contesting question...

situatation: 2 minions carrying the same unique piece of equipment, their methuselahs start contesting the equipment. 1 of the minions gets burned. can that minons controler still keep up the contesting? I would say yes, since the contested cards are considerd out of game. Greetz, Oortje

Oortje wrote: [ quoted text not captured ] No. A contested card on a minion who is burned is itself burned. http://groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/msg/723875f3607837d8 -- That is my story, be it bitter or be it sweet. Keep a little and let a little come back to me. LSJ (vtesr...@TRAPwhite-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep (remove spam trap to reply) http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

LSJ wrote: > Oortje wrote: > > > situatation: > > 2 minions carrying the same unique piece of equipment, their > > methuselahs start contesting the equipment. > > 1 of the minions gets burned. can that minons controler still keep up > > the contesting? > > I would say yes, since the contested cards are considerd out of game. > > No. A contested card on a minion who is burned is itself burned. > http://groups.google.com/group/rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad/msg/723875f3607837d8 How about the following situation: Smudge is controlled by Player A Sandra is controlled by Player B Smudge and Sandra both equip with the Eye of Hazimel, so Players A and B are contesting the Eye. Now Player C takes permanent control of Sandra (via Form of Corruption, Hostile Takeover, etc.). What happens to the contestation?

Halcyan 2 wrote: > How about the following situation: > > Smudge is controlled by Player A > Sandra is controlled by Player B > > Smudge and Sandra both equip with the Eye of Hazimel, so Players A and > B are contesting the Eye. > > Now Player C takes permanent control of Sandra (via Form of Corruption, > Hostile Takeover, etc.). What happens to the contestation? It continues as normal. A and C are contesting the Eye (since it is a minion card). [ quoted text not captured ]

Any effect that goes looking for an out-of-play card will not find it. Quote of LSJ (threat about "Kerrie" vs burn effect ofbloody talon) 4.1 of rulebook... For the duration of the contest, all copies of the contested card are turned face down and are out of play. Isn't this contradictory? Greetz, Oortje

If a different player plays a minion card that is currently being contested by two other players will that player now also have to pay for contestation? [ quoted text not captured ]

serge wrote: > If a different player plays a minion card that is currently being > contested by two other players will that player now also have to pay > for contestation? Yes. Contested cards are considered out of play except for purposes of contesting other copies.