[Q] Obedience

Short question that must already have been dealt with: Can Obedience be used by a tapped vampire. ? This situation can occur when a tapped vampire is the target of a Bum's Rush. In other words, does the sentence "Can only be used in combat" supersedes the general rule "Tapped vampire cannot play reaction cards" ? I believe not. Could someone confirm ? == Herve Guillemet

[ quoted text not captured ] Yes, obedience is can be used in a sitch where the reacting vampire is tapped, but it doesn't untap you. -Zach

Herve Guillemet (guil...@marsouin.imed.jussieu.fr) wrote: : Short question that must already have been dealt with: : : Can Obedience be used by a tapped vampire. ? : This situation can occur when a tapped vampire is the target of a : Bum's Rush. Hurm. Obedience says to use as entering combat with an acting vampire. Since this usually happes due to a block, the vamp playing obedience should already be tapped. Hence, I don't see any trouble with using it in the situation you described. Joe -- +--------------...@dimensional.com------------------------+ | "Look what I had to overcome from my last life / | | I think I'll write a book" | +-----"I have no fear of falling / but I hate hitting the ground"-----+

guil...@marsouin.imed.jussieu.fr (Herve Guillemet) wrote: >Short question that must already have been dealt with: >Can Obedience be used by a tapped vampire. ? >This situation can occur when a tapped vampire is the target of a >Bum's Rush. >In other words, does the sentence "Can only be used in combat" supersedes >the general rule "Tapped vampire cannot play reaction cards" ? >I believe not. Could someone confirm ? > == Herve Guillemet No the tapped vamp could play combat cards, including precombat ones like weather control or that new DS dominate one but not a reaction card. Rory IMHO

guil...@marsouin.imed.jussieu.fr (Herve Guillemet) writes: >Short question that must already have been dealt with: >Can Obedience be used by a tapped vampire. ? >This situation can occur when a tapped vampire is the target of a >Bum's Rush. >In other words, does the sentence "Can only be used in combat" supersedes >the general rule "Tapped vampire cannot play reaction cards" ? >I believe not. Could someone confirm ? True, it does not. Only untapped vampires may play reaction cards. The restrictions are cumulative: Only untapped vampires about to enter combat with younger acting vampires can play Obedience. -- L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.sc.edu) | DejaFu - http://www.math.sc.edu/~sjohnson | The feeling that things have Graphics Specialist and V:tES Rulemonger. | been this FU'ed before.