Hello LSJ,
I feel like this question has been asked before, but I couldn't find
it. Let's say I corrupt Smudge, the Ignored from my prey, and now I
control him. Then I oust my prey. Then Smudge is burned.
1) Does Smudge end up in my ash heap, or removed from game (and
returned to my prey)?
2) If the answer to #1 is "removed from game," is Smudge actually
burned, then removed from game, or just directly removed from the game
instead?
I think #1 is Removed from Game, but I'm not sure why. This was the
closest I could find:
1.3. Golden Rule of Card Ownership
Your cards are never transferred to another player permanently as a
result of card play. At the end of the game, the cards you began the
game with are returned to you. If you are ousted before the end of the
game, any of your cards that other players control remain in play
until burned as normal.
Thanks,
Ira
[ quoted text not captured ]
IANLSJ, but it is my opinion that Smudge is controlled by you, and
would be placed in your ash heap until his state changes, or the game
ends. In either case, at the end of the game, or when you are ousted,
you return him to the original controller.
ira...@gmail.com wrote:
> Hello LSJ,
>
> I feel like this question has been asked before, but I couldn't find
> it. Let's say I corrupt Smudge, the Ignored from my prey, and now I
> control him. Then I oust my prey. Then Smudge is burned.
>
> 1) Does Smudge end up in my ash heap, or removed from game (and
> returned to my prey)?
> 2) If the answer to #1 is "removed from game," is Smudge actually
> burned, then removed from game, or just directly removed from the game
> instead?
>
> I think #1 is Removed from Game, but I'm not sure why.
Yes.
#2 is "burned", since you say that he was burned in the set up to the question.
He then goes to his owner's ash heap (as all burned cards do). And, since his
owner isn't in the game, his owner's ash heap is effectively a "removed from the
game" area.
For control returning to an ousted Methuselah (a more common question), see
http://groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/msg/898cc14273f74599
On Feb 2, 3:02 pm, LSJ <vtes...@white-wolf.com> wrote:
> ira...@gmail.com wrote:
> > Hello LSJ,
>
> > I feel like this question has been asked before, but I couldn't find
> > it. Let's say I corrupt Smudge, the Ignored from my prey, and now I
> > control him. Then I oust my prey. Then Smudge is burned.
>
> > 1) Does Smudge end up in my ash heap, or removed from game (and
> > returned to my prey)?
> > 2) If the answer to #1 is "removed from game," is Smudge actually
> > burned, then removed from game, or just directly removed from the game
> > instead?
>
> > I think #1 is Removed from Game, but I'm not sure why.
>
> Yes.
>
> #2 is "burned", since you say that he was burned in the set up to the question.
>
> He then goes to his owner's ash heap (as all burned cards do). And, since his
> owner isn't in the game, his owner's ash heap is effectively a "removed from the
> game" area.
Effectively. However, could the same smudge be Daemonic possessioned
if it was under my preds control when it was burnt?
[ quoted text not captured ]
No, since the reach of Daemonic Possession doesn't extend beyond the game.
(Indeed, no game effect extends beyond the game.)
>
> IANLSJ, but it is my opinion that Smudge is controlled by you, and
> would be placed in your ash heap until his state changes, or the game
> ends. In either case, at the end of the game, or when you are ousted,
> you return him to the original controller.
BURNED, not torporised, you silly person.
/returns to somnolence.
On Feb 2, 3:31 pm, LSJ <vtes...@white-wolf.com> wrote:
> (Indeed, no game effect extends beyond the game.)
I was wondering why my attempts at using obfuscate at work weren't
working.
[ quoted text not captured ]
See 9.1. Victory Points:
When a Methuselah runs out of pool counters, she is ousted from the
game. If you are ousted, all the cards you control are removed from
the game.[...]
Regards,
Hardy
[ quoted text not captured ]> question.- Zitierten Text ausblenden -
>
> - Zitierten Text anzeigen -
*Do not post from work*
*Do not post from work*
*Do not post from work*
Point taken. :-)
Hardy
[ quoted text not captured ]
At first I thought you were telling me, "do not post from work" and I
was wondering how you knew I was at work and if you were my boss...