups

floppyzedolfin

Hi Scott, + Suppose A hunts. There is no block. Final Loosening is played. Is the hunt successful? Put in other words: Does Final Loosening reduces the blood gain to 1, or does it changes it to a gain 1 blood effect? + Here's a weird situation (I'll try to be as precise as I can): Slow Withering is in play. 1. Someone plays Voter Captivation at superior. Terms are: gain 2 blood and 2 pool. 2. There is no Direct Intervention played. 3. Voter Captivation is replaced. 4. Voter Captivation is paid and its effects happen : the vampire gains blood, the Methuselah gains pool. 5. The vampire has gained blood. Now, my question is : Where in that list does Final Loosening get played? I think it's some place between 3 and 4, but this is weird (I can't think of any other card that would be played in there). I think it can't be played until 2 is over. + Final Loosening doesn't say where the blood comes from. Does that mean it comes from the same source it was about to be gained from? (similarly to cards that give "additional blood" without precision about the origin) Suppose A plays inferior Consignment to Duat on B. There is no block. Final Loosening is played. Are both the blood counters awarded by Final Loosening taken *from B* - ending up with B losing *TWO* blood ? If the answer is different for A and B, why is it so? (cardtext seems to make difference). Thanks (and sorry again) ~~ Final Loosening Cardtype: Reaction Discipline: Auspex/Dementation/Fortitude Requires an anarch. [aus] Play when the acting vampire would gain 1 or more blood. The acting vampire and this reacting anarch each gain 1 blood instead. [dem] Gain 4 votes. [for] Only usable when an ally is acting. The action fails and the ally takes 1 damage. Tap this reacting anarch. The Slow Withering Cardtype: Event Gehenna. Do not replace until a vampire commits diablerie. Requires at least one other Gehenna card in play. Cards that require any superior Disciplines cost an additional blood. Any vampire who commits diablerie is immune to this effect until the next Gehenna card is played. Voter Captivation Cardtype: Action Modifier Discipline: Presence Only usable after resolving a successful referendum <called by this acting vampire>. [pre] The acting vampire gains X blood from the blood bank, where X is the number of votes by which the referendum passed. [PRE] As above, but move up to 2 of those blood counters to your pool instead of this vampire. Consignment to Duat Cardtype: Action Cost: 1 blood Discipline: Serpentis [ser] (D) Steal 1 blood or life from a ready minion. [SER] (D) Put this card on a ready minion. During this minion's untap phase, he or she burns 1 blood or life. If this vampire cannot burn a blood, he or she goes to torpor. Burn this card if this acting minion enters combat or leaves the ready region. A minion can have only one Consignment to Duat.

LSJ

On Apr 1, 9:25 am, floppyzedolfin <floppyzedol...@gmail.com> wrote: > Hi Scott, > > + Suppose A hunts. There is no block. Final Loosening is played. > Is the hunt successful? Yes. > Put in other words: Does Final Loosening reduces the blood gain to 1, > or does it changes it to a gain 1 blood effect? Reduce. > + Here's a weird situation (I'll try to be as precise as I can): > Slow Withering is in play. > 1. Someone plays Voter Captivation at superior. Terms are: gain 2 > blood and 2 pool. > 2. There is no Direct Intervention played. > 3. Voter Captivation is replaced. > 4. Voter Captivation is paid and its effects happen : the vampire > gains blood, the Methuselah gains pool. > 5. The vampire has gained blood. > > Now, my question is : Where in that list does Final Loosening get > played? Before 4. > I think it's some place between 3 and 4, but this is weird (I can't > think of any other card that would be played in there). Any "would gain" could be played in there. Foul Blood is played in a similar window in a hunt. > I think it > can't be played until 2 is over. Correct. > + Final Loosening doesn't say where the blood comes from. > Does that mean it comes from the same source it was about to be gained > from? (similarly to cards that give "additional blood" without > precision about the origin) > Suppose A plays inferior Consignment to Duat on B. There is no block. > Final Loosening is played. > Are both the blood counters awarded by Final Loosening taken *from B* > - ending up with B > losing *TWO* blood ? No. The acting vampire's gain (from whatever source) is reduced to 1. And the reacting anarch gains 1 (form the bank). [ quoted text not captured ]

Juggernaut1981

> Any "would gain" could be played in there. > > Foul Blood is played in a similar window in a hunt. It seems as though Foul Blood should be played in a separate window... FB would appear to only be playable at action resolution (when the action is actually successful), as opposed to FL which can be played at any point where the vampire is guaranteed to gain blood (when the action is known to not fail and result in blood gain). Foul Blood Type: Reaction Requires: Quietus Cost: 1 blood ***Only usable when a vampire successfully hunts.*** [qui] The acting vampire gains 1 less blood and takes 1 unpreventable damage. Tap this reacting vampire. [QUI] As above, but do not tap this reacting vampire.

LSJ

On Apr 1, 8:44 pm, Juggernaut1981 <brasscompo...@gmail.com> wrote: > > Any "would gain" could be played in there. > > > Foul Blood is played in a similar window in a hunt. > > It seems as though Foul Blood should be played in a separate window... > FB would appear to only be playable at action resolution (when the > action is actually successful), as opposed to FL which can be played > at any point where the vampire is guaranteed to gain blood (when the > action is known to not fail and result in blood gain). > Yes. It is played in a similar window. Namely: the window when you're about to resolve the effect in question, just before resolving the effect in question. [ quoted text not captured ]