Violet Tremain - the machine

With the new Thaumaturgy strikes being hand strikes, Violet Tremain's ability might actually be worth something. Now, assume Violet has gotten superior CEL. She gets into combat, dodges, with an additional strike of Blood Fury for 2 (hand damage). No presses, combat ends. Can she wait for the opposing minion to lose a capacity before she plays Psyche! at superior (and then do it again in the resulting combat)? If not, will the opposing minion still lose a capacity at the end of the chain of combats even if she doesn't do 2+ hand damage in the Psyche'd combat?

Jozxyqk wrote: > > With the new Thaumaturgy strikes being hand strikes, Violet Tremain's > ability might actually be worth something. > > Now, assume Violet has gotten superior CEL. > She gets into combat, dodges, with an additional strike of Blood Fury > for 2 (hand damage). No presses, combat ends. > Can she wait for the opposing minion to lose a capacity before she > plays Psyche! at superior (and then do it again in the resulting combat)? Yes. The opposing minion's loss of capacity is not optional. It occurs at the end of combat whether Psyche! is played or not. See also hand size reduction/restoration from Raptors and card replacement from "Do Not Replace Until After Combat" cards. > If not, will the opposing minion still lose a capacity at the end of the > chain of combats even if she doesn't do 2+ hand damage in the Psyche'd combat? -- LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc. Links to V:TES news, rules, cards, utilities, and tournament calendar: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

[ quoted text not captured ] since combat ends at some point (the condition for playing psyche!), the opposing vampire's capacity is reduced by one, yes. When combat starts again, the opposing vampire is 1 capacity below. Is it so useful ? i guess not... Maybe if you play with attonments, then your attoned small vapires can now block the opposing vampire without tapping... If you playwith ventrues, maybe you can buy the opposing vampire providing you lower his capacity very low... anyway i doubt it's of any use. reyda

> Yes. > The opposing minion's loss of capacity is not optional. It occurs at the end > of combat whether Psyche! is played or not. > See also hand size reduction/restoration from Raptors and card replacement > from "Do Not Replace Until After Combat" cards. Oh, a followup question: If a vampire whose capacity was lowered by Violet is then Banished, does its controller need to only influence it out to its reduced capacity? Or to its full capacity? Is it at full capacity when it comes back out?

[ quoted text not captured ] Reduced capacity. [ quoted text not captured ]

LSJ wrote: > > Jozxyqk wrote: > > > > > Yes. > > > The opposing minion's loss of capacity is not optional. It occurs at the end > > > of combat whether Psyche! is played or not. > > > See also hand size reduction/restoration from Raptors and card replacement > > > from "Do Not Replace Until After Combat" cards. > > > > Oh, a followup question: > > > > If a vampire whose capacity was lowered by Violet is then Banished, does its > > controller need to only influence it out to its reduced capacity? Or to its > > full capacity? Is it at full capacity when it comes back out? > > Reduced capacity. > I had this come up a few months ago at Watford (although not in the tourney). If a vampire is banished with a master discipline card (or sanguine instruction), does he need to be filled up to orginal capacity or new larger capacity (it would have made a large difference to the result in the game for me). The guy who's vamp was banished said that all cards on the vamp are ignored until it comes back into play. Is that correct? If so, how does a vamp having being lowered by Violet Tremain be any different? Surely if she reduces the capacity, that is forgotten whilst it is uncontrolled until it becomes controlled again (therefore the blood rolls off into the bank). -- Andy "Slytherin" Brown VEKN Setite Ruler of Cambridge SET awakens, watch out all non-believers

Andy Brown wrote: > > LSJ wrote: > > > > Jozxyqk wrote: > > > > > > > Yes. > > > > The opposing minion's loss of capacity is not optional. It occurs at the end > > > > of combat whether Psyche! is played or not. > > > > See also hand size reduction/restoration from Raptors and card replacement > > > > from "Do Not Replace Until After Combat" cards. > > > > > > Oh, a followup question: > > > > > > If a vampire whose capacity was lowered by Violet is then Banished, does its > > > controller need to only influence it out to its reduced capacity? Or to its > > > full capacity? Is it at full capacity when it comes back out? > > > > Reduced capacity. > > > > I had this come up a few months ago at Watford (although not in the > tourney). If a vampire is banished with a master discipline card > (or sanguine instruction), does he need to be filled up to orginal > capacity or new larger capacity (it would have made a large difference > to the result in the game for me). The guy who's vamp was banished > said that all cards on the vamp are ignored until it comes > back into play. > > Is that correct? Yes. > If so, how does a vamp having being lowered by Violet Tremain > be any different? No card. > Surely if she reduces the capacity, that is forgotten whilst > it is uncontrolled until it becomes controlled again (therefore > the blood rolls off into the bank). No. [ quoted text not captured ]