rec.games.trading-cards.jyhad

Dowa No Confidence Require an Anarch?

5 messages from 3 participants · 10 August 2008 – 12 August 2008
original thread on Google Groups

Ben Swainbank

Is No Confidence considered a card that requires an anarch for use (untapping and anarch) with Powerbase: Los Angeles? No Confidence Play after resolving a successful action that requires an anarch. Put this card on a titled non-anarch vampire controlled by the target of the action (or by your predator or prey if the action is undirected). A vampire with two No Confidence cards loses the benefit of his or her title. Burn this card if this acting vampire leaves the ready region. The text implies that it is anarch only. But it doesn't say "requires an anarch". -Ben Swainbank

LSJ

Ben Swainbank wrote: > Is No Confidence considered a card that requires an anarch for use > (untapping and anarch) with Powerbase: Los Angeles? Yes. [ quoted text not captured ]

floppyzedolfin

Can Grey Thorne play No Confidence on a Keystone Kine action ? The lack of explicit "requires a ready anarch" on the cards makes me think he can, but that particular lack would've make me think No Confidence was not a card that requires an anarch for use with Powerbase: Los Angeles. [ quoted text not captured ]

LSJ

floppyzedolfin wrote: > Can Grey Thorne play No Confidence on a Keystone Kine action ? > The lack of explicit "requires a ready anarch" on the cards makes me > think he can, but that particular lack would've make me think No > Confidence was not a card that requires an anarch for use with > Powerbase: Los Angeles. Only anarchs can play No Confidence. Which means No Confidence requires anarch. Which would mean Grey Thorne could play it as an anarch if his text was just "may play cards that require anarch as an anarch". But instead he's got that pesky card text about only playing cards that require cel or pot as an anarch. And No Confidence is not such a card. [ quoted text not captured ]

LSJ

LSJ wrote: > floppyzedolfin wrote: >> Can Grey Thorne play No Confidence on a Keystone Kine action ? >> The lack of explicit "requires a ready anarch" on the cards makes me >> think he can, but that particular lack would've make me think No >> Confidence was not a card that requires an anarch for use with >> Powerbase: Los Angeles. > > Only anarchs can play No Confidence. Which means No Confidence requires > anarch. Which would mean Grey Thorne could play it as an anarch if his > text was just "may play cards that require anarch as an anarch". > > But instead he's got that pesky card text about only playing cards that > require cel or pot as an anarch. And No Confidence is not such a card. I'm a bit slow this morning. I get it now. Quite right, floppy. Grey Thorne can play Keystone Kine at cel as an anarch. And then, after resolving that action (that requires anarch) successfully, he can play No Confidence. Which means No Confidence is not a card that requires an anarch, since Grey Thorne is not an anarch. So that REVERSES the earlier ruling that No Confidence could be a "card that requires anarch" for purposes of Powerbase: Los Angeles. Nice work, floppy.