[LSJ] Succubus Club Q.

If I have Succubus Club in play, and I choose myself as the Methusaleh to trade with; thus allowing me to freely move equipment, retainers and locations between my own minions? From the card text and rulings, it seems like I can do this.

CVV wrote: [ quoted text not captured ] The current text: " During your untap phase, you may tap this card to trade with a Methuselah who agrees to trade. You may trade pool and cards from your hand and cards you control. The trade cannot result in either Methuselah have fewer cards in hand than his or her hand size. Any additional terms can be established, but none are enforced by the rules." It specifically "either" Methuselah, so I'd think that you need two of them. Peter D Bakija pd...@lightlink.com http://www.lightlink.com/pdb6 "The gun is good! The penis is bad!" -Zardoz

Peter D Bakija wrote: > CVV wrote: >>If I have Succubus Club in play, and I choose myself as the Methusaleh >>to trade with; thus allowing me to freely move equipment, retainers and >>locations between my own minions? >> >>From the card text and rulings, it seems like I can do this. > > The current text: > > " During your untap phase, you may tap this card to trade with a Methuselah > who agrees to trade. You may trade pool and cards from your hand and cards > you control. The trade cannot result in either Methuselah have fewer cards > in hand than his or her hand size. Any additional terms can be established, > but none are enforced by the rules." > > It specifically "either" Methuselah, so I'd think that you need two of them. Even if one could trade with oneself, doing so offers no mechanism for moving equipment, retainers, or locations between oneself (since no change of control occurs). FWIW, trading with oneself is allowed. It results in tapping the Club (with no other tangible effect). -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. Links to V:TES news, rules, cards, utilities, and tournament calendar: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/