In article <537vql$9...@tron.sci.fi>, Marko Saari <gu...@sci.fi> wrote:
>1. Can I play Rötschreck against Pulled Fangs?
I'd say yes; as far as I know, however, the Rules Team's agin it.
A Tom Wylie ruling says the big R must be played when strikes are
declared, thereby disallowing its use at the time it's legal to
pull a fang.
>2. Can I play multiple Pulled Fangs at the same time (causing more
> aggravated damage) ?
Not as far as I know; once the first one resolves (as soon as it's played),
your target's in torpor and there is no opportunity to play another.
>3. Do I get manouver from Bum`s Rush if targeted minion blocks it?
Nope; BR offers the choice of remaining untapped or tapping to deny the
maneuver -- assuming the Rusher has no stealth, mind.
>4. according official tournament rules. IV Special Floor Rules. 1. Repeat
> actions rule: minions action is blocked and she untaps. Can she perform
> same action again in the same round?
This is still awaiting Shawn's pleasure -- where *is* that smooth
talking Irishman?
>5. Can I use damage preventation cards outside of combat? ie. Can vampire
> prevent damage from Carnas the Imp with Skin of Rock (or with Flak
> Jacket)?
Nay not, barring specific card errata, such as Rutor's Hand at superior.
gomi
--
'spend a day and a half dead and the lettuce runs amok.'
-babs woods
I have some questions:
1. Can I play Rötschreck against Pulled Fangs?
2. Can I play multiple Pulled Fangs at the same time (causing more
aggravated damage) ?
3. Do I get manouver from Bum`s Rush if targeted minion blocks it?
4. according official tournament rules. IV Special Floor Rules. 1. Repeat
actions rule: minions action is blocked and she untaps. Can she perform
same action again in the same round?
5. Can I use damage preventation cards outside of combat? ie. Can vampire
prevent damage from Carnas the Imp with Skin of Rock (or with Flak
Jacket)?
---Marko---
Gomi no Sensei wrote:
>
> In article <537vql$9...@tron.sci.fi>, Marko Saari <gu...@sci.fi> wrote:
(snip)
> >3. Do I get manouver from Bum`s Rush if targeted minion blocks it?
>> Nope; BR offers the choice of remaining untapped or tapping to deny the
> maneuver -- assuming the Rusher has no stealth, mind.
Does this mean that whenever I enter combat with someone who isn't
choosing to block (Bum's Rush, Haven Uncovered, etc) they remain
untapped after combat? Are they only tapped as a result of blocking?
--
---------------------------------------------------------------------
pheersum inhabits the mortal shell of eric schultheis. one
channels mailto://phee...@sb.net. pheersum manifests at
http://www.sb.net/pheersum/Pheerpage.htm . the oracle speaks--"in theory
there is no difference between theory & practice, but in practice..."
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Pheersum <phee...@sb.net> writes:
>Gomi no Sensei wrote:>>
>> In article <537vql$9...@tron.sci.fi>, Marko Saari <gu...@sci.fi> wrote:> (snip)>> >3. Do I get manouver from Bum`s Rush if targeted minion blocks it?
>>
>> Nope; BR offers the choice of remaining untapped or tapping to deny the
>> maneuver -- assuming the Rusher has no stealth, mind.>Does this mean that whenever I enter combat with someone who isn't
>choosing to block (Bum's Rush, Haven Uncovered, etc) they remain
>untapped after combat? Are they only tapped as a result of blocking?
Yes - only two things will tap a minion, outside of card text explicitly
stating that a minion is to be tapped. Those two things are:
acting (attempting an action)
blocking (successfully blocking an action)
--
L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.sc.edu) | One single fact can ruin a
http://www.math.sc.edu/cgi-bin/sjohnson/home | perfectly good argument.
Graphics Specialist and V:tES Rulemonger. |
L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.scarolina.edu) wrote:
: Yes - only two things will tap a minion, outside of card text explicitly: stating that a minion is to be tapped. Those two things are:: acting (attempting an action)
: blocking (successfully blocking an action)
By my knowledge (in Jyhad rules) you are also tapped as result of going
into combat. Perhaps I missed some ruling, but that how my group plays it.
And that's how we will continue to play it, btw.
--
//The Doctor.
+-------------------------------------------------------------------+
| GCS -d+ H++>+++ s:++>+:+ g+ p2 !au a->+++ w++ v+(---) |
| C+++>+ UHL++ P?>+ L+ !3 E N++ K- W(---) !M !V po+ |
| Y t(+) 5>+ !j R+ G++@ tv+(++) b+>++ D+ B? e+ u+** |
| h+* f? !r--- n---- !y+ |
+-------------------------------------------------------------------+
do...@fn3.freenet.tlh.fl.us (Danny Oscar Kip) writes:
>L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.scarolina.edu) wrote:>: Yes - only two things will tap a minion, outside of card text explicitly
>: stating that a minion is to be tapped. Those two things are:>: acting (attempting an action)
>: blocking (successfully blocking an action)>By my knowledge (in Jyhad rules) you are also tapped as result of going
>into combat. Perhaps I missed some ruling, but that how my group plays it.
There are no references in either the original Jyhad rulebook, the
"corrected" Jyhad rulebook, any Rules Team Rulings, nor the VtES rulebook
(with errata to same) that support that position.
>And that's how we will continue to play it, btw.
That's just fine. We have a list of house rules as well.
--
L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.sc.edu) | Virtue is the failure to
http://www.math.sc.edu/cgi-bin/sjohnson/home | achieve vice.
[ quoted text not captured ]
>: acting (attempting an action)
>: blocking (successfully blocking an action)
So you don't tap to use some reaction cards? (Say like Telepathic Counter?)
Sorrow
--
I don't want to be alone | I hurt, therefore I am
anymore |--------------------------------
I don't want to be anyone | "What are you looking at...?
anymore | you never seen anyone try to
I don't need a reason to kill myself | commit suicide before?" - Anon
------------------------------------------------------------------------
On 10 Oct 1996, Sorrow wrote:
> >: acting (attempting an action)
> >: blocking (successfully blocking an action)
>
> So you don't tap to use some reaction cards? (Say like Telepathic Counter?)
No you don't tap. You don't tap when someone is attacking you. You only
tap if you take an action, block an action, someone uses the Louvre with
Prince of Paris, someone misdirects you, or someother ones I can't think
of at this time.
[ quoted text not captured ]
Danny Oscar Kip wrote:
>
> L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.scarolina.edu) wrote:
>
> : Yes - only two things will tap a minion, outside of card text explicitly
> : stating that a minion is to be tapped. Those two things are:
>> : acting (attempting an action)
> : blocking (successfully blocking an action)
>> By my knowledge (in Jyhad rules) you are also tapped as result of going
> into combat. Perhaps I missed some ruling, but that how my group plays it.> And that's how we will continue to play it, btw.
This returns to a question I posted that has probably been answered
before. If blocking, not combat taps the vamp, then if my opponent says,
"Why yes, I won't block that Bum's Rush (Haven Uncovered, etc.) does
that mean they remain untapped after combat?
--
---------------------------------------------------------------------
pheersum inhabits the mortal shell of eric schultheis. one
channels mailto://phee...@sb.net. pheersum manifests at
http://www.sb.net/pheersum/Pheerpage.htm . nature says,"go ahead, have
as many babies as you want. something will eat them."
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Pheersum <phee...@sb.net> writes:
>> L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.scarolina.edu) wrote:
>>
>> : Yes - only two things will tap a minion, outside of card text explicitly
>> : stating that a minion is to be tapped. Those two things are:
>>
>> : acting (attempting an action)
>> : blocking (successfully blocking an action)>This returns to a question I posted that has probably been answered>before. If blocking, not combat taps the vamp, then if my opponent says,
>"Why yes, I won't block that Bum's Rush (Haven Uncovered, etc.) does
>that mean they remain untapped after combat?
That's exactly what that means. If you don't act and don't block, then
you don't tap. Explicit card text may allow other tap effects/options,
but this is the default behavoir.
Combat never results in a tap. Some cards (Brujah Frenzy) will cause
a combat and a tapping effects, and almost all blocks (which are tapping
effects) will cause combat, but combat itself doesn't tap anything.
[ quoted text not captured ]
>This returns to a question I posted that has probably been answered
>before. If blocking, not combat taps the vamp, then if my opponent says,
>"Why yes, I won't block that Bum's Rush (Haven Uncovered, etc.) does
>that mean they remain untapped after combat?
From what I understand, yes. However, if it is a Bum's Rush and you block,
they do not get the maneuver permitted by the Rush. So I guess you'd have to
decide which you want more in that case.
[ quoted text not captured ]
Sorrow (cbo...@apdi.net) wrote:
: >This returns to a question I posted that has probably been answered: >before. If blocking, not combat taps the vamp, then if my opponent says,
: >"Why yes, I won't block that Bum's Rush (Haven Uncovered, etc.) does
: >that mean they remain untapped after combat?: From what I understand, yes. However, if it is a Bum's Rush and you block,
: they do not get the maneuver permitted by the Rush.
Not to mention the fact that the acting vamp will have to fight the minion
*you* want him to fight (the blocking minion) instead getting to fight the
minion *he* wanted to fight (the target of the Rush).
: So I guess you'd have to: decide which you want more in that case.
Chris Mattern
Pheersum <phee...@sb.net> wrote:
>Danny Oscar Kip wrote:>>
>> L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.scarolina.edu) wrote:
>>
>> : Yes - only two things will tap a minion, outside of card text explicitly
>> : stating that a minion is to be tapped. Those two things are:
>>
>> : acting (attempting an action)
>> : blocking (successfully blocking an action)
>>>> By my knowledge (in Jyhad rules) you are also tapped as result of going
>> into combat. Perhaps I missed some ruling, but that how my group plays it.
>> And that's how we will continue to play it, btw.>This returns to a question I posted that has probably been answered>before. If blocking, not combat taps the vamp, then if my opponent says,
>"Why yes, I won't block that Bum's Rush (Haven Uncovered, etc.) does
>that mean they remain untapped after combat?
You got it. Of course, not blocking means that the opponent gets the
free maneuver. Blocking denies them the maneuver, but your vampire is
tapped. It's a tradeoff.
gnfnrf